Borderlands 3 Borrows a Surprising Amount From Mass Effect, And It Works

Borderlands 3 Borrows a Surprising Amount From Mass Effect, And It Works

The familiar elements of Borderlands return intact, but the canvas is much bigger now.

"I can sing! And dance!" We're back on Pandora, and Claptrap—the hyperactive bot that serves as Borderlands 3's mascot—is cheerfully spinning and sliding down a familiar-looking desert hill. But for the Unreal Engine 4-driven graphics, it would feel much as it did back in 2009, when Gearbox first hit upon the idea to mate the FPS genre with Diablo-style loot mechanics.

As befits a series now in its third main entry (fourth, if you count the somewhat disappointing Pre-Sequel), the canvas is wider now. While Borderlands 3 starts on the familiar confines of Pandora, it soon moves from its scarred surface to a brand new starship called the Sanctuary 3; and from there, into the stars. That's right: Borderlands 3 is going full Mass Effect. Well, as Mass Effect as you can get with a looter shooter, at least.

Psychos are back, looking a bit more modern in an Unreal Engine 4 game running on current-gen consoles and PC. | 2K Games/Gearbox Software

For Gearbox, the new planets are mainly about keeping the setting fresh and interesting; and by extension, the formula. Borderlands is in some ways deeper than its direct competition, sporting multiple dense skill trees and many weapon types, but it's also a very known quantity at this point. Another jaunt across Pandora wasn't going to be enough for this sequel.

So now Borderlands 3 has three major planets as well as a multitude of smaller "planetoids." This has plenty of interesting implications for the look, feel, and overall structure of Borderlands 3. Among them, it opens up the opportunity to have a bit of fun with the mix of sci-fi and Wild West elements that have long been Borderlands' calling card. Where the Pre-Sequel shook things up by moving the action to Pandora's moon, Borderlands 3 hints at settings ranging from futuristic cities to Endor-like forest villages.

The sense of possibility suffusing Borderlands 3's new planets extends to the Sanctuary 3 itself. The Sanctuary 3 is as bursting with personality as the rest of Borderlands' wacky universe, filled as it is with familiar faces and visual gags. You'll find Claptrap busy designing a girlfriend in one area; in another, a trophy room is occupied by Sir Hammerlock, who looks right at home in the trappings of a Victorian hunting lodge (in space!). All of these characters, plus others, have their own individual sidequests, which will help to flesh out Borderlands 3's overall content.

The Sanctuary 3 will be your main home through the bulk of Borderlands 3. You'll have quarters that you will be able to customize with your favorite weapons and other special rewards. When you enter a friend's game, you will be able to take your private quarters with you too. The Sanctuary 3 will be instantly accessible no matter where you are, and will serve as the jumping off point for multiple sidequests.

Co-op play will once again be a huge part of the Borderlands experience. | 2K Games/Gearbox Software

I'll admit, I'm a sucker for any game that gives me access to a starship. It feels a little sacrilegious to compare the Sanctuary to Mass Effect's iconic Normandy, but it does have that vibe to it. Even Claptrap, who is described by Gearbox as equal parts "needy, bossy, and pathetic," feels like he'd be right at home in a BioWare game. (What is HK-47 if not a low-key psychotic Claptrap?) I even felt some of that old sense of wonder when the camera panned to the Sanctuary 3's window and I found myself looking down above the dusty surface of Pandora.

It feels like Gearbox is working hard to make the Sanctuary 3 more than just a place where you refill your ammo and set a course for your next quest. The customization is much appreciated, as are some of the unique challenges. I especially like Hammerlock's trophies, which are reminiscent of the monster bounties from games like Final Fantasy 12. Gearbox isn't quite ready to talk about the endgame yet; but on the face of it, there will be a lot to do in Borderlands 3.

The Remaining Question Facing Borderlands 3

On the ground, Borderlands 3 nearly the same as it did back in 2009. Borderlands 3 may be running on Unreal Engine 4 now, but it still has the distinctive ink-drawn aesthetic that has become its house style. Its manic sense of humor also returns intact; grating to some and hilarious to others. I'll admit, I'm in the former camp, but that's because my own sense of humor has always been a little more... dry. Old Game of Thrones references ("I challenge you to a trial by combat!" Claptrap yells at one point) don't really do it for me.

Still, Gearbox is sticking with what works, and who can blame it? According to creative director Paul Sage, Borderlands 2 can still reach 200,000 concurrent players. That's a pretty healthy number for a seven-year-old game, even one with as many ports as Borderlands 2. (It's even on Vita, which I know because I reviewed it.)

Apart from some key upgrades, like multiplayer level scaling that allows low-level players to play seamlessly with high-level ones, Borderlands 3's main innovation is the Sanctuary 3. In going to the stars, it will no doubt draw comparisons to Destiny, which has come to own the so-called "looter shooter" genre in the years since Borderlands 2. But the Sanctuary 3 is a necessary upgrade. It's time for the series to expand its canvas.

In doing so, it's taking the steps needed to survive in a space that has become ferociously competitive in the years since Borderlands 2 arrived in 2012. Its next step, beyond growing its setting, is proving that it has staying power beyond its fanatical core. If there's one complaint I see on a consistent basis, it's that the content in Borderlands and its sequels feels more finite and limited than that of its competitors. Accurate or not, Gearbox ought to take steps to remedy that feeling with a robust endgame.

I have a feeling that Borderlands 3 will be fine in any case. It has a rabid fanbase, a distinct personality, and history. It also stands to benefit from the stumbles of its competition, which has seen both Fallout 76 and Anthem fall flat in recent months. Even if Gearbox plays the rest of Borderlands 3 relatively straight, it's hard to imagine it struggling as hard as those two games did at launch.

But credit where it's due: the Sanctuary 3 is pretty cool, and so is the ability to travel to multiple planets. In that, Borderlands 3 is off to a very good start. It will be out September 13 on PC, Xbox One, and PlayStation 4.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Kat Bailey

Editor in Chief

Kat Bailey is a former freelance writer and contributor to publications including 1UP, IGN, GameSpot, GamesRadar, and EGM. Her fondest memories as a journalist are at GamePro, where she hosted RolePlayer's Realm and had legal access to the term "Protip." She is USgamer's resident mecha enthusiast, Pokemon Master, and Minnesota Vikings nut (skol).

Read this next

Borderlands 3 Stadia, Release Date, Prequel DLC, Gameplay - Everything we Know

Here's our complete roundup of info on Borderlands 3, including a release date, gameplay, prequel DLC, characters, weapons, and more.

Borderlands 3 Puts a Bow on the Main Trilogy's Story: "Where We Go From Here, We Have No Idea"

The new game will also resolve questions from Tales From the Borderlands and Borderlands: The Pre-Sequel.

"No Current Plans" for Borderlands 3 DLC Characters, Gearbox Confirms

Four Borderlands 3 DLC packs are planned, but new characters will have to wait.

Borderlands 3 Devs Respond to Odd Claptrap Mission in Borderlands 2 DLC

The mission seemingly referencing hostilities with a former employee is reportedly not actually doing that.

Ice-T Revealed as Ornery Stuffed Bear in Borderlands 3

And he gets eaten by an alien T-Rex.

Borderlands 3 FL4K Skill Tree: Hunter, Master and Stalker Skill Trees Detailed

The fourth Vault Hunter has been revealed to be FL4K. Here’s what you need to know.

Borderlands 3 Weapons: Weapon Manufacturers, Rarity, Gun Perks

Here’s everything you need to know about the weapons in Borderlands 3.

More Opinions

The Pride Flag in Marvel's Spider-Man is a Small Gesture That's Made a Large Impact

THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | Pride flags in Marvel's Spider-Man, edits to Yakuza re-releases, and an Ion Fury backtrack show publisher actions speaking louder than words

What the Heck is Ray Tracing and Why Does it Matter for Next-Generation Consoles? An Explainer

Nvidia is pushing ray tracing very hard, so let's talk about why it matters to games.

The Fire Emblem: Three Houses Student Ranking Thunderdome: 34 Students Enter, Only Shamir Leaves

We have no favorites among Three Houses' characters, except for the ones that are our favorites.

NBA 2K20 Finally Tackles the VC Microtransaction Grind: "We Didn't Want People to Feel [...] Trapped in This Grind Anymore"

Virtual Currency is here to stay, but at least the grind will be less painful this year.

More on PC

Trials of Mana Interview: The Developers on Topping the Fan Translation and the Possibility of New Mana Games

"[T]he localization team took a look at the translation and the first thing they said was, 'We're going to show them up.'"

Oninaki Review

Oh now feel it, comin' back again.

Remnant: From the Ashes is Quickly Becoming 2019's Breakout Hit

A multiplayer Souls-shooter is picking up steam.

Former Artifact Designer Says Expansions Were in the Works Prior to His Departure

He hopes the maligned card game can still find an audience.

Final Fantasy 14 Director Details Upcoming Job Changes for Ninja, Samurai, and Summoner

Future collaborations with other games remain top secret.

More Action Games

Final Fantasy 14 Director Details Upcoming Job Changes for Ninja, Samurai, and Summoner

Future collaborations with other games remain top secret.

Yakuza Producer Says Next Game in the Series Could Still Feature Some Familiar Faces

Producer Daisuke Sato details the next Yakuza game, and reflects on Judgment.

What the Heck is Ray Tracing and Why Does it Matter for Next-Generation Consoles? An Explainer

Nvidia is pushing ray tracing very hard, so let's talk about why it matters to games.

Where Nintendo Switch Online Has Gone Wrong

The reasons Nintendo's online service is flaccid, and what it can do to pump things up.