Destiny 2: Forsaken's Gambit Mode Almost Didn't Have PvP

Destiny 2: Forsaken's Gambit Mode Almost Didn't Have PvP

Senior technical designer Peter Sarrett from Bungie gave a talk at GDC 2019 detailing the development of Destiny 2: Forsaken's Gambit mode.

When Destiny 2's third expansion Forsaken dropped last fall, some said that it put Destiny 2 on the path to redemption. A lot of that was credited to its new mode Gambit, which blends PvE with PvP—a first for the series. While Gambit was bumpy at launch, it's become a fan favorite activity for both hardcore and casual players of Destiny 2. At the Game Developers Conference in San Francisco, California today, senior technical designer Peter Sarrett from Bungie described how the team approached, what he calls, is Destiny 2's Halo Firefight meets Super Puzzle Fighter.

For a clever four-versus-four PvEvP mode where players gather "motes" dropped by waves of enemies, deposit the motes into a central bank, and invade another side to ruin the other team's day, it's surprising to learn that the "versus players" part almost didn't happen. But at the inception of development of Gambit, "no direct player interaction" was actually a core design pillar in a list of many. Gambit, at first, was set to only be PvE.

"We wanted to have longer legs than Prison of Elders," Sarrett told the GDC 2019 crowd at his talk, describing Prison of Elders' replayability in its fixed arenas where players faced mobs of AI, though it did grow stale over time. "We wanted to be fresher than that."

There needed to be some interaction, something players could do to affect the other four-person team of Guardians beyond emoting dramatically at the Ready Room lobby at the start of a match. Sarrett described this necessary element as "interferences," which went through many models before Invasion came to be. Scrapped interferences included summoning web mines, using flashbangs, sending ogres to the other side that players would be able to control, removing cover from the enemy side, obscuring their vision, and just starving their ammo. Yet, nothing quite worked.

"[We knew people would ask] 'why can't I shoot the other guys?' We didn't have an answer for that," Sarrett said. So Bungie tested the Invasion mechanic, where a player is able to "invade" the enemy side for a limited time (or until they're killed) after depositing 25 or 50 motes in their bank, which opens up a portal for the deemed invader. Immediately, playtesters loved Invasion. "It was clearly our secret sauce for this mode," he said. "We succeeded by failing," he added later in the talk, on casting away the design pillar.

Also during the talk, Sarrett talked about how the mote design came to be, which began as something similar to in-game engrams. In testing though, Bungie found it was tedious when they would roll down hills with their dice-like shape. They were also at one time a glowing red color, which drove players in the opposite direction as they thought the motes were bombs, not things to be collected. (An impulse that Sarrett said is not surprising, in retrospect.)

Season of the Drifter is currently underway in Destiny 2, which focuses on the character The Drifter who hosts the Gambit mode. It brought with it Gambit Prime, a new version of Gambit mode with each player choosing a specific role to play rather than the loose, non-dictated structure of the launch version (such as Sentry, a guard to the bank). Season of the Drifter is also ushering in new maps for Gambit.

Gambit has become a big part of Destiny 2's revival after a rough post-launch year, and will surely remain a key part of it for the months to come.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Caty McCarthy

Features Editor

Caty McCarthy is a former freelance writer whose work has appeared in Kill Screen, VICE, The AV Club, Kotaku, Polygon, and IGN. When she's not blathering into a podcast mic, reading a book, or playing a billion video games at once, she's probably watching Terrace House or something. She is currently USgamer's official altgame enthusiast.

Read this next

Destiny 2 Shadowkeep Exotics List - All New Exotic Weapons and Armor for Shadowkeep

This is our guide to all the new Shadowkeep Exotics, including weapons and armor, featured in Destiny 2 Shadowkeep.

Destiny 2 Moon Lost Sector Locations - Where to Find All Lost Sectors on the Moon

Need a guide detailing all the Destiny 2 Moon Lost Sector locations? You've come to the right place.

Destiny 2 Upgrade Modules - Where to Find Upgrade Modules Quickly

Need to find Upgrade Modules in Destiny 2 quickly? We've got you covered.

Destiny 2: Shadowkeep's Campaign Ending Has Major Implications For What's Next

The future of Destiny 2 sounds very, very interesting.

Destiny 2: Shadowkeep Review: Moon's Haunted and So Is My Playtime

The lack of new loot and a so-so campaign weighs down an otherwise solid expansion for Destiny 2.

Destiny 2 Vex Offensive Walkthrough - How to Complete Eyes on the Moon and Unlock the Vex Offensive

Here's how to unlock the new Destiny 2 Vex Offensive activity, through completing the Eyes on the Moon quest.

Destiny 2 Weekly Reset Times - When is the Weekly Reset?

Here's the complete Destiny 2 weekly reset times schedule for regions around the world.

More News

The Good Version of Sonic the Hedgehog Is Coming to Super Monkey Ball

The HD remake of Super Monkey Ball's Wii installment is getting a classic, blue-quilled bonus.

Control Gets a Free Photo Mode Update Tomorrow

Document your time as the Director of the Federal Bureau of Control.

Google Sets Stadia's Official Launch Date and Shows Off Its UI

Games are coming to Google pretty soon.

Divinity: Fallen Heroes is On Indefinite Hiatus Due to Lack of Time and Resources

Larian Studios and Logic Artists were originally targeting Fallen Heroes for a November 2019 release.

More on PC

The Good Version of Sonic the Hedgehog Is Coming to Super Monkey Ball

The HD remake of Super Monkey Ball's Wii installment is getting a classic, blue-quilled bonus.

Control Gets a Free Photo Mode Update Tomorrow

Document your time as the Director of the Federal Bureau of Control.

Divinity: Fallen Heroes is On Indefinite Hiatus Due to Lack of Time and Resources

Larian Studios and Logic Artists were originally targeting Fallen Heroes for a November 2019 release.

Fortnite Upgrade Bench - How to Upgrade Your Weapons

Here's how to use the new Upgrade Benches in Fortnite, so you can upgrade your weapons.

Fortnite Medals List - How to Earn Them, When Does the Punchcard Refresh?

Here's our guide explaining the new Fortnite Medals, and how you can earn them easily.

Fortnite Chapter 2 Map Overview - Named Locations and Landmarks on the New Fortnite Map

Here's our full guide to the Fortnite Chapter 2 map, including a list of all named locations and new landmarks.

Fortnite Battle Royale XP Guide - How to Earn XP and Level Up Quickly

Here's how to earn XP in Fortnite Battle Royale as quickly as possible.

More FPS Games

Google Sets Stadia's Official Launch Date and Shows Off Its UI

Games are coming to Google pretty soon.

Blizzard Cancels Overwatch Switch Launch Event Amid Ongoing Public Backlash

The Nintendo New York event has been abruptly cancelled.

Apex Legends Halloween Event Release Date - All the New Halloween Skins

Here's our guide to the Apex Legends Halloween event release date, as well as global start times, and all new Halloween skins so far.

Halo Infinite Lead Producer Leaves 343 Industries Two Months After Taking Charge on Campaign

A 343 representative says the departure isn't a sign of a "creative dilemma."