Call of Duty: Modern Warfare's Realistic Military Violence Draws Mixed Reactions

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare's Realistic Military Violence Draws Mixed Reactions

How well does Infinity Ward handle the violence in the new Call of Duty?

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2019 is a "soft reboot" of the original Modern Warfare game that Infinity Ward developed in 2007. Like its predecessor, the new Modern Warfare wants to portray military combat in a realistic way, based on real-life events. But is this dedication to realism successful as an artistic choice, or is it just a tagline to sell this year's new Call of Duty?

Several members of the press, including USG, had the opportunity to check out the new Modern Warfare and speak with Infinity Ward about the process behind developing this year's Call of Duty. You can read our summary of the preview here, but press was essentially shown two distinct portions of Modern Warfare.

The first focuses on a group of Tier 1 Operators as they infiltrate a home to stop a cell of domestic terrorism. We called the sequence "harrowing" and compared it to dramatization of assassinations in films like Zero Dark Thirty.

The emotional complication for this scene arises from the fact that the terrorists disguise themselves as civilians, making it seem like the soldiers are shooting what could be innocent women and children. While there's a potential to just show shocking images for the novelty of it, members of the press did express interest in how the final game tackles these moral ambiguities.

Austin Walker of VICE Gaming was similarly interested in this segment of the Modern Warfare press demo. "It wasn't perfect–there's a moment that uses a baby in a low-hanging fruit way to ratchet up tension... But in that level, I could see the game beyond the fact sheets and the slideshow and the carefully designed taglines," Walker writes. "I was ready and eager to see what else this team would do."

Others like Dean Takahashi from GamesBeat felt otherwise. "I am told that the narrative of the story, which is generally secret, will explain the context for this scene. But as it is, as I've seen it, I found it profoundly disturbing and unjustifiable."

"This might be a confirmed terrorist cell but there's still something uncomfortable about shooting ordinary looking men and women in very ordinary looking rooms," writes Leon Hurley from GamesRadar. Especially when they panic or cry out for help–forcing a moment's hesitation until you realize it's a distraction as they reach for a gun."

The other campaign segment highlights the other side of the global conflict focusing on Farah, a future freedom fighter who in the demo is just a child that must escape soldiers in a fictional Middle Eastern country. Russian soldiers are invading her fictional nation of Urzikstan. Farah, who just saw her father shot down by soldiers, must take her younger brother and stealthily navigate their way out of town, avoiding Russian soldiers. And at the start of it, Farah and her brother kill a soldier. This demo was as provocative as the first, but "a little cloying in its emotional beats," from what we perceived.

This sentiment was more common among the press members present during the demo. "While many war-focused FPS games are eager to highlight 'the horrors of war' in the abstract, very few take critical positions on particular military ventures, least of all America's own," Walker writes of Farah's demo. Walker instead expresses frustration this sequence "could've been ripped from any other FPS in the last month."

Modern Warfare will follow two distinct heroes. | Infinity Ward/Activision

The campaign scenario for this year's Modern Warfare is handled by two ex-Naughty Dog veterans, campaign gameplay director Jacob Minkoff and narrative director Taylor Kurosaki. Both developers cite their work on the Uncharted series, but also films like Last Men in Aleppo and American Sniper as influences for the game's realistic tone. But despite the flashy storytelling and mature action direction, Modern Warfare is still a Call of Duty game.

Infinity Ward also spent a good amount of time talking about the latest standard Call of Duty improvements like enhanced visuals, more realistic weapons, and the new engine powering Modern Warfare. But mixing the directors' pitch that this year's Modern Warfare wants to recontextualize military violence, while also selling it as the latest blockbuster military shooter, might have cheapened the message.

"The overall dramatic effect of the intense scenes should be memorable and artistic. Not gratuitous or base. The developers can fall back on the argument that this is our world. Their game is 'ripped from the headlines.' But this puts us on a slippery slope," concludes Takahashi. "What about school shootings? What about Christchurch? Do we want to put those in video games because they exist in the real world?"

Infinity Ward appears to genuinely want to showcase the mature direction of Call of Duty: Modern Warfare, but it must also be marketed as the next great achievement in the long-running Call of Duty series. That contrast, it seems, is already taking a toll on Modern Warfare's central pitch, because it appears that the two messages cannot exist together cohesively.

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare comes out on October 25 for PlayStation 4, Xbox One, and PC.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Matt Kim

News Editor

Matt Kim is a former freelance writer who's covered video games and digital media. He likes video games as spectacle and is easily distracted by bright lights or clever bits of dialogue. He also once wrote about personal finance, but that's neither here nor there.

Read this next

Blaming Video Games For Gun Violence is a Tired Old Song

We've been here before, and it's never worked out.

Inside Modern Warfare's Push to Rebuild Call of Duty's Multiplayer From the Ground Up

Animation director Mark Grigsby and multiplayer design director Geoffrey Smith break down the huge overhauls in Modern Warfare.

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare Won't Be Going Too Crazy With Colorful Cosmetics, Say Devs

Don't expect neon colored gun skins in this Call of Duty.

The Pros and Cons of Call of Duty: Modern Warfare's Battlefield-Style Maps and Player Counts

From 10v10 to more than 100, Modern Warfare is pushing its player count to the limit, and not necessarily for a battle royale either.

How To Watch Today's Call of Duty: Modern Warfare Multiplayer Reveal

See how Call of Duty is changing the game this year.

More News

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate Character Ban Sets Off Massive Debate

Dragon Quest's Hero is a random character... possibly too random.

Halo Infinite's Creative Director Leaves 343 Industries

This week sees a leadership shake-up for Microsoft's big launch title.

"Stop Asking 'Is It Political?' and Start Asking Instead About the Actual Politics of Each Game"

THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | Also, the things studios of all sizes do to survive, and what happens when that's not enough.

More on PC

What's The Best Video Game Spaceship?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | In honor of No Man's Sky Beyond, let's look back on the coolest spaceships around.

Halo Infinite's Creative Director Leaves 343 Industries

This week sees a leadership shake-up for Microsoft's big launch title.

"Stop Asking 'Is It Political?' and Start Asking Instead About the Actual Politics of Each Game"

THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | Also, the things studios of all sizes do to survive, and what happens when that's not enough.

Destiny 2: Shadowkeep is Axing the Damage Stacking

No more stacking up those auras.

Epic Isn't Budging On Fortnite's Mechs, Despite Player Protests

The massive machines of destruction seem like they're here to stay.

No Man’s Sky Base Building (Beyond Update 2019)

Everything you need to know about Base Building in No Man’s Sky.

More FPS Games

Halo Infinite's Creative Director Leaves 343 Industries

This week sees a leadership shake-up for Microsoft's big launch title.

Classic Doom Ports No Longer Require Bethesda Net Login to Play

That login screen should be fully optional now.

Call of Duty Mobile Release Date - Android, iOS, Battle Royale Details

This is our guide on Call of Duty Mobile, including the release date, platforms including Android and iOS, battle royale details, and more.