Sections

Dragon Quest XI Director Acknowledges the Harm of Crunch, Suggests AI Might Help Reduce it Someday

A stressed-out workforce appears! Command?

News by Nadia Oxford, .

"Crunch" is the term used for the period of long workdays leading up to a game's final development deadline. "Crunch" also accurately what happens to some developers' souls when they're glued to their computers for hours at a time to get the job done—especially if a crunch period extends past a few weeks (which is often does).

Crunch has always been a heated discussion topic in the industry, but it's been near the forefront of the news since Rockstar co-founder Dan Houser boasted about Red Dead Redemption II developers working 100-hour weeks in an interview last month. Houser walked back on the boast following backlash, but like many triple-A game publishers, Rockstar doesn't have a reputation for offering its employees a sensible work-life balance.

Waypoint's Aron Garst recently asked several game developers in Japan and Europe about their thoughts on crunch culture, and what they do to combat it (if they do at all). The document, published today, has considerable insight from Hokuto Okamoto and Takeshi Uchikawa, the producer and game director respectively for Square-Enix's critically-acclaimed RPG, Dragon Quest XI. The pair acknowledges the harmful effects of crunch, but also says the game's developers, all Dragon Quest fans, understand crunch is inevitable.

Okamoto and Uchikawa say Square Enix encourages its developers to go home and rest during periods when crunch makes it easy to lose track of time. They also say the team used an Unreal engine plugin when making Dragon Quest XI, which cut down on necessary bug-hunting. But Uchikawa admits despite Square Enix's efforts, some developers worked days that stretched beyond 12 hours.

"Most members of the team joined as fans. They love the series, they play it, and they have really strong motivations," Uchikawa tells Garst. "They are also used to making the series, since many of them have done it for years over several iterations. So there is a strong team cohesion to make the game as good as we possibly can in the time provided."

When Garst asks if Okamoto or Uchikawa are worried developers "[p]utting in tons of extra hours that might make their health suffer or even harm the quality of the work they put into the game," Okamoto asks "I don't understand, how could them putting in more work hurt the quality?" Garst clarifies: "I think what I was trying to say was is there anything you do to make sure their passion isn’t manipulated? Even if it’s not intentional?" to which Uchikawa responds, "Square Enix would never do anything like that, although sometimes we will say ‘if you love the game, are you really ok with being this quality?’"

Okamoto and Uchikawa say they're aware long work hours is a big problem in Japanese society, and they believe video game crunch time will likely reduce when AI is robust enough to tackle the tedious job of bug-testing. Dragon Quest XI came to North America in September.

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Comments 4

  • Avatar for LBD_Nytetrayn #1 LBD_Nytetrayn 12 days ago
    "I don't understand, how could them putting in more work hurt the quality?"

    It's called "fatigue," you walnut!!
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for AceOfCakez #2 AceOfCakez 12 days ago
    Well, I always knew that working long hours in Japan was fairly normal for them over there. I know Square Enix has been doing it since Final Fantasy VII. Now that it's been brought to light here, I wonder if this will have any sort of effect on Japan's work culture; probably not.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for docexe #3 docexe 12 days ago
    @AceOfCakez Yeah, overworking is actually a big problem in Japanese corporate culture, and not only in the videogame industry but in general. There are reports of people outright dying from working too many hours.

    Unfortunately, I think it will require a pretty big cultural shift there before the problem is addressed constructively.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Dorchadas #4 Dorchadas 12 days ago
    "I don't understand, how could them putting in more work hurt the quality?"

    Sounds like the Japanese education system, too. "If studying for four hours is good, studying for eight hours is twice as good."

    yontougoraku.
    Sign in to Reply

Comments

Close