EA Says That FIFA Ultimate Team is Not Gambling, Working to Stop Illegal Resellers

EA responds as you'd expect to loot box claims.

News by Matt Kim, .

Loot boxes have become one of the video game industry's most hot-button topics. Several companies like Blizzard, Valve, PUBG Corp. and EA are under the magnifying glass from legislators domestically and in Europe who are looking to investigate loot boxes. During today's financial earnings call EA pushes back on gambling claims related to FIFA Ultimate Team.

During an investors Q&A with EA executives, one person in the call asked EA CEO Andrew Wilson the company's position on the ongoing investigation into loot boxes as gambling in Europe. Belgium recently found EA's FIFA 18 in violation of its gambling rules and announced that it will be working with EA and other video game companies on how to fix these mechanics.

FIFA 18 was one of the game's cited by Belgium in its gambling decision.

Wilson didn't detail any potential changes or solutions. Instead he brought up how EA is working with various organization bodies to push back on FIFA Ultimate Team's label as a gambling mechanic. "We're working with all the [video game] industry associations globally and with regulators in various jursidtictions and territories. Many of whom we have been working with for some time and who have evaluated and established that programs FIFA Ultimate Team are not gambling."

Wilson added that EA doesn't "authorize" ways to cash out the company's digital currency for real-world money, and that EA "actively seek to eliminate where that's going on in an illegal environment." Wilson says that because ther is no real-world value associated with Ultimate Team, the mechanic isn't gambling.

Of course as our sister site Eurogamer found last year, you can certainly cash out in Ultimate Team for real money. Thereby giving value to Ultimate Team via third-party channels.

Loot boxes have come under heavy scrutiny in Europe. The Netherlands also recently ruled that loot boxes ran against the country's gambling laws and will try and enact changes into loot box mechanics for its players. It's unclear exactly how video game companies will react to these findings, but it's clear that the decisions are no laughing matter.

As we've covered before, the loot box conversation has already affected game development on titles with loot boxes. One developer has already looked at the current loot box landscape and made decisions on how to monetize the game based on the current climate.

Even EA, which kickstarted the loot box debate with Star Wars Battlefront 2, has reacted by fundamentally changing how progression and loot work in Battlefront 2. Other games targeted by European legislators include Counter-Strike: Global Offensive, Overwatch, and PUBG.

To learn more about FIFA 18 Ultimate Team check out our complete Ultimate Team guide for the full details.

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Related Tags

Comments 4

Comments on this article are now closed. Thanks for taking part!

  • Avatar for Fourfoldroot #1 Fourfoldroot 6 months ago
    No real world value? Then how come they take peoples real world money?

    This was obviously going to be the response when the soft "it's gambling because you can cash out on third party sites" argument was raised.

    Its gambling because you pay real world money in the hopes of getting things that aren't guaranteed and, in fact, have vanishingly small chances of being delivered.

    Hopefully EAs ridiculous loophole will be closed and we can once more get games that don't encourage further real money spending.

    Incidentally, it's clearly kids who are the gamblers in Fifa. The rest of us know that, for the most part, the best players are not the biggest names, just those with the most pace and strength.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for riot-50 #2 riot-50 6 months ago
    I'm gonna guess that all of those years of trying to wring every single dollar humanly possible out of their customers is finally, finally gonna come bite EA on the ass with this one.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for chaoticBeat #3 chaoticBeat 6 months ago
    Thank god it's not gambling. I'm so happy that we can trust them!

    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for steveanders #4 steveanders 2 months ago
    @Fourfoldroot What they mean is "it's not real world gambling because we don't want it to be".
    Sign in to Reply