Best Prospect Catchers in MLB The Show 18

Best Prospect Catchers in MLB The Show 18

A complete guide to the best prospects, franchise mode, Road to the Show, Stubs, Diamond Dynasty, Conquest Mode, and more in MLB The Show 18. Best players in MLB The Show 18.

Catchers can be the cornerstone of a great franchise, from Johnny Bench, to Gary Carter, to Mike Piazza, to Yadier Molina. The catch (no pun intended) is that finding a great one can be extremely difficult. When you start a franchise in MLB The Show 18, you’ll find that there are only six catchers aged 24 or under, with an A Potential. Let’s take a look at the best of them in our guide to the best prospect catchers in MLB The Show 18.

If you're after anything else at all to do with MLB The Show 18, including how to be the best player possible, make sure to head over to our MLB The Show 18 guides hub.

MLB The Show 18 Best Prospect Catchers

We've put together the key info the best best prospect catchers in MLB The Show 18 so you can recruit the best players without putting in the hard work scouting. Directly below you'll find a table detailing the best prospect catchers in MLB The Show 18, with additional details on each catcher just below that.

NameTeamAgeStarting OverallPotential
Chance SiscoBaltimore Orioles2364A
Chad DuarteChicago White Sox2053A
Francisco MejiaCleveland Indians2278A
Estaban MuñozMinnesota Twins1852A
Rick FelderChicago Cubs1852A

Best Potential Catcher - Chance Sisco - Baltimore Orioles Franchise

After moving on from Matt Wieters after the 2016 season, the Orioles are in search of their next long term answer at catcher. At only 23 years of age, Chance Sisco has the opportunity to be that answer. He’s an adept hitter (59 Con vs R, 50 Con vs R), as well as a skilled behind the plate with a good arm (71 Strength, 70 Arm Accuracy) and good blocking skills (74).

Best Potential Catcher - Chad Duarte - Chicago White Sox Organization

Being only 20 years old, Duarte has a lot of time to develop into an extremely good bat, though there are some concerns about his defense. His hitting will come around, but he starts the game with low 30s Contact numbers, and mid 30s power numbers. The good thing about him is that he doesn’t favor one arm side over the other. The problem lies with him defensively. He only has a 45 Fielding rating, along with a 41 Reaction, and 46 Blocking. However, he does have a pretty good arm with 76 Arm Strength. His bat will develop, but if his glove doesn’t he’s a strong candidate to move to 1B or DH.

Best Potential Catcher - Francisco Mejia - Cleveland Indians Organization

At only 22 years old, Mejia is the highest rated catcher (78) in the Indians’ organization, and thus, will have lots of playing time to grow. Starting with Contact numbers in the mid-to-high 50s Mejia has the opportunity to be a great hitting catcher. His glove is nothing to sneeze at either. Sporting 68 Fielding, 71 Arm Strength and 75 Blocking, he’s got a chance to be the kind of catcher that can build a dynasty around.

Best Potential Catcher - Estaban Muñoz - Minnesota Twins Organization

At only 18 years old, Muñoz will have a lot of time to let his A Potential flourish, and his 84 Durability will keep him on the field and allow that to happen. 35 Con vs R and 42 Con vs L are acceptable for someone this young, and his power numbers are not to far behind. If he can grow from his 52 Fielding, the only thing you’ll end up having to worry about is his 41 Blocking, which should mature into something more manageable. Again, he’s only 18, so he’s got time.

Best Potential Catcher - Rick Felder - Chicago Cubs Organization

The Cubs are already set at catcher with Willson Contreras being an 88 Overall with A Potential and only being 25 years old. Felder looks to develop into a contact hitting, defensive specialist with a weak arm. Being that he’s only 18, you gould decide to try to move him for something to help at another position in the short term, or ride him out until Contreras reaches his Free Agent years and let him move on, with Felder ready to take over.

That's it for our best potential catchers in MLB The Show 18. Head elsewhere for guides to the best prospect first basemen, or the best shortstops in the game.

Related articles

Tetris Effect: Connected's Co-op Has a Self-Revival Trick Everyone Needs to Learn

We're never gonna protect this trippy Tetris realm if you don't!

How to Make Your Money in Yakuza: Like a Dragon's Business Mode

Go from rags to riches with some proper management.

Xbox Game Pass Ultimate Is the First Thing You Should Buy on Your New Xbox Series X

We break down the reasons why Xbox Game Pass is an essential pickup now that the Xbox Series X is here.

Temtem: Saipark Safari This Week (17th August - 23th August)

We show you where to find the new Temtem Reserve, and how to catch rare and Luma Temtem there.

You may also like

Press Start to Continue

A look back on what we tried to accomplish at USgamer, and the work still to be done.

Mat's Farewell | The Truth Has Not Vanished Into Darkness

This isn't the real ending, is it? Can't be.

Eric's Farewell | Off to Find a New Challenger

It's time for us to move on, but we'll carry USG with us wherever we go.