Sections

Dissecting Final Fantasy VII, Part 6 -- Can Final Fantasy VII's Premise Pass Muster in a Modern Remake?

DESIGN IN ACTION | What happens when the good guys are kinda... bad?

Analysis by Jeremy Parish, .

Design in Action is a weekly column by Retronauts co-host Jeremy Parish that explores games both new and classic, analyzing the way their various moving parts work together to make them great. Currently: Final Fantasy VII has just turned 20 years old, and it's time to examine how the series' standards shaped a medium-changing masterpiece.

Final Fantasy VII begins with one of the most exciting, high-tempo prologue sequences ever to appear in any video game. It's as important, and speaks to the developers' objectives with the game ahead, every bit as much as Half-Life's introductory tram ride did.

The bombing mission and its lead-in introduces players to Cloud Strife, his newfound comrades, the city of Midgar, and the Shinra Corporation; it ends in a meet-cute between the hero and his soon-to-be love interest, Aerith Gainsborough. It's a powerful initiation into a sprawling adventure, and it sets up everything that players can expect from the following 40 hours of the journey ahead: The characters, the world, the systems, and the dazzling presentation. It remains a frequently discussed moment in video game history for good reason. It had profound impact on everyone who played it in 1997, and it holds up remarkably well even now.

Less commonly discussed, however, is the aftermath of that opening sequence. The AVALANCHE team separates in order to disappear into the crowd and evade Shinra security, and the player follows Cloud as he wanders through the carnage his actions have wrought. Although it's largely antiseptic — there's no literal carnage — the game leaves little doubt that the reactor explosion resulted in chaos, panic, and destruction beyond just the power plant that was the group's target. Admittedly, it doesn't seem too extreme in its collateral damage — after all, Aerith still has time to sell Cloud a flower — but nevertheless, that scene's a little difficult to stomach 20 years later. It's all a bit too real.

Final Fantasy VII officially launched in the U.S. on Sept. 7, 1997. Exactly four years and four days later, the U.S. suffered the deadliest ever terrorist attack ever to take place on American soil, and quite possibly the most symbolic to have ever taken place in the world. Everyone reacted to the Sept. 11 attacks in their own way. For some, the event hardened their hearts and became a wake-up call to go to battle against foreign peoples or unfamiliar ideologies. For me, it created a sense of empathy: A realization of how terrifying and deadly terrorism truly is.

Like most American people — sheltered, comfortable, and relatively wealthy compared to the rest of the world — the idea of terrorism had always existed in my mind in the abstract before Sept. 11, 2001. Terrorism was something that happened far away, to other people, mentioned on television for a few seconds before the news anchor switched gears to the other bad news of the day. But suddenly, terrorism happened on a massive scale in a place I knew; if I'd had a stronger resume at the time, it could have affected me directly — I had applied for a job with a company based in the WTC a few months before that. A decade later, I married a woman whose father lost most of his coworkers in the WTC and only avoided being killed himself because he happened to miss his train that morning.

But it's not these near-misses that stick with me when I think back on that disaster. It's the endless news coverage that unfolded over the following days: The panicked crowd reactions, the suffocating clouds of debris, the horrifying sight of people leaping from 100 stories high to meet a quick end rather than painfully burning to death. Those memories linger, and they fill me with sadness and sympathy for new victims of terrorism any time I hear of attacks in far-off places like Paris or Gaza or Jakarta, regardless of those people's nationality or beliefs. And they make it hard to find much place for the concept of terrorism as past of escapist entertainment.

Dissecting Final Fantasy VII, Part 2: How Materia Completed a Role-play Reversal

DESIGN IN ACTION | The ultimate evolution of Final Fantasy's game design philosophy amounted to an inversion of RPG tradition.

Dissecting Final Fantasy VII, Part 3: How a "Rotting Pizza" Defined the Plight of Final Fantasy VII's World

DESIGN IN ACTION | The oppressive megalopolis at the heart of a classic RPG.

In the abstract, Final Fantasy VII's premise of a rag-tag group of rebels fighting against an evil empire was little different than countless other stories that had come before it. Many other games had already used a similar narrative thread, including Final Fantasy VI (where the rebels were called Returners) and even Final Fantasy II, way back in the 8-bit days (where the protagonists didn't belong to a formal organization but nevertheless fought the power). Final Fantasy owes a tremendous debt to Star Wars, of course, wherein the Rebel Alliance waged war against the corrupt and murderous Galactic Empire... and Star Wars would never have existed without Akira Kurosawa's The Hidden Fortress, which itself involves a rebellious uprising of prisoners of war. The idea of the little guy fighting against overwhelming odds — the crux of FFVII's narrative — stretches at least as far back as the Old Testament book of 1st Samuel. It makes for a more interesting and engaging premise than the big guy crushing the little guy.

Where FFVII stands apart from those other works is in its presentation. Unlike the space fantasy of Star Wars with its hyperspace combat and planet-destroying weapons, unlike even the steampunk world of FFVI with its airships and demihuman monsters, FFVII takes place in a world that works not too dissimilarly to our own. Shinra is the "evil empire," yes, but it's a corporation that functions as the hub for a sprawling metropolis. Shinra provides Midgar with electricity. The protagonists get about the city by way of a modern metro subway line, hang out in a goofy-looking playground, meet up in a dive bar, follow the developing story line by watching television news broadcasts, ascend a skyscraper, and escape from the city by way of a vintage motorcycle and pickup truck. Later, you can hang out in a beach villa, take a rocket on a low-orbit space trip, and kill time at a garish amusement park. FFVII may not be the real world, but it was as convincing and authentic as any we'd ever seen in an RPG outside of something like the Shin Megami Tensei games, which take place in Tokyo.

Which means that while AVALANCHE may be another group of ragtag rebels fighting for justice, they also "read" much more clearly as terrorists as we know them in the real world. When Cloud struts through streets full of people running in blind panic from a massive explosion, it resonates just a little too much for comfort. It doesn't help that you later discover that AVALANCHE was born in a desert-like region as a response to Shinra's exploitation of its natural resources, and to the corporation's cold-blooded treatment of the people in that area — an origin story that bears too much similarity to real-world terrorist organizations for comfort.

Dissecting Final Fantasy VII, Part 4: Sephiroth Skewered Our Expectations for RPG Villains... and Our Girlfriend, Too

DESIGN IN ACTION | Final Fantasy VII's big bad wasn't all that big, but he was definitely bad.

Dissecting Final Fantasy VII, Part 5 -- An RPG Gets Existential With Its Central Question: "Who Am I?"

DESIGN IN ACTION | How an RPG put a new spin on a classic literary concept.

I don't think FFVII's emphasis on terrorism was accidental. Less than two years prior to the game's debut in Japan — which is to say, right at the outset of its development cycle — Japan suffered a devastating terrorist strike during the Aum Shinrikyo incident. In that attack, a doomsday cult unleashed sarin gas on a Tokyo subway, which caused a few fatalities and injured or temporarily blinded thousands. Given the severity of the attack and the fact that it took place in a subway station less than two miles from Squaresoft's headquarters at the time, it's hard to imagine that the Aum Shinrikyo incident wasn't at least at the back of scenario writer Kazushige Nojima's mind as he penned the game's script.

To FFVII's credit, it doesn't treat AVALANCHE's actions as trivial. Shinra immediately declares most-wanted status for the group, and its members express remorse for the collateral damage they cause. AVALANCHE member Jessie, whose task it was to design the group's bombs, seems mystified by the unexpected power of her bombs. Still, despite some shades of grey, there's never any doubt that AVALANCHE is ultimately right to stand up to Shinra: The corporation has no qualms about leeching the planet of its life in their pursuit of profits. And it doesn't take too long for Shinra's leaders to use AVALANCHE's actions as pretext for launching a false-flag operation that results in the deaths of untold numbers of Midgar citizens with the blame laid at the terrorists' feet: An indulgence of the worst and most wild-eyed kind of real-world conspiracy theory nonsense.

Still, the world — and the concept of terrorism — has changed radically in the past 20 years. While it certainly existed in 1997, its reach and severity have spread across the globe. It's no longer an abstract thing that only happens in war-torn regions covered by foreign correspondents on the evening news. It happens here, too, and not just in massive symbolic acts of murder. It happens almost daily in elementary schools and on random city streets. We always like to root for the underdog, but it's hard to find much enthusiasm for their actions when countless innocent lives are lost as collateral damage.

The original FFVII script almost — almost! — managed to engage with its protagonists' less-than-heroic actions in a meaningful way. The question now is, will the game's upcoming remake make good on that potential? Or will the nature of AVALANCHE be changed altogether? It's hard to imagine how FFVII could work without Cloud and his allies attempting to destroy Shinra from within, but it's also hard to imagine rooting for the "good guys" if the script takes a casual view of acts of rebellion that remind us of the worst headlines we see every day. There's a chance for Square Enix to say something meaningful with this game, to probe the morality of antiheroism in the fashion of premium television series like Breaking Bad or Hannibal. But will they? Questioning the nature of its heroes' actions may not be the most obvious challenge the FFVII remake faces, but it could prove to be the most difficult.

Next time: The column shifts gears 10 years forward to a more recent RPG.

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Comments 12

  • Avatar for SatelliteOfLove #1 SatelliteOfLove 5 months ago
    And this itself happened not long after the OKC Bombing too.

    We're just going to have these cataclysmic pivots on the American psyche every ~8 years I guess.

    I do agree this redo is going to require some differing viewpoints to go along with that differing combat mechanics, yeah.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for jeremy.parish #2 jeremy.parish 5 months ago
    @nimzy What a great response. Thanks for that.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for pdubb #3 pdubb 5 months ago
    To piggy back off@nimsy, maybe FF7 is more relatable in 2017 than I realized. As he pointed out, Barret and the coal miners feel left behind, but also too is rocket town which is a victim of failed promises and dreams. It makes sense that large portions of the general population ignore the damage being done to the planet in hopes of returning to better times. It makes sense that they believe Shinra will make their world great again despite all evidence showing otherwise.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for KaiserWarrior #4 KaiserWarrior 5 months ago
    @pdubb Yeah, when you look back on it, FF7 has a VERY prominent backdrop of depressed relics of the old industries dealing with being replaced by more modern enterprise. Even, to a somewhat lesser extent, Wutai -- a once-great nation reduced to little more than a tourist trap, an amusement for those that conquered them militarily and, ultimately, economically. Of course, the entire point of Wutai is that it's a stand-in for Japan itself.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for brionfoulke91 #5 brionfoulke91 5 months ago
    FF7 proves this to me: any story can seem amazing if the soundtrack is good enough. FF7's story has some problems, but it's got good memorable characters and it's generally entertaining. And it's really more than the sum of parts, and the glue (that many people still continue to overlook) is that killer soundtrack.

    So yeah, I think a remake can work just as well today.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for MarsDragon #6 MarsDragon 5 months ago
    They can jazz up the moral to fit in better with modern sensibilities. Instead of playing as AVALANCHE, you play as the Turks and go around kidnapping and murdering people in the name of corporate profits.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Nuclear-Vomit #7 Nuclear-Vomit 5 months ago
    In the remake.... AVALANCHE.. will go on social media and publicly shame Shinra?

    We still need AVALANCHE to be terrorists and their actions should to be even more heart wrenching, brutal, and relevant. I'm talking about hostage taking and video tapes of executions sent to media. Should they model their actions from the disgusting ISIS? Or maybe it would make the game too political?

    And while they fight each other, the real enemy, Sepiroth threatens to kill everything. So even Shinra Teams up with AVALANCHE to stop this, if I remember correctly.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for mattb0527 #8 mattb0527 5 months ago
    See, Jeremy goes and writes something meaningful and thoughtful and insightful about how the remake needs to be able to adjust its narrative to match modern sensibilities...and here I was discussing with a friend last night about how I don't think a scene like the Honeybee Manor will be able to translate in hyper-realistic HD graphics.

    The theme of rag-tag group of youths fighting against an entrenched power structure is nothing new in RPGs but FFVII differentiated itself by truly defining your characters actions in the context of terrorism. Something that my 7th grade brain completely glossed over at the time.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Vonlenska #9 Vonlenska 5 months ago
    This is a fantastic article (and series) and I'm really enjoying the discussion. FFVII is a much more substantial game than most remember it as. I'm not really optimistic that the political and personal facets of the game will make much of a translation into the remake, even though a lot of them are arguably more relevant to the game's audiences today than they were in 1997.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Bklyn2LA #10 Bklyn2LA 5 months ago
    GREAT article! It dawned on me that Avalanche was an Eco-Terror group years after I played the game, as I was too young to understand the severity of the implications the game was making. However, I never worried about censorship of the core message of the story until reading this article. Truth is, I don't know if FFVII CAN be done in our times. Would Trump tweet out that this game glorifies Terror? Who knows. However, if Square-Enix stays true to the core story with all of its steep moral implications and grey areas, I will absolutely be purchasing the remake on DAY ONE.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for UnskippableCutscene #11 UnskippableCutscene 5 months ago
    We're also in an age where everything with a USB port wnd a data connection is an attack vector, so they could probably replace "bombs" with "let's upload the virus to the computer" and achieve the desired effects without the awkward aftertaste.

    The plate drop honestly, after seeing Rogue One received so well, things could work as-is. The Midgar plate event is similar to an Imperial middle manager turning the friggin' Death Star on an allied city just to wipe out some high ranking rebels hiding within.

    One thing they could do is change it so the event isn't at the hand of someone who later becomes a player favorite like Reno (who hops down to push the button and fight you) but an unredeemed psycho like Heidegger. If the Turks show up just to kidnap Aerith but are as shocked as anyone else by the plate collapse... It would 'sell' the moment a bit more and their eventual "this place is undone, I quit" attitude would make more sense.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for The-Challenger #12 The-Challenger 14 days ago
    I just want a 1-1 remake. Why sanitize the game at this point. I hope they leave the story leave as. But I know SQE will alter this game to the point that the only recognizable aspect will be the characters.
    Sign in to Reply

Comments

Close