"Eventually, All of Our Games Will Be Safely in the Cloud Too and We'll Feel Great About It"

"Eventually, All of Our Games Will Be Safely in the Cloud Too and We'll Feel Great About It"

THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | Google responds to legitimate concerns about Stadia by talking to would-be customers like they are toddlers.

This Week in Business is a collection of stats and quotes from our sister site GamesIndustry.biz that sheds light on console sales, new trends, and more. Check back every Friday for a new entry!

Let's mix it up a little this week. Read the first quote and then meet me in the paragraph after it.

QUOTE | "We get this a lot. I hear you. Moving to the cloud is scary. I felt the same way when music was transitioning from files to streaming… The same happened to Movies and Photos and my Docs and other files... and it's great! Games are no different. Eventually, all of our games will be safely in the cloud too and we'll feel great about it. We've been investing a ton in tech, infrastructure and partnerships over the past few years. Nothing in life is certain, but we're committed to making Stadia a success." - Google Stadia director of product Andrey Doronichev responds in a Reddit AMA session when a user asks what would happen to their Stadia purchases if Google were to discontinue the service.

OK, back with me now? That quote is stuck in my craw. It bothers me for a couple reasons. First, it's condescending. It doesn't read like a representative of a global tech giant explaining the virtues of their new attempt at disrupting a global industry that pulls in more than $100 billion annually. It reads like Mister Rogers comforting a four-year-old getting ready for the first day of school. Only instead of trying to build a more caring world for everyone, this Mister Rogers wants to sell me sweet, sweet murder simulators.

Second, it doesn't answer the question. Doronichev doesn't explicitly say what will happen if Google decides to get out of the Stadia business. The answer, presumably, is that players lose access to any games they purchased through Stadia, and Doronichev is certainly not giving out assurances that they will be able to download those games for free or get refunded or anything like that. The best he can say is that players are able to download their games' metadata and save files.

It doesn't take a whole lot of work to read between the lines and realize that customers are out of luck if Google decides to pull the plug, but Doronichev's answer is built on the assumption that on-demand game streaming is an inevitability, and the insistence that Google is committed to making Stadia a success. It completely ignores the significant hurdles facing on-demand game streaming, and Google's own track record of wavering commitment when it wades into an established market and finds little demand for its offering. (Google+ says hello.)

Jumping on board the streaming bandwagon, especially with the business model Google has chosen for Stadia, is a leap of faith. And it doesn't inspire much faith in me to have the people responsible for the project dismissing legitimate concerns, talking down to the people who express them, and tapdancing around the reality that there is no permanence to on-demand streaming, that the games you "buy" can only be played as long as the business on the other end feels it's worth it to keep running servers in the cloud. If that business ever folds, or if running those servers ever stops making financial sense (and without mandatory subscription fees, that's a massive concern), the plug gets pulled and the customers will in all likelihood come away with exactly what Doronichev's answer was worth: nothing.

QUOTE | "As you know, the Yogscast expects the highest levels of professionalism from its talent and that it is central to the company and its ethos that our fans and community are considered first." - Two weeks ago, Yogscast CEO Mark 'Turps' Turpin explains why the game streaming collective fired content creator Matthew "Caff" Meredith after eight women (including multiple Yogscast employees) came forward with allegations he used his position to pursue sexual relationships with people he had power or influence over.

QUOTE | "I have sent some inappropriate messages to several members of our community and I'm deeply embarrassed about this error of judgement." - This week, Yogscast CEO Mark 'Turps' Turpin explains why he is resigning from the company.

QUOTE | "In the past, YouTubers were very problematic for us, because players were watching those videos thinking, 'Okay, I've got the story, I don't need to play the game, I know what it's about.'" - Quantic Dream's David Cage, on a panel with Hazelight Studios' Josef Fares, where both developers said YouTube Let's Plays and Twitch streams were beneficial to their games despite fears that people wouldn't buy story-based games that could just be watched online.

QUOTE | "The additional contributions—no matter how large or small—from anyone within the HitRecord community are completely voluntary, and are meant to give them a chance to have their own creative expressions included in the game." - Ubisoft defends its partnership with HitRecord for Watch Dogs Legion, where any number of musicians will create finished songs for inclusion of the game, and then the publisher will pick 10 of them and give each song's creative team $2,000 to split between them.

QUOTE | "From store concepts that offer competitive sessions in home-grown e-Leagues to locations that sell strictly retro gaming software and hardware, GameStop will pilot the new store concepts in a select market to present something new to players both old and new, and searching for experiences in gaming beyond the console." - Specialty retailer GameStop lays out its strategy for the future after a particularly rough year that has seen its stock drop from more than $17 per share to a low just over $4.

Kind Words is a game about writing nice letters to real people, all from a cozy room with some chill lo-fi beats to listen to. | Popcannibal

QUOTE | "We have had no help, no guidance, love or support. It's a black box they operate in, and I get that at such a size they are now it's probably impossible to do more, but every major change they've made in the past four to five years has been at the cost of helping developers and pretty much every new change has hurt them." - MidBoss CEO Cade Peterson is one of a dozen indies who weighed in on the current state of Valve's discoverability problems on Steam.

QUOTE | "With Elegy for a Dead World, we didn't have a whole lot of trolls. My suspicion is that this was because it wasn't a fun surface to graffiti. You paid to be there, and it's a classy area and so few people are reading what other people write, you don't have an audience. It's like standing alone in a room with a beautiful painting and saying something mean to it. Like, who cares?" - Ziba Scott talks about designing around trolls in 2014's Elegy for a Dead World and his latest game, Kind Words (lo fi chill beats to write to).

QUOTE | "As a whole, the era of tricking people into spending money is probably gone. I think games got away with that for a while, but I think we're in a place where we're following the rules, being compliant and being transparent with players about what they're getting into." - Jake Neri, executive producer on Glu Mobile's free-to-play RPG Disney Sorcerer's Arena, talks about making a game using Disney's vast library of IP and not targeting it at players under 13.

QUOTE | "Without persuasive evidence that a novel restriction on content is part of a long (if heretofore unrecognized) tradition of proscription, a legislature may not revise the 'judgment [of] the American people,' embodied in the First Amendment, 'that the benefits of its restrictions on the Government outweigh the costs.' That holding controls this case." - Justice Antonin Scalia sides with the games industry in 2011 in the Supreme Court's majority opinion deciding the legal battle over a California violent games law. The US absolutely has a tradition of restricting gambling among children, which is just one reason a fight over loot boxes may play out very differently.

STAT | $436 million - Detective Pikachu's worldwide box office gross to date, edging out the $433 million posted by Warcraft to become the highest grossing movie based on a specific video game yet. (Movies about games have still done better; Wreck-It Ralph did $471 million worldwide and its sequel Ralph Breaks the Internet managed $529 million, according to Box Office Mojo. Somehow the Fred Savage phenomenon The Wizard only managed $14 million domestically, but if we account for inflation and assume it was huge overseas, that's gotta still be number one, right?)

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Brendan Sinclair

North American Editor

Brendan joined GamesIndustry International in 2012. Based in Toronto, Ontario, he was previously senior news editor at CBS-owned GameSpot in the US.

Read this next

Quantic Dream Condemned by French Court for Failing to Meet Security Obligation

An employee will receive some compensation for the spread of Photoshopped images.

Do Delays Reduce Game Developer Stress, or Simply Extend It?

THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | With The Last of Us Part 2 and Watch Dogs: Legion slipping, the first quarter of 2020 suddenly looks a lot lighter for game releases.

Ubisoft Delays Three Games, Including Watch Dogs Legion, to Beyond March 2020

The publisher attributes it to how this year's games panned out.

Watch Dogs, Far Cry 3: Blood Dragon, and More Set to Get Animated Series

They'll be a little more family-friendly, though.

Quantic Dream Co-Founder Says You Can Expect "Different Genres" From The Studio in the Future

Co-founder Guillaume de Fondaumière gives hints about the studio's future at Gamescom.

Watch Dogs Legion Stadia, Release Date, Map, Gameplay - Everything We Know

This is our guide to the Watch Dogs Legion release date, map of London, gameplay reveal, and more.

More News

If You're Bad at Tetris 99, You Can Now Squad Up For Help

The puzzle-battle royale hybrid just got friendlier.

Resident Evil's Newest Survivor is a Living Homage to "Jill Sandwich"

Martin should probably stay away from small rooms with descending ceilings.

The CEO of Japanese Indie Publisher Dangen Entertainment Resigns As Allegations of Harassment Mount

Ben Judd is stepping back from the publisher he helped found, as well as his "other industry endeavors."

More on Google Stadia

Google Defends 4K, 60 FPS Claims For Stadia While Placing Responsibility on Developers

"We expect that many developers can, and in most cases will, continue to improve their games on Stadia."

Cyberpunk 2077 Likely Won't Come to PS5 or Scarlett Around Launch

Keanu's only got eyes for the current gen.

"Stadia Nailed the Impossible, and Then Failed the Possible"

THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | A time of technological transitions for companies like Google, Valve, Game Freak, Microsoft, Sony, and more.

Red Dead Redemption 2's Frame Rate and Resolution Come Up Short on Stadia

Digital Foundry went deep on Red Dead's two streaming modes for Stadia.

More Action Adventure Games

For Axiom Verge's Creator, the Switch Was a "Natural Platform" For the Sequel

Thomas Happ answers our most pressing questions about today's announcement.

Assassin's Creed: The Rebel Collection Shows the Series Can Shine on Switch

This great collection highlights a potential direction for the Assassin's Creed franchise.

Starting Screen | Tyrants, Dollhouses, and Rude Geese: Looking Back on 2019's Great Gaming Moments

There were some great moments in video games this year. Let's look back on some of our favorites.