Bioshock Infinite: Should You Choose the Bird or the Cage Pendant?

Bioshock Infinite: Should You Choose the Bird or the Cage Pendant?

We go over the details and consequences of choosing between the different necklaces for Elizabeth.

Some way into the story of Bioshock Infinite, you'll have to choose between two options for Elizabeth: whether to give her a pendant showing a bird or a cage. We'll explain the choice here, as well as what impact it has on the rest of the game.

Warning: the following contains spoilers for the plot of Bioshock Infinite.

Should I Choose the Bird or the Cage?

The honest truth is that it doesn't really matter, at least not in terms of gameplay, with more of a symbolic impact than anything mechanical. Choice, divergent paths, freedom and entrapment are running themes of Bioshock Infinite, and this is an extension of that idea, inviting you to make a decision that you don't get to see the results of. The necklace does play into the game later, but it doesn't actually change your overall experience or set you on a different path.

What Happens If You Choose the Bird or Cage?

Spoilers still, but this is less about you and more about the Lutece twins who offer you the choice, similar to the coin flip they gave you at the beginning. Being interdimensional explorers unlimited by time or space, the Luteces have likely seen this scenario play out hundreds of times, either in different timelines or by going back and looping the same events over and over. This is their way of keeping score of all the little differences and nuances. You could also make the point that it's a metanarrative comment about free will and player choice, but that's probably for a different article.

All that being said, there is a moment at the very final minutes of the game where Booker sees Elizabeth, only to suddenly exclaim that it isn't her. Looking closer reveals she's not wearing the pendant you picked out, presumably making her an Elizabeth from another universe.

From the beginning, every interaction you have with the Luteces is part of a controlled experiment. | Joel Franey/USgamer, Irrational Games/2K

It's a bit of a mind-bending answer, but should clear things up after a couple of days to process it. If you want something more straightforward in the meantime, why not check here to see how to crack all the Vox Populi ciphers and codes? Or if you want news on the upcoming Bioshock sequel, just follow this link here.

Joel Franey

Guides Writer

Joel loves books, games, comics and drinks that make a person feel like they just got kicked in the head by a mule. He has a Masters in writing from Sussex, which he somehow got by writing about Superman. He is absolutely NOT three children in a long coat, so please stop asking.

In other news

Monster Hunter: Rise is a Switch Exclusive Launching in March 2021

The next entry in the series returns to its Nintendo roots.

Godfall Is a Day One Launch Title for the PS5

Gearbox's new looter-slasher launches on November 12.

Devil May Cry 5 Special Edition Coming to PS5 on Day One

And it looks like Vergil has new playable segments.

Ghostrunner Slides, Dashes, and Leaps Toward an October Launch

The very speedrun-friendly first-person action title is just a few weeks from launch.

You may also like

Are Launch Day Lineups Getting Worse?

THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | People are clearly excited for the new hardware, but are the games they'll actually play on it as interesting as they used to be?

Hello Games Teases New No Man's Sky Update Called Origins

It'll be "the beginning of something new," studio founder Sean Murray says.

Superbrothers Delay Jett: The Far Shore to 2021, Pushing Back Another PS5 Holiday Title

Before Jett lifts off, the Sword and Sorcery EP makers say they need more time.