Blizzard is in an Even Bigger Mess Than the NBA on China, and It Has No One to Blame But Itself
Blizzard's handling of the Hearthstone controversy is an international mess of its own making.
At Blizzard's headquarters in Irvine, stylized plaques list the eight values that comprise its mission statement. Conspicuously covered up today were "Think Globally" and "Every Voice Matters," a reflection of the mushrooming controversy over the suspension of Hearthstone pro Ng "blitzchung" Wai Chung, who recently advocated for the ongoing protests in Hong Kong.
The backlash, as you might expect, has been strong. The decision immediately shot to the top of Reddit and other social networks, drawing the attention of mainstream publications. "Blizzard" has been trending for the U.S. on Twitter. Polygon reporter Colin Campbell decried "Blizzard's abject cowardice and greed" in a tweet linking to the story on the decision, and Gamesbeat fumed that Blizzard "failed to make a stand for anything but China and money."
The intense reaction is owed to many factors: geopolitical rivalries, the concurrent controversy in the NBA, and even the ongoing Epic Games Store backlash. But what we're seeing is new. As the protests in Hong Kong rage on, China is now wielding its influence as a blunt instrument in an effort to silence any support for the protesters. With Chinese companies like Tencent having large stakes in American publishers, including Blizzard—of which it owns a roughly 5 percent share—the impact is now being felt by the games industry.
Blizzard's reaction is dispiriting not just because it illustrates its willingness to bow to Chinese pressure over Hong Kong, but because of how draconian it was. Donning a mask and saying, "Liberate Hong Kong, revolution of our age" was enough to get Chung banned for a year and his winnings revoked. Blizzard even went as far as to fire the commentators who happened to be in the video (and subsequently hid their faces when Chung made his statement).
For comparison, when Overwatch League player Josh "Eqo" Corono, who plays for the Philadelphia Fusion, made a racist gesture and said "I am Korean" on a stream, he was suspended for three games and fined $3000. For Blizzard, support for Hong Kong's protests is seemingly far worse than being racist.
It's easy to see the motives behind Blizzard's actions. Aside from Tencent's ownership stake, Blizzard's Overwatch League has a large presence in China thanks to teams like the Shanghai Dragons. According to the company's most recent financial releases, the entire Asia-Pacific region only makes up about 12 percent of Blizzard's revenue, but like everyone else, Blizzard sees China as an area of growth.
Blizzard isn't going to be able to easily fix this mess, but the NBA's response to its own controversy may be instructive. After Houston Rockets general manager Daryl Morey tweeted, "Fight for freedom, stand with Hong Kong," prompting a firestorm on Chinese social media, the NBA put out a muddled statement in which the NBA mostly talked about bringing people together. This did little more than stoke the flames on both sides of the Pacific.
Today, though, commissioner Adam Silver rallied strongly behind Morey. "The NBA will not put itself in a position of regulating what players, employees and team owners say or will not say on these issues. We simply could not operate that way."
Adam Silver has released statement on league’s relationship status with China, reading in part: “The NBA will not put itself in a position of regulating what players, employees and team owners say or will not say on these issues. We simply could not operate that way.” pic.twitter.com/A43BOAdG57
— Shams Charania (@ShamsCharania) October 8, 2019
The full statement was derided by some outlets as wanting to have it both ways (which didn't work in any case, because China's CCTV responded by suspending all NBA preseason broadcasts), but Silver said what needed to be said. Even with perhaps billions of dollars in broadcasting rights on the line, the NBA won't throw Morey under the bus or fire him. Blizzard should follow the NBA's lead.
Unfortunately for Blizzard, it's already pulled the trigger on Chung's suspension, so it's not as easy to do an about face on this issue. Probably the best it can do is to cancel the suspension, or at least award him his prize money, which comes to around $10,000. Either way, Blizzard won't exactly be able to play a Healing Touch card and move on from this fiasco.
Other publishers, meanwhile, might want to look at this mess and maybe realize that for all the money at stake in angering China, forfeiting their principals is worse. Whether it realizes it or not, the entertainment industry has plenty of power of its own in China. After all, the Chinese like watching basketball and playing video games just as much as the rest of the world.
One way or another, it's been a bad day for the American games industry. And with China's influence on gaming continuing to grow, other publishers are apt to face similar tests. Here's hoping they acquit themselves better than Blizzard did.
Read this next
Overwatch Director Jeff Kaplan Just Threw in His Support for Blitzchung
"I think the suspension should be reduced more or eliminated. But that's just me."
1
A Devolver Co-Founder Makes A Plea For Publishers To Rethink Predatory Microtransactions
THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | Devolver Digital co-founder Mike Wilson likens addictive titles to crystal meth.
3
Blizzard's Commitment to Free Expression Doesn't Mean Much With Blitzchung Still Banned
THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | Blizzard calls its suspension of Blitzchung for voicing support for the ongoing Hong Kong protests a "tough Hearthstone esports moment."
7
Hearthstone Battlegrounds is Blizzard's Puzzling Reaction to Auto Chess
Its autobattling, but also very much Hearthstone.
Blizzard President Apologizes for Hearthstone Controversy, Doesn't Change Ruling
Brack apologized, but didn't change the company's stance despite protest.
4
Suspended Hearthstone Pro Blitzchung Signs With Esports Team
Chung "Blitzchung" Ng Wai, the player at the center of Blizzard's Hong Kong controversy, is now a player for Tempo Storm.
BlizzCon 2019 is Blizzard's Most Crucial Show in Years
The wayward company has a chance to set its tone for the future, for better or worse.
3
More Opinions
Galarian Meowth: Oh My God, What the Hell
The U.K. is free of rabies, but Galar seemingly isn't.
10
In Defense of Cal Kestis, Jedi: Fallen Order's Dorkiest Padawan
There's more to Fallen Order's red-headed Jedi than meets the eye.
1
The Biggest Game Awards 2019 Snubs and Surprises: Disco Elysium and Outer Wilds Miss Out
Some indie darlings are up for smaller awards, but not the major one.
8
Starting Screen | Starting Screen: Google Stadia is Gaming for No One
Google's first foray into the console space manages to alienate both causal and hardcore gamers alike.
3
More on Android
How to Complete the Fortnite Pipeman, Hayman, Timber Tent Locations Challenge
Here's how you can complete the Fortnite challenge to dance in front of the pipeman, hayman, and timber tent locations.
Path of Exile 2 Just Got Announced, and It's Already Throwing Jabs at Diablo
We've got a tussle for the loot game spotlight on our hands.
1
Fortnite's New Stormtrooper Skin Lets Everyone Know You Have Bad Aim
The Fort is strong with this one.
Project xCloud’s Preview Selection Makes Stadia’s Launch Lineup Look Tiny
Dozens of games are coming for testers of Microsoft's game streaming service.
1
John Carmack Is Shifting Roles at Oculus to Focus on Artificial Intelligence
The former CTO is now the "consulting CTO."
Several Big Google Stadia Features Won't Go Live Until 2020
Family sharing, Android compatibility, and more are missing the launch window.
1
A Massive Stardew Valley Update is Dropping Very Soon
The free 1.4 update is just around the corner for PC players.
More Strategy Games
Fire Emblem: Three Houses Finally Adds Another Gay Romance Option For Male Byleth
Small spoiler warning: we'll be detailing the new S-Rank character for male Byleth.
4
New Fire Emblem: Three Houses DLC Has Everyone Thirsty
Maid outfits and Jeritza for all.
1
Starting Screen | Blizzard Had a Terrible Weekend, But At Least Warcraft 3: Reforged is Good
Maybe Blizzard's best days really are behind it.
5
Hearthstone Battlegrounds is Blizzard's Puzzling Reaction to Auto Chess
Its autobattling, but also very much Hearthstone.
Newsletter
Subscribe to our weekly newsletters
Get the best of USG in your inbox by subscribing to our newsletters.