Battle Royale at an Itty Bitty Scale: Why Recent Efforts Like Red Dead Online's Fall Short

Games are starting to implement their own battle royale modes, at all sorts of scales.

Last week, Red Dead Online introduced its own battle royale-lite mode, entitled Gun Rush. It's really the second battle royale-ish mode to come to Red Dead Redemption 2's online counterpart, but Gun Rush's sights are set more clearly. It's a battle royale mode in everything but player count and name.

For anyone who plays the likes of Fortnite or PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds, Gun Rush's frame work is a familiar concept. In Gun Rush, only 32 players are in a fight to the death until the last person standing. As players scrounge for guns and ammo across the map, a circle closes in. But it has major problems: the spawns are a bit odd, and the experience you net for the time played simply isn't worth it for its already sparse progression—unless you always land at the top spot.

I wish this sort of posse strategizing happened more often in Red Dead Online's Gun Rush. | Rockstar/Take-Two

Of course, the most successful "supplemental" modes to come of the battle royale trend are obvious. There's Fortnite, once just a colorful PvE zombie game, now known more for its free-to-play battle royale spinoff mode, and then there's Call of Duty: Black Ops 4's Blackout. The success of both comes from the player count and sizes of their maps: Fortnite supports 100 players, while Blackout supports a crisp 88. The missing 12 doesn't end up feeling like it matters much, due to Blackout's fast-pace. Blackout's Call of Duty-like formula and Fortnite's identity reinvention are the big success stories in established games trying their hand at a new genre trend. If only other games could be so lucky.

Across the past almost-two years, we've seen quite a few battle royale modes grace the likes of Steam and consoles, but largely, they're standalone releases like PUBG. But enough time has passed that now we're seeing the opposite end of things. H1Z1, in one of the earliest examples, divorced itself from its survival half in 2016. Eventually, the battle royale mode's King of the Kill name was dropped, and it lay firm claim to "H1Z1" proper—somewhat like Fortnite's embrace of just "Fortnite" by most fans, rather than its full name of Fortnite Battle Royale.

In the past couple months, more battle royale modes have cropped up in online games. At its beta launch, Red Dead Online had Make It Count, wherein players only had bows and knives at their disposal within a shrinking circle. In January it's introduced Gun Rush, a similar mode, only with more weapon options. Last month, Counter-Strike: Global Offensive went free-to-play, and introduced a new battle royale mode, Danger Zone, alongside its standard multiplayer fare.

It's left me with a question I've been pondering since PUBG exploded on the scene in early 2017: What really defines a battle royale mode? Is it the island map? The player count? The fact that the last person standing wins? Personally, I feel like it's a combination of all of those things, and that's why a lot of the smaller-scale battle royale modes haven't quite appealed in the same way. When you consider a battle royale, it's a tense experience knowing 80-to-90 players are also gunning for the same top spot. In Red Dead Online, Counter-Strike, and undoubtedly other modes, the stakes are a lot lower. It's not as tense, because there's not as many players. (Counter-Strike especially suffers from this, with its pacing feeling more akin to a Deathmatch mode.)

Standalone releases too, like the ill-fated S.O.S., sometimes bill themselves as battle royale when their player counts barely stretch over 30 usually. In March, Battlefield 5 will unleash its own entry in the battle royale race with Firestorm, a mode we know will have 64 players total, leaning on Battlefield's strengths of working alongside a squad. Also instead of a strange wall of death, it's an actual ring of fire that is closing in. Yikes!

Still, that player count pales in comparison to Call of Duty's own battle royale mode, which is admittedly more traditional compared to Battlefield 5 Firestorm, which will be bringing tanks and other intimidating vehicles into the mix. Firestorm sounds at least interesting as a concept compared to other battle royale games. And for a battle royale to stand out, it really needs an extra hook to make it greater than just another Last Man Standing.

I have an issue with other games trying out "battle royale" modes that dial back the scale considerably. In order to be a battle royale, that tension is necessary, be it from an astounding player count or an unforgiving locale like the usual isolated islands in the middle of nowhere. There are interesting ideas in some battle royale-lite modes, like in Red Dead Online's stealth-dependent Make It Count, but largely, they just feel like afterthoughts.

That said, it's easy to see how the now well-storied battle royale mode is appealing. Epic Games shifted its early-access zombie game into an overnight sensation; Call of Duty's own foray into the mix combines the best of Fortnite and PUBG, with its own dash of what makes the Black Ops series so appealing. It remains to be seen if Battlefield 5 will enjoy the same level of success that Blackout has, given its smaller scale.

At least Battlefield 5 seems to be doing something right though: taking the formula of battle royales and bending it into its own unique mix of gameplay. If only Red Dead Online, CS: GO, and whatever other battle royale modes out there that will someday be (or already are and I'm forgetting) could embrace the same sensibility.

Tagged with Battle Royale, Opinions, PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds (PUBG), Red Dead Online, Rockstar Games.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Read this next

More Opinions

What's the Most Painful Game Save You've Ever Lost? Players Share Their Stories

A cartridge's save battery is finite. Just like a parent's love.

The Friends of Ringo Ishikawa Is a Coming of Age Beat 'Em Up With A Lot On Its Mind

Part-River City Ransom, part-Persona, part-Yasujirō Ozu: can there ever be a better mix?

Apex Legends Almost Feels New Again After Its Latest Patch

I can engage in long-range combat now? What?

Dreams Wants to Make Game Developers of Us All, And I'm Convinced It's Working

Dreams has scope unlike any other creation-focused game before it.

More Battle Royale Games

Fortnite's Teasing an Avengers: Endgame Crossover With Captain America

Avenge the fallen in Fortnite's upcoming crossover event.

What's Your Favorite Co-Op Game to Play With Loved Ones?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | It's a weekend all about spending time with family and friends, so let's hunker down and talk about our favorite co-op games!

Apex Legends Almost Feels New Again After Its Latest Patch

I can engage in long-range combat now? What?

Apex Legends May Have Accidentally Added Another Buff to Gibraltar

Respawn is investigating the unannounced ability.