Banner Saga 3 Devs Speak Out in Favor of Narrative Games Over "Flavor of the Moment" Games

Banner Saga 3 Devs Speak Out in Favor of Narrative Games Over "Flavor of the Moment" Games

Stoic Studios is made up of BioWare veterans who know narrative games.

Banner Saga 3 is out today, and it caps off the Viking trilogy first Kickstarted by Stoic Studio in 2012. Over the next six years Banner Saga became one of the first in what would become a revival of sorts for the strategy RPG genre. But in 2018 the landscape looks quite different and multiplayer experiences like battle royale games are the driving force of the industry.

With that in mind I asked three of the members of the Stoic Games team, who have a background in making single-player games at BioWare, what they think of the death of single-player narrative game theme of the last year.

"I think it's greatly overstated," says Matt Rhoades, lead designer of Banner Saga 3. "There's no question that making a single-player story game, we're competing at a much bigger playfield now. And you need to make sure that people know about you and they have a reason to be talking about you even if they're not playing your game with their friends and it creates a lot more noise for you to break through."

Ultimately though Rhodes says there's no way people will abandon the kind of narrative experience single-player games offer. "People want those kinds of narrative experiences. They want it in film, they want it in books, and they want it in games. So, I'm not worried that a subgenre of games is going to die off."

Banner Saga 3

Alex Thomas, a co-founder of Stoic Studio, BioWare veteran and writer for Banner Saga says that if there is a death of single-player experiences Banner Saga hasn't felt it. "One thing we have noticed with Banner Saga is that the sales of it has been very steady over six years, very consistent. I think we made something with an art style and narrative that is kind of timeless. You can play it ten years from now, try a different path. You can play it with your kids, you know, 20 years later."

Thomas says this timelessness is a big advantage for Banner Saga over games trying to get in on the latest fad "People are still going to be picking [Banner Saga] up across any platform that comes along in the future compared to whatever the flavor of the moment is, like battle royale. It could be that nobody is playing Fortnite a year from now, who knows?"

As more studios get in on battle passes, games as service, and long-term benefits of retaining players it's clear that the top of the industry is moving towards more service-like experiences. However studios like Bethesda and Motive have also said that narrative games will stick around. And for studios like Stoic and games like Banner Saga the creative drive for narrative games remain a focus.

For more on Banner Saga 3 check out our review when it drops tomorrow along with a full interview with Stoic Studios.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Matt Kim

News Editor

Matt Kim is a former freelance writer who's covered video games and digital media. He likes video games as spectacle and is easily distracted by bright lights or clever bits of dialogue. He also once wrote about personal finance, but that's neither here nor there.

In other news

Fire Emblem: Three Houses Adds a Secret Fourth House in New DLC

Byleth dives deep into the Abyss for more students to teach.

Wargroove's Free Double Trouble DLC Gets a Release Date, But PS4 Players Will Have to Wait

Double Trouble will drop first on PC, Switch, and Xbox One next month.

Valve's Dota Underlords Has Been Having Trouble Holding Onto Players

The autobattler has been slowly bleeding players.

You may also like

What Underused Setting Would be Amazing in a Video Game?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | South Asia? Toronto? We want to hear from you which underused setting would be great for a video game.

The Leads of Red Dead Redemption 2 Would Like You to Know They're Not "Voice Actors"

The people behind Dutch, Arthur, and other game stars want to set something straight.

Temtem Can Be "Better Than Pokemon" Because It's Not Pokemon

There's a wonderful freedom in being the new kid on the block.

Activision Blizzard Moves Away From Twitch, Partners With YouTube Gaming

The Overwatch League and more will stream exclusively with Google.