Batman: The Telltale Series, Episode II PC Review: Sins of the Father

Batman: The Telltale Series, Episode II PC Review: Sins of the Father

Telltale's Batman takes a divergent turn from previous versions of the Batman mythos.

Batman: The Telltale Series is an episodic video game. This is a review of episode 2 of a 5-episode series. Spoilers may exist in the review. Reviews for previous episodes can be found here:

Batman: The Telltale Series is a far more divergent version of Batman than I originally anticipated. I covered the basic gameplay my review of the first episode, so now it's time to take a deeper look at the story being told.

The beginning of this new Batman was largely about the caped crusader's alter ego, Bruce Wayne. Unlike many of the comic iterations, Telltale seemed more interested in exploring not only Bruce Wayne, but how much his family meant to the city of Gotham.

Telltale is playing on expectations here. It's been a long constant that Bruce's parents, Thomas and Martha Wayne, were nominally good people. They were old money, but they were kind with their wealth. Thomas was a doctor, Wayne Industries helped the city, and the Waynes were generally seen a a shining light in Gotham.

Towards the end of the previous episode, there was mention of Thomas Wayne being involved with mob boss Carmine Falcone. My assumption as a long-time Batman reader was this was a swerve, some plot whipped up by a Batman villain like Hush. It's clear from this episode that Telltale is playing it completely straight.

Thomas Wayne was working with Carmine Falcone and corrupt mayor Hill to control the city. The alley mugging that killed the Waynes and created Batman was a deliberate hit; a strike at one of the kings of Gotham City. Martha Wayne may have had knowledge of her husband's activities. Alfred definitely did, even if he disagreed with the Wayne's actions.

It's an interesting dynamic, because while Batman has the extra-judicial power and gadgets to bring down criminals and Bruce Wayne has the wealth and resources to help the city, none of that is useful against the truth: The Waynes were the photogenic face of Gotham's corruption. Bruce Wayne, Batman, and Wayne Industries are all the result of criminal actions. Bruce believed one type of crime created Batman, a low-level, general crime plaguing the city, but that was merely the result of a larger crime. Seeing Bruce deal with that, while trying to stop a larger evil in his city as Batman, is an interesting take on the mythos.

Part of the issue with second episodes in episodic games is that you're in the middle of an act. It's not all establishment, but it's not the climax either. With Batman: The Telltale Series and Minecraft: Story Mode, it's clear that Telltale has grasped how to make second episodes work. Make sure the the pace is quick and the events feel like they matter.

A lot happens here. Carmine Falcone and Mayor Hill lay out the extent of the Wayne's corruption. Renee Montoya is introduced and undertakes a major action in the plot of the episode. Catwoman and Batman bond in their civilian guises, setting up the famous love-hate relationship they have in the comics. Telltale's version of the Penguin and Killer Croc strike the Gotham mayoral debate. And in the midst of all of this, the faceless mastermind pulling everything behind the scenes is shown for the first time.

Batman: The Telltale Series Episode 2 moves along at a brisk pace. It's an episode that's just as good as the first, and I'm impressed that Telltale was even able to surprise me here and there. Batman is a character with a long history and massive fandom. Charting your own path is probably better than slavishly sticking to the source material and Telltale made the right choice here.

Telltale continues to craft its own version of Batman and Bruce Wayne. The action is still solid, but this is all about the story: Who is Bruce Wayne when everything he knows to be true is a lie? Given the truth of his origins, who is Batman? Telltale's Batman relies on safety and familiarity to subvert expectations here and it works well.


Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Mike Williams

Reviews Editor

M.H. Williams is new to the journalism game, but he's been a gamer since the NES first graced American shores. Third-person action-adventure games are his personal poison: Uncharted, Infamous, and Assassin's Creed just to name a few. If you see him around a convention, he's not hard to spot: Black guy, glasses, and a tie.

Other reviews

13 Sentinels: Aegis Rim Review: A Cruel Kaiju's Thesis

Vanillaware's latest is a twisty sci-fi melodrama, with a bland side of RTS.

Tell Me Why: Chapter 3 Review: Facing the Facts

Dontnod's series concludes with a solid chapter.

Tell Me Why: Chapter Two Review: High and Dry

Dontnod's middle act struggles to keep the momentum.

Paradise Killer Review: Love Dies

An island murder mystery where discovery is intoxicating, even if the climax falls flat.

Need help?

Outer Wilds Walkthrough

You’re pretty much left to your own devices in Outer Wilds. Here’s a recommended path.

Zelda Link's Awakening Signpost Maze - How to Make it Through the Signpost Puzzle

Here's our guide on making it through the Signpost puzzle in Zelda Link's Awakening as easily as possible.

No Man's Sky Tips - How to Get Started in 2019

Here are some tips to help you get a strong start in No Man's Sky.

Zelda Breath of the Wild Boss Guides - How to Beat Every Boss and Conquer Every Dungeon

This is our complete Zelda Breath of the Wild bosses guide, detailing every single boss and all the dungeons in Hyrule.