Sections

Chase: Cold Case Investigations ~ Distant Memories ~ 3DS Review: Short Story

The successor to defunct developer Cing's emotional adventure games can't help but feel like a pretender to the throne.

Review by Bob Mackey, .

While they only existed for a scant five years in America, I really enjoyed the mopey, talky adventure games produced by the now-defunct Japanese developer Cing. While their puzzles were typically mediocre at best, titles like Hotel Dusk and Last Window carried a listless, melancholy spirit that made them feel incredibly human.

Cing went the way of the dodo back in 2010, but six years later, Taisuke Nanasaki, the director of their Kyle Hyde games—the aforementioned Hotel Dusk and Last Window—has returned to craft a spiritual successor to his unique brand of adventure games. Now working under the auspices of Aksys, and with a much smaller budget, Nanasaki's Chase: Cold Case Investigations sets out to pick up exactly where detective Kyle Hyde left off—albeit with a palette swap doppelganger as the protagonist. But despite how well C:CCI captures the tone of Nanasaki's previous works, the absolutely brain-dead puzzles and unexpectedly abrupt ending make his latest game a supreme disappointment.

As the title implies, Cold Case Investigations centers on unsolved mysteries: crimes abandoned by the authorities due to a complete lack of leads. Our hero Shounosuke Nanase and his assistant take it upon themselves to tackle these impossible mysteries, even if Nanase himself doesn't seem very motivated. The entirety of C:CCI takes place in their cramped office, with Nanase interviewing a series of suspects and mulling over evidence in an attempt to find the truth. While this setting can feel somewhat claustrophobic, Nanase and his assistant keep things lively by bouncing off of each other in an entertaining way: He's rough around the edges with a heart of gold, and she's a consummate professional put off by his unprofessionalism. (Even if he gets the job done.)

In terms of presentation, C:CCI attempts to ape the look of Nanasaki's past games, even if he doesn't quite have the budget this time around—his previous works would typically use live-action actors rotoscoped to look like something straight out of the famous "Take on Me" music video. For the most part, this pretty basic presentation gets the job done, since C:CCI doesn't aspire to be anything more than a glorified visual novel. It's a game almost entirely about conversations, meaning you don't need to see much outside of two characters flapping their lips at one another.

While the step down in presentation from Cing's established standard comes as a bit of a disappointment (though an expected one), the much bigger step down in game design is pretty crushing. Simply put, C:CCI feels like a reading comprehension game: Characters typically figure things out for themselves, though every once in awhile you'll be prompted when one of them forgets a name or a date. Sometimes, there's a bit more deduction involved, but the right answer out of the list of options you're given is always immediately obvious. There's one Ace Attorney-style puzzle that has you investigating a picture of a crime scene, but said picture is so poorly rendered, I ended up brute-forcing it by clicking on every hotspot until I inevitably stumbled upon the right area of that visual mess.

To its credit, C:CCI contains a pretty good locked-room mystery, with plenty of intriguing characters, each with their own possible motives. Unfortunately, much of the atmosphere ends up being lost in the game's poor localization, which opts for a dry and overly literal interpretation of the original Japanese script. Nanase's tendency to repeatedly use the inexplicable phrase "flower language" when referring to what a certain kind of flower symbolizes definitely points to a localization that desperately needs a second pass. Coming off of an extremely well localized game like Ace Attorney: Spirit of Justice, C:CCI couldn't help but feel like a product of an entirely different era.

Despite the poor localization, C:CCI had me slightly hooked for its first ninety minutes—so I was kind of shocked to discover those are its only ninety minutes. To say C:CCI ends abruptly would be a major understatement: What's contained in this digital release feels like the prologue of a much larger game, to the point where it establishes mysteries about Nanase's past that never see a resolution. I'd be slightly less disappointed if C:CCI presented itself as an episodic game, but as far as I know, that's all she wrote. In its current form, C:CCI comes off as a polished-up prototype for a full game Nanasaki couldn't successfully pitch to a publisher.

Occasionally, moments of Cing's former brilliance shine through in C:CCI, but these redeeming qualities are often drowned out by the low budget, bad localization, and thoughtless design. Director Nanasaki thrived in the DS era, where an extremely popular platform looking to find an audience outside of the traditional "gamer" allowed him to produce big, beautiful games full of strange ideas. With Cold Case Investigations, though, we have a clear case of a creative force struggling to adapt.

The Nitty Gritty

  • Interface: You won't be doing more than reading dialogue and occasionally making a selection, and Cold Case Investigations makes this pretty effortless.
  • Lasting appeal: With no alternate narrative branches or alternate endings, there's really no reason to give this adventure a second go.
  • Sound: The great, moody soundtrack amounts to the most redeemable element of Cold Case Investigations.
  • Visuals: For the most part, the visuals get the job done—you don't need to do much to convincingly render a conversation between two people.

While the brilliance of its director's past games occasionally surface in Cold Case Investigations, this thoughtlessly designed and incredibly brief adventure will do nothing but disappoint fans of the defunct developer Cing.

2 /5

Chase: Cold Case Investigations ~ Distant Memories ~ 3DS Review: Short Story Bob Mackey The successor to defunct developer Cing's emotional adventure games can't help but feel like a pretender to the throne. 2016-10-17T16:30:00-04:00 2 5

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Comments 8

Comments on this article are now closed. Thanks for taking part!

  • Avatar for highkingconchobhar #1 highkingconchobhar 2 years ago
    Spot on. If anything, I think you may have been _too kind_ to the game; I found the cold case angle to be contrived and pointless, since the central mystery was so straightforward and predictable. Like, it seems the only reason it was never solved is because nobody bothered!
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Ghopper101 #2 Ghopper101 2 years ago
    I had no idea this was a thing until I saw this review. It's disappointing to see such a lackluster game descended from such great pedigree.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for JackLeveledUp #3 JackLeveledUp 2 years ago
    This seems like it would've been a great game to have had a Kickstarter. There's a strong cult following behind Hotel Dusk, and I'm sure they wouldn't need to ask for a huge amount of money in order to fund the game.

    It's a shame this isn't any kind of glorious comeback, but maybe it'll sell well enough to keep everything on life support for another shot.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for FalcoT #4 FalcoT 2 years ago
    Too bad, Hotel Dusk and the Europe only sequel are prohibitively expensive : (
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for link6616 #5 link6616 2 years ago
    @FalcoT It might not be your cup of tea, but if you can accept cart only copies, you can get hotel dusk pretty cheaply. (I got my copy for $2.50, legitimate). Last Window is another story of course. Very glad I made the call to buy it when I did.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for orient #6 orient 2 years ago
    It was more of a 3 star game for me. I thought the music and atmosphere were great and found the mystery intriguing. It felt like a strong start to a longer game. I just hope we get more cases.

    The localisation is a little dry but I wouldn't call it bad. It lacks the descriptive flavour of Hotel Dusk but it does a good job of getting the characters across. "Flower language" is the only weird thing in there and I think he says it like twice.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for swamped #7 swamped 2 years ago
    Oh no! How disappointing. I really like to support this type of game but 90 minutes is a hard sell.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Ladypyramidhead #8 Ladypyramidhead A month ago
    I just beat the game a few minutes ago and I honestly thought the whole thing was a tutorial when I was playing it. Then it ended.
    I looked, confused for another chapter in the main menu, reloaded the game to make sure I didn't just randomly get a bad ending... But nothing.

    This review is pretty on point, I think the only thing going for it is atmosphere and animation.

    (To be fair, "flower language" isn't a mistranslation, it is a language that many countries share or have their own versions. For example we all know what a red rose means when you give them to someone. It's a way of expressing your feelings subtly.)
    Sign in to Reply

Comments

Close