Does Detroit Become Human's David Cage Actually Know What His Game is About?

Does Detroit Become Human's David Cage Actually Know What His Game is About?

The video game director and writer is unclear about his upcoming game.

For what it's worth, I think French video game developer David Cage is a storyteller with lots of ambition. Whether or not that ambition translates into good video games is up for debate. What isn't up for debate, but will spark one soon I imagine, is Cage's rather odd remarks regarding his upcoming title, Detroit: Become Human. It appears that Cage has been giving contradictory remarks about Detroit's story, leading to questions about whether or not Cage even knows what his own game is actually about.

The confusion stems from two interviews David Cage did with two different outlets at E3 last week. While talking about Detroit's central story and potential social commentary, Cage appears to have gone on record to give two different, seemingly contradictory, answers. When Cage spoke to The Verge about Detroit, he told the media outlet, "People will see [Detroit: Become Human] as, 'Oh this is about androids and the revolution,' and honestly I don't think this is the story I wrote."

However, when he spoke to Kotaku about the same game, Cage said, "The story I'm telling is really about androids... They're discovering emotions and wanting to be free. If people want to see parallels with this or that, that's fine with me. But my story's about androids who want to be free." Reading those two interviews back-to-back Cage essentially says that his story is either about androids or humans, but not both.

The problem then ultimately becomes what Cage actually wants to say through his video game (that’s either about android or humans). Unfortunately, Cage seems to have also gone on record to say that he doesn’t really want to say anything at all. Talking to Waypoint this time, Cage explains (again) “I didn’t want to deliver a message to mankind with this game. I just want to ask questions.” This line is actually one of the more consistent talking points for Cage across all three interviews, where the director claims he is simply content to ask questions rather than delivering any message at all.

So then why should anyone bother playing a game that has no discernable message or consistent narrative engine? Anybody can ask questions about this or that, but Cage appears to be either deliberately avoiding taking any position on topics like society or race, or is unsure about what exactly he wants to say about those things in the first place. In either case, it doesn’t do Detroit any favors by selling gamers an uncertain vision that could either be about humanity—or not—or simply be just a series of philosophical questions with no resolution.

Update: Added a link to @Nibellion who has been tweeting publically about the situation

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Matt Kim

News Editor

Matt Kim is a former freelance writer who's covered video games and digital media. He likes video games as spectacle and is easily distracted by bright lights or clever bits of dialogue. He also once wrote about personal finance, but that's neither here nor there.

Read this next

Quantic Dream Co-Founder Says You Can Expect "Different Genres" From The Studio in the Future

Co-founder Guillaume de Fondaumière gives hints about the studio's future at Gamescom.

"Eventually, All of Our Games Will Be Safely in the Cloud Too and We'll Feel Great About It"

THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | Google responds to legitimate concerns about Stadia by talking to would-be customers like they are toddlers.

Detroit: Become Human Guide - Tips, Tricks and Controls

Detroit: Become Human Romance guide, Best Endings, Voice actors, and more.

Detroit, Beyond, and Heavy Rain Coming to PC on the Epic Games Store

Quantic Dream's titles finally drop their PlayStation exclusivity.

More News

Microsoft Sees Decreased Hardware Sales as This Console Generation Comes to a Close

As we near the end of a console generation, Microsoft is touting success on the services side.

How to Play The Outer Worlds For $5, And Get a Chalupa in the Process

For the price of a chalupa combo (yes, really), you can get some time with Xbox Game Pass.

WWE 2K20: How It Went So Wrong

A longtime developer's departure might have been the writing on the wall.

More on PlayStation 4

Fallout 76 Just Threw Out Months of Goodwill in a Single Day

With the announcement of a subscription service, Fallout 76 tosses a fire bomb at its community.

WWE 2K20: How It Went So Wrong

A longtime developer's departure might have been the writing on the wall.

How a New California Law Could Pave the Return of EA's NCAA Football Games

EA CEO Andrew Wilson says he'd "jump for the opportunity" to license with the NCAA again.

MediEvil Review: Sometimes Dead is Better

MediEvil is revived for our modern era, but we question if it should've been.

The Final Fantasy 15 Novel Collecting Canceled DLC Has Been Delayed for English Readers

The break of dawn has been pushed back a bit for English audiences.

Battlefield 5's War in the Pacific Update Is Bringing Back the Series' Best Map

It's been a long, long time since Battlefield has revisited Wake Island.