Pikmin 3 Review

Like an army of its tiny, titular, vegetable minions, Pikmin 3 is a tasty treat that offers just enough crunch to properly satisfy.

Review by Jeremy Parish, .

Primary Reviewer Jeremy Parish

Pikmin 3 dabbles in a popular narrative device common in sequels: The story revolves around new protagonists, but the shadow of the old hero looms long over the proceedings. As with Don Corleone in The Godfather Part II or Jason Bourne in The Bourne Legacy, this isn't the story of Captain Olimar... but he's always there, just off-camera.

Thankfully, his replacements manage to come across as likable, memorable characters of their own rather than empty ciphers chasing the shadow of a better lead (in other words, Pikmin 3 hews closer to The Godfather Part II than The Bourne Legacy). As new leads Alph, Brittany, and Charlie unravel the mystery behind the enigmatic traces Olimar has left behind on Planet PNF-404, they reveal their personalities through both journal entries and spoken conversations. Admittedly, those personalities are painted in broad, archetypal strokes, yet you can't help but like them -- especially Brittany, who views the world with a wry, intellectual dispassion betrayed only by her enthusiasm for fruit juice and cuteness.

Pikmin 3
Pikmin 3 revolves around enslaving primitive indigenous peoples, depopulating wild animal species, and using slave labor to strip-mine this savage land of its natural resources. A typical feel-good Nintendo game, in other words.

The protagonists hail from planet Koppai, not Hocotate like Olimar and his partners, which allows Pikmin 3 to preserve the outsider's perspective that suffused the original game. The Koppaian explorers arrive as newcomers to PNF-404, a troublingly desolate version of Earth that manages to be at once post-apocalyptic and pangaean, which means they go through the process of learning the ropes of controlling the tiny creatures called pikmin that thrive in our ruined world from step one. Similarly, they regard the fruit that serves as the game's core collectible with the same naïve freshness with which Olimar described the "treasures" he scavenged in Pikmin 2. I would never have called an Italian eggplant a "dapper blob," but you know, it does kind of look like a little fat guy wearing a hat.

The lead trio serve a much more essential purpose in the game than simply casting a new perspective on things, though. They help bring Pikmin 3 closer to becoming a "true" real-time strategy game than the series has ever come before. By allowing players to change their focus between the three different Koppaians, the game grants a huge range of flexibility to players comfortable with multitasking. You can still win by timidly sticking to a single party except when forced to divide up to clear specific obstacles, but splitting the team and assigning tasks (and making smart use of waypoints and auto-pathfinding) gives Pikmin 3 considerably more strategic depth than either of the previous games. Granted, this is no StarCraft or Company of Heroes -- but then, it's not meant to be.

The core tenets of Pikmin 3 remain true to the game's heritage. Players control a team of tiny astronauts who lead an army of vegetable men called pikmin. The team's "home base" serves as the key tactical point for creating new pikmin from scavenged resources, as well as dropping off collected fruit for storage and sustenance. Pikmin 2 dropped the hard 30-day time limit of the first game, but Pikmin 3 restores it in a sense: The protagonists must collect fruit in order to feed the crew during their excursion. Roughly 100 days' worth of fruit is scattered about the maps, and acquiring certain of them makes for some of the game's most challenging goals. You can effectively play indefinitely if you manage your resources right.

Pikmin 3
Thankfully, before it was wiped off the face of the earth, humanity marked where you should chuck your comrades. We're really quite a considerate species.

Besides the ability to divide and conquer more effectively with your tiny spacemen, Pikmin 3's greatest asset is easily its absolutely perfect level design. Each of the game's maps sprawls magnificently and provides progressive goals that beg re-traversal and follow-up exploration. As the protagonists' abilities (namely, different pikmin breeds) are meted out one by one, new areas and new prizes come into reach on each map. The selection of pikmin themselves is the series' best to date as well; the ill-considered white and purple pikmin of the second game have been replaced by black and pink ones that serve a number of useful roles. But unlike their kin, they've been designed with care to avoid seeming overpowered or replacing any of the basic three types altogether. Where the purple pikmin supplanted the red ones, black pikmin work best in tandem with reds.

Pikmin 3 has its failings, to be sure. The game doles out new abilities for nearly a month of in-game time, then all too suddenly ends. Rather than letting you stretch a fair bit once you have your full arsenal of tricks in hand, Pikmin 3 instead rushes you to the finale. The game just feels a little short at the end -- not rushed, more like it's missing something. Given the way the ending movie hints at a sequel or, more likely, DLC, it's entirely possible that the "missing" content is actually "cut and being saved for later" content.

And the final map, intricately designed as it may be, turns into something of a slog due to a special condition that affects your trip through the area. Worse, it highlights both the sometimes clumsy camera perspectives that affect your progress and the occasionally awful pathfinding AI. There's nothing more frustrating than cornering a hairpin turn around a body of water only to have your lagging pikmin decide to cut straight through the water despite the fact that they can't swim.

Pikmin 3
When life gives you lemons, enslave some pikmin and force them to make you lemonade.

Despite these occasional flaws, Pikmin 3 works. In a medium where the word "sequel" far too often means "last year's game with a few superfluous features added," Pikmin 3 feels downright refreshing. Of course, there was no Pikmin game last year; the last new entry in the series arrived two generations ago, on GameCube, back in 2004 -- but Pikmin 3 offers more as a sequel than just a lengthy time gap.

Rather, this is the platonic ideal of a sequel: Bigger, better, more refined, but nevertheless faithful to what's come before. The game does stumble in a few areas, particularly in the final stretch, but on the whole it builds on the foundation of the first two games to stand as the best entry in the series by a considerable distance. Not only does Pikmin 3 strike a perfect balance between the first game's high-pressure minimalism and the second's languid dungeon-crawling, it also brings the best elements of their Wii remakes into the mix as well. Add some excellent solo and multiplayer extra modes to the best single-player campaign in the series and you have a sequel par excellence.

It's an especially gratifying sight coming from Nintendo, who in recent years has been a paragon of bumming around aimlessly with sequels rather than pushing new boundaries. Sure, games like New Super Mario Bros. U have demonstrated some excellent level design, but on the whole they tend to feel like Nintendo is spinning wheels rather than making advances. The arc of Pikmin, on the other hand, feels more akin to what we saw with classic NES trilogies like Super Mario and Castlevania: A great, if simple, first title; an entertaining follow-up that mixed up its predecessor's conventions both for better and for worse; and a third entry that returns to the first game's principles but with far more substance. Don't get me wrong; I wouldn't quite call this a masterpiece on the level of Super Mario Bros. 3. But it's a significant leap forward for the series, and the most fun I've had on Wii U to date.

Secondary Reviewer John Benyamine

Small admission: I never really got into the Pikmin series. Like many gamers looking for a reason to use my GameCube, I gave Pikmin a good run but it never really grabbed me. Mild interest in the original led to complete disinterest in the sequel, fair or unfair. That's why I'm surprised to completely concur with Jeremy's conclusion that this is the best game on the Nintendo Wii U, one that borders on system-seller status.

Jeremy's full review speaks at length about the single-player game, and I agree that it is a wonderful time. The characters are cute but not unbearable, and the maps are really gorgeous. The HD visuals are stunning, with a beautiful use of focus to give the larger-than-life garden worlds a touch of reality. Hell, the post-level closeups of the different fruit you gather gives you some of the most gorgeous visuals I've seen on a home console.

The Wii U GamePad also comes in handy a lot more than I was expecting. Given the fact you have three captains you can control, the GamePad is almost mandatory for effective management as you explore each level's terrain. Even if you're an expert gamer, you'll want to use the "Go Here" feature which allows one of your captains and their squad of pikmin to head to a specific part of the map, giving you a chance to really multitask without giving it much thought past the initial strategy you lay out. One captain heads for a piece of fruit while another helps take down some barriers, and you're free to use the third captain to continue on your main adventure.

The delay may have been frustrating for thirsty Wii U owners, but if that helped lead to the two modes on top of the game's single-player story, it was worth the wait. The first is a mission mode that helps you tackle different objectives on the game's maps, but it's the second, Bingo Battle mode, that makes this a must-have.

Pikmin 3
Theory: Pikmin 3 is set in the Left Behind universe. Here, we see a snowman that a pure-hearted child created only moments before taken away by the Rapture.

Bingo Battle takes place on a screen split vertically, and each player takes control of a captain with their own set of pikmin. Each player has a bingo card with various items to collect in order to mark it, and the first person to make a line across their card wins the match. What starts off as a match full of exploration and getting your bearings quickly turns into a cutthroat game as you try to complete your card, but also try to block your opponents from completing theirs.

This is further complicated by a power-up roulette wheel that occasionally appears to give you items you can use against your opponents. Time them correctly, and you can really gain an advantage. In one match, I found myself doing pretty well and was close to sending @danackerman to his doom. But Dan, sensing the end, made a bee-line for my side of the play field and hit his meteor power-up. Before I could look up in the sky, an interstellar rock flattened not only me and my crew of pikmin, but also Dan and his remaining guys. Assured victory was snatched from my hands in favor of mutual assured destruction. And yes, it was fun.

Slowly but surely, Pikmin 3 began to pique my interest, and the final product has delivered a great experience worthy of top marks. If Nintendo keeps games like Pikmin 3 coming, the Wii U has a real shot of becoming a powerhouse as the year rolls on.

The Details

  • Visuals: Pikmin 3's graphics won't blow your mind, but that's because the game takes a more subtle approach. The world is full of pastoral beauty, even the dusty desert climes, colorful but muted enough to help your vibrant minions stand out more clearly.
  • Audio: Gentle tunes evoke the countryside (Shigeru Miyamoto does love his banjo), with a dynamic audio mix to help alert players to nearing danger. The sound design is nearly perfect, with distinct audio cues to give you a sense of exactly what's happening around you -- and how far away it's happening.
  • Interface: Weirdly, the Wii remote interface works much better than the Game Pad. But it works wonderfully, even with the added complexity of managing three different teams.
  • Lasting Appeal: The single-player campaign ends somewhat abruptly, but it's still larger than either campaign from the first two games. The bonus mission and competitive modes could come across as tacked-on extras, but they're loads of fun.

Right now, Pikmin 3 is the single best piece of software on Wii U. I don't think it's a system seller by any means -- it's a light strategy game about controlling chirpy carrot-men, after all -- but anyone who owns a Wii U should give it a try. I went from being cooly disinterested in Pikmin 3 to completely smitten in the course of an afternoon. It's one of those games in which everything comes together just right. Olimar would be proud.

4.5 /5

Pikmin 3 Review Jeremy Parish Like an army of its tiny, titular, vegetable minions, Pikmin 3 is a tasty treat that offers just enough crunch to properly satisfy. 2013-08-01T19:01:00-04:00 4.5 5

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Related Tags

Comments 20

  • Avatar for darthhouser #1 darthhouser 4 years ago
    Great review! ive never played the first two games but this definitely has me interested!
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for superpatrick #2 superpatrick 4 years ago
    Does this game work with the original wiimote? (sans motion plus)
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for jeremy.parish #3 jeremy.parish 4 years ago
    @superpatrick Yes, the Wii controls consist entirely of pointing at things to aim -- nothing more complex.Edited July 2013 by jeremy.parish
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for superpatrick #4 superpatrick 4 years ago
    @jeremy.parish Thanks for the reply. Can't wait to pick this up.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for daysofstatic65 #5 daysofstatic65 4 years ago
    Sans Wii U currently, and this is probably the only reason for me to want to run out and buy one at this point.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Feanor #6 Feanor 4 years ago
    I don't understand using a star system and half stars when you could just use the same out of 10 scale Eurogamer does.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for dr134 #7 dr134 4 years ago
    If you are looking for a Pikmin type game on a non-Nintendo console, give Overlord or Overlord 2 a try. I enjoyed them both.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for jeremy.parish #8 jeremy.parish 4 years ago
    @Feanor Because -- and bear with me here if this seems too crazy to believe! -- we're not Eurogamer. We're a related site in the same network.

    And, while I didn't pick the star system, I like it a LOT more than a numeric system. If I had my druthers we wouldn't even have half-stars.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for docexe #9 docexe 4 years ago
    Meh, the numerical system is overrated anyway. Nice review Jeremy. Honestly, I have never played a game on the franchise, it just never looked that interesting to me, but this one is definitely grabbing my attention. Sadly, the planning of my finances doesn’t involve buying a Wii U (or another home console for that matter) until next year, but I will definitely keep an eye on this game.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for EuroDarlan #10 EuroDarlan 4 years ago
    I only recently picked up the New Play Control version of Pikmin 2, and while I thought I'd fall in love with it I honestly grew bored with it pretty quickly. I'm on the fence with this one, but it'll probably be a good while before I pick up a Wii U anyhow, so I bet it'll be cheap and worth it for me then.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Fresh_Paprika #11 Fresh_Paprika 4 years ago
    Jeremy, I've been reading your work since... God, probably 2006 (2005 maybe), and since I only started commenting recently (we'll see how long I'll last, I honestly don't know if I enjoy doing it or not), I never commented on anything you wrote. So anyway: great stuff! In general, I mean.

    (Well, I did write a lousy rant comment in Toastyfrog once, but I didn't bother posting it.)

    Add Ray Barnholt to the mix, and I could finally have that "1up X Eurogamer" crossover I always secretly wanted.

    I'd like to add that an often overlooked aspect of Pikmin is its looks and themes: surreal, cute character design mixed with realistic environments. There's no other game - or anything, for that matter - that looks quite like it. It's beautiful and tranquil, but has the brutality of nature. It's the "shank or be shanked" world of insects somehow presented in an adorable package. Insects through the eyes of tiny aliens, maybe?

    And its themes always lay in survival. In Pikmin it was survival of a man, Pikmin 2 survival of a company, Pikmin 3 survival of an otherworldly species. What's clever about this is how it matches the insect world: survival is all insects know and seek. Everything just comes together.

    I'm only 2 hours in, and I set myself with an amount of hype that no game or thing should ever have to live up to (but hey, at least the hype was caused by me and me alone). So far it's as lovely as I hoped, but even if it wasn't, I'm just happy Nintendo made another Pikmin.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Captain-Gonru #12 Captain-Gonru 4 years ago
    @jeremy.parish You know, one of my favorite reviews of the last few years didn't have a score at all. Instead, it was a well-written commentary of the content of the game, coupled with the reviewer's impressions. Now, this WAS on a site that was ending it's run, so I suppose they could get away with such a cheeky move. I can't recall the name of that talented wordsmith, but I sure hope he landed on his feet somewhere.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Feanor #13 Feanor 4 years ago
    A star system with half stars is no different than the numeric system Eurogamer use that grades in whole numbers out of 10, except on USGamer we have to look a bit closer at the score graphic to see if one of the stars is half colored in.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for jeremy.parish #14 jeremy.parish 4 years ago
    @Feanor No, you're mistaken. There's an important perceptual difference between a star and a numeric system. The numeric scale's integrity has been undermined by the "7-to-10" rating system so common in the gaming press. I never hear anyone making sarcastic remarks about the "3 and a half-to-5 star" scale. Using stars frees us from that perceptual baggage. The overwhelming majority of people read 2.5 stars as "mediocre," whereas they read 5/10 as "terrible," despite them being ostensibly the same score.
    @Captain Gonru Thanks, but the only reason I could get away with that was because the site was walking dead. Since then, I do my best to write reviews in the same spirit regardless of whether or not a number is attached.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Feanor #15 Feanor 4 years ago
    You don't hear those comments as often because few game sites use that system. 2.5/5 is the same as 5/10, whatever mental gymnastics you do to convince yourself it's different. People just look at the percentage score on gamerankings or MetaCritic anyway.

    If USGamer had given The Last of US 3.5/5 the Sony fanboys would have been just as indignant as if another site with the same status had given it 7/10. You may think the audience for videogame websites are dumb, but most of them can do their two times table.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for jeremy.parish #16 jeremy.parish 4 years ago
    After 10 years of dealing with the realities of scores and review reactions, I can say with certainty that the overwhelming majority of readers do in fact read the two systems in very different ways. It's nothing to do with reader intelligence, and you don't need to take this reality as a personal affront.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Feanor #17 Feanor 4 years ago
    I don't take your individual perception of anything as a personal affront. You're free to believe that the "overwhelming majority" of people think in a way that justifies your scoring system, and that your 4.5/5 for Pikmin 3 is not the same as Eurogamer's 9/10 even though it quite obviously is, and will be listed as such assuming USGamer eventually gets added to gamerankings and MetaCritic.

    But when Polygon gave Resident Evil 6 4/10 and Giant Bomb gave it 2/5 the internet reactions to those review scores were the same because people understood those were the same fractions expressed with different denominators.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Yeahhhh Jeremy is back. Great review. I don't own a Wii U and this one surely isn't going to make me buy one, but it's definitely one of the games on my list to buy when there is a compelling enough reason to buy one.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for smug43 #19 smug43 4 years ago
    Awesome review.. it's so well written and only noting other "RTS" games and NOT comparing them!! THANK F'ING GOD for that!! I can't state how much that irritates the crap out of me. Every game should be based on their own merit even games in the same genre etc... Lot's of respect!! Pikmin 3 will be injected into my bloodstream in THREE days!!!!!!! FUCK YES!!!!
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for tombriggs21 #20 tombriggs21 4 years ago
    So great to see Jeremy back to a site that allows for unconventional reviews. Good stuff, and I completely agree with his assessment of Pikmin 3.
    Sign in to Reply