Bleeding Edge Didn't Leave a Good First Impression

Bleeding Edge is so forgettable, I almost didn't write this up.

Team-based action games had their heyday a few years ago, when Battleborn and Overwatch tussled with more MOBA-influenced games like Paragon. But those have largely fallen off for battle royales and whatever the next hot setting for a shooter is. Bleeding Edge feels like it never got the memo.

Ninja Theory's first game as an Xbox Game Studio is a four-on-four arena combat game, where two sides vie for control of certain areas of the map while collecting power-ups, avoiding environmental hazards, and fighting the enemy team. It seems tailor-made to inspire esports commentary and analysis, with assigned roles like DPS, healer, and tank. It uses mechanics like "mounting up," where characters can hop on a vehicle to move faster after a short charge time, and lets you charge up an ultimate that can shift the tide of battle.

Bleeding Edge also feels like a game I've played many times before, and it didn't do anything for me that those games didn't. Jumping through the roster in the dojo, each character seemed overly familiar: The frail but deadly ninja, a support with a heal beam, and a tank who focused on area control were among the few that seemed just like any other.

I eventually settled on Gizmo, the punk-rock kid with gatling gun whose ultimate summoned a robotic teddy bear mech. Her kit was a mix of utility and escape mechanics, mostly to accent her gatling gun's gradual spin-up. The longer I held the trigger, the faster I could spit out damage, so it played to my advantage to keep foes at a distance.

While Gizmo was mostly about holding down the triggers, which was par for the course with other ranged characters I tried out, melee fighters get a combo out of mashing the X button. Each character brings their own special abilities and ultimate tailored to them, and some were pretty fun to use, like Nidhoggr's powerslide. Most of the heroes, on their own, are fairly interesting. While some have a Borderlands-esque level of "love it or hate it" loud aesthetic, it gives each fighter enough character to not only make them visually distinct on the battlefield, but in playstyle as well.

I lost interest as the match wore on, though. Big team fights in Bleeding Edge amount to a visual and aural cascade that's hard enough to dissect in the moment after just a few minutes with the game. I frequently felt like I didn't know what I was doing or who I was targeting, even when I was getting kills. Each character was individually interesting, but in concert they felt disorganized, when I wanted more clear synergy and interplay rather than eight disparate combatants flung into an arena.

The objectives have very little notification, and it felt like the game had trouble communicating to the player the best uses of their time. Often, the developers had to shepherd us from fight to fight, objective to objective, because the cues were never clear enough in what we should be doing.

Taken by themselves, each of these things were just little nitpicks. But as a whole, Bleeding Edge just felt like a game that already came out. The clear tie-ins for esports-style metagaming and commentary, using conventional terms like healer or DPS, and an odd mix of control point and deathmatch mixed in with a Battlefield-style ticker at the top just felt too mechanical, too routine.

Given how worn its content feels, the name "Bleeding Edge" misses the mark a bit. | Microsoft/Ninja Theory

There are parts of Bleeding Edge I enjoyed; even though I personally didn't like the look of some characters, I appreciate that they went for style and stuck to it. There are some cool ideas scattered about the various combatant's arsenals, and I'm naturally inclined to enjoy anything with some MOBA concepts.

But I walked away from my time with Bleeding Edge feeling neither excited nor disappointed. It was an ode to a genre that's basically owned by Overwatch now, without much new to offer. Maybe it's the right blend for someone else who hasn't played so many games in the same vein, but it didn't show me anything to make me feel like I should jump into another competitive hero arena brawler.

[Take a look at our E3 2019 coverage for more hands-on impressions, news, and rumors!]

Tagged with E3 2019, Microsoft, Ninja Theory, Opinions, Shooters, Xbox E3 2019, Xbox One.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Read this next

Xbox E3 2019 Press Conference Recap: The Next-Generation Xbox is Revealed (Sort Of), But Keanu Reeves Steals the Show

Cyberpunk 2077 and Gears 5 get release dates, Project Scarlett gets details, and Keanu Reeves drops in instead of Shigeru Miyamoto.

Bleeding Edge Alpha Release Date: 4v4 Multiplayer, Characters - Everything We Know

Bleeding Edge is the new game from Ninja Theory. Here’s what we know so far.

Ninja Theory's Next Game, Bleeding Edge, Hitting Technical Alpha Later This Month

Bleeding Edge was officially revealed at the Xbox E3 press conference.

Bleeding Edge, Ninja Theory's Next Game, Appears to Have Leaked Ahead of E3 2019

Ninja Theory's first game since getting acquired by Microsoft.

Now That E3 2019 Is Done, What's Your Most Anticipated Game for the Rest of 2019?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | The smoke has cleared. Let's look ahead to what's next now.

How John Wick Hex's Action is Designed With the Help of the Film's Fight Choreographers

We check out the unique strategy game being developed with consultation from the film series' creators.

Gooigi Adds a Gooey New Dimension to Luigi's Mansion 3's Puzzles

We get to know Luigi's Mansion 3's creepiest new character.

More Opinions

Gooigi Adds a Gooey New Dimension to Luigi's Mansion 3's Puzzles

We get to know Luigi's Mansion 3's creepiest new character.

Animal Crossing: New Horizon's Customization Options Prove Representation Can Be Simple

Sometimes it just comes down to letting people play as themselves.

Marvel Ultimate Alliance 3 is the Better Marvel Game at E3 2019

The Switch delivers the Marvel experience I'm looking for.

All the Big Fan Theories That Have Already Emerged From the Zelda: Breath of the Wild 2 Reveal

It looks like Ganondorf is making his Breath of the Wild debut, and that can only spell trouble.

More on Xbox One

Now That E3 2019 Is Done, What's Your Most Anticipated Game for the Rest of 2019?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | The smoke has cleared. Let's look ahead to what's next now.

"If We Are Going to Do [E3] as an Industry, Then We Need to Be Into It"

THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | The theme of this year's E3 2019? Subscriptions and streaming, with every major company either participating or at least weighing in on the coming wave of services.

Xbox Boss Phil Spencer Says E3 Just Isn't the Same Without Sony

Without the friendly rivalry, E3 suffered a little bit.

Cyberpunk 2077 Will Let You Create Transgender Characters

CD Projekt Red ultimately wants a robust character creator.

The E3 2019 Awards: The Best Games We Saw at This Year's Show

Here are all the best games we saw at E3 2019, including our Game of the Show!

Phantasy Star Online 2 Will "End Up on All Platforms," Phil Spencer Confirms

The popular MMORPG will eventually come to PlayStation and maybe even the Switch.

More Shooter Games

Now That E3 2019 Is Done, What's Your Most Anticipated Game for the Rest of 2019?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | The smoke has cleared. Let's look ahead to what's next now.

The E3 2019 Awards: The Best Games We Saw at This Year's Show

Here are all the best games we saw at E3 2019, including our Game of the Show!

Splatoon 2's Final Splatfest Detailed, Private Splatfest Mode Coming in July

The festivals are coming to an end with one last climactic battle.

Vote Here for the USG Best of E3 2019 Community Award!

What did you love most from E3 2019? We want to hear from you!