DOOM 3 and the Challenge of Living up to Your Own Legacy

DOOM 3 and the Challenge of Living up to Your Own Legacy

How do you top the achievement of changing video games forever? For id Software, the answer was to change directions entirely.

The '90s were defined by big games — Sonic! Street Fighter! Mortal Kombat! Resident Evil! Final Fantasy VII! Gran Turismo! Mario 64! — but id Software's DOOM has a pretty good claim on being the biggest game of the decade.

I remember the first time I ever saw DOOM being played by some friends in the office nook of their dorm room; the gore turned me off, but I couldn't help but be transfixed by the incredible "3D" graphics on display... not to mention envy them, since I'd decided to study graphic design and journalism, and the game wouldn't be available for years on my expensive Mac, the industry-standard tool for people of my chosen field of study. DOOM hit the video game world with megaton impact, the ripples of its arrival changing everything. It was neither the first first-person shooter nor even the most ambitious of its era, but its blazing fast pace, irreverent heavy-metal aesthetics, and engrossing competitive play made it transcendent. The term "first-person shooter" wouldn't come along for several years; until then, everything was just a "DOOM clone."

WATCH: Looking back at DOOM 3.

The problem with changing the world is that once you've done it, everyone keeps an eye on your next accomplishment and expects you to top yourself again and again. It's a tall order for anyone to create a revolutionary work, but even more unlikely to expect them to do it systemically. We see it all the time with Nintendo — seriously, isn't it enough that Shigeru Miyamoto has designed more than half a dozen medium-defining video games? — and it's something id faced when it came time to produce a proper follow-up to DOOM more than a decade later. The FPS had evolved considerably in that time, presenting id with a mighty challenge of their own making: How to top a host of games building off their ideas? Heck, the biggest FPS of the late '90s, Half-Life, ran on id's own Quake engine.

Their solution? Go in a completely different direction. Where the original DOOM was a breakneck shooter, 2004's DOOM 3 felt more like survival horror. Set in stifling corridors shrouded in darkness, DOOM 3 showed off John Carmack's impressive light-casting technology, and the way it forced players to make either-or choices between light or firepower heightened the tension considerably. It was a remarkable piece of work... and a bold attempt to reinvent a classic. But not an entirely successful one, as players chafed at contrivances like cheap, teleporting monster ambushes and the fact that the heroic space marine couldn't figure out how to use light and guns at the same time. You have to admire id for making a go of it, but the fact the DOOM 4 will be going more in the direction of "big, dumb, fast-paced shooter" probably says it all.

Honestly, DOOM 3 reminds me a lot of all those Nintendo Entertainment System sequels that totally threw out the style of their legendary predecessors in favor of trying something new. Like Zelda II. I suppose starting from scratch is a natural instinct for successful game designers who don't want to be pigeonholed... and I suspect giving in and returning to the classic format is the successful designer's natural acceptance of the fact that gamers don't necessarily care for change.

For more of This Day in Video Game History, check out the series hub and subscribe to our YouTube channel!

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Read this next

What Retro Game Do You Still Play Regularly?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | Mario 3? Planescape Torment? StarCraft? We want to know what classic games are still in your regular rotation.

Trials of Mana Interview: The Developers on Topping the Fan Translation and the Possibility of New Mana Games

"[T]he localization team took a look at the translation and the first thing they said was, 'We're going to show them up.'"

Oninaki Review

Oh now feel it, comin' back again.

The Pride Flag in Marvel's Spider-Man is a Small Gesture That's Made a Large Impact

THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | Pride flags in Marvel's Spider-Man, edits to Yakuza re-releases, and an Ion Fury backtrack show publisher actions speaking louder than words

Remnant: From the Ashes is Quickly Becoming 2019's Breakout Hit

A multiplayer Souls-shooter is picking up steam.

More

On 50 Cent: Blood on the Sand, The Surprisingly Excellent Third-Person Shooter That History Forgot

For 50 Cent: Blood on the Sand's 10th anniversary this year, we give it a long overdue reappraisal.

Final Fantasy 8 Was Always Good

Reexamining one of the most divisive games in the series on its 20th anniversary.

How Crash Team Racing Challenged Mario Kart and Made Naughty Dog What It Is Today

We look back on the kart racing hit with Naughty Dog's co-founders and Crash Team Racing's lead artist.

From Super Fan to Producer: An Insider's Perspective on Silent Hill

GUEST POST | A Silent Hill producer reflects on what drew him to the perennially haunted series, and what it was like to work on it during its troubled years.