Far Cry 5's Conflicting Tones Never Really Meet

Far Cry 5's Conflicting Tones Never Really Meet

There's nothing wrong with providing different moods in one story, but they have to feel like they fit together.

Mood is an aesthetic choice in storytelling. It's not the frame or walls of the story, that's in the plot and themes of the work. Mood is the paint on the walls, it's the feeling of a story. You can think of it as the context of game, movie or television show. You can play out the same situation as a serious tragedy or a light comedy depending on how you establish the mood. It's a matter of what the creator is trying to accomplish with their story.

What mood do you think this is trying to reach?

You'll hear this wrapped up in the concept of tone (as I did in the headline), but mood and tone are actually two different ideas. Tone is how the narrator feels about the story being presented, mood is how the reader feels about it. To use an example from an outside source:

"Let's say you have an unreliable narrator who happens to be a serial killer. He or she may use a matter-of-fact, or even humorous tone when depicting events. As the reader, the tone may make you feel uncomfortable, unsettled, or weirded out– that's the mood! And that's also an extreme example. Generally, if the narrator can be trusted, the mood and the tone will be similar," says NY Book Editors.

In games, the narrator is generally trusted because what you see is what you get. Mood and tone are frequently the same, hence we tend to talk in terms of tone.

While this is a totally different mood.

Far Cry 5 is a game of wildly different tones, changing between comical and deadly serious. In one moment, you can be helping the director the action film Blood Dragon 3 keep his set quiet. In the next, you're hearing a psychopath discuss sin and the power of moving through your pain via self-mutilation, after seeing the evidence of his torture. The time between pulling off an Evel Knievel-style daredevil stunt and listening to a long tale of cannibalism involving small children can potentially be a few minutes at best.

There's nothing wrong with this. Games, films, and comics can absolutely have shifting moods over the course of telling their stories. Earthbound is a well-loved role-playing game that lives on the harsh shift from light-hearted comedy to crushing psychological horror. Persona 4 is a wonderful high school drama and chilling murder mystery. There's nothing wrong with a game shifting back and forth.

As I said in my review, Far Cry 5's opening and several of the primary story missions are full of unrelenting darkness. The opening almost plays out like Resident Evil 7 or Outlast 2, with the protagonist trapped in a horrible situation. The direct confrontations with the Seed clan are all explorations of their specific moralities within the overarching Project at Eden's Gate. Faith wants to free the world from its pain with her drug-induced euphoria, while Jacob feels that humanity has been made weak by attempting to protect the weakest among us. This all plays out in heavy shadows, blinding lights, self-serious moralizing, and not a little torture and brainwashing.

The rest of game is a romp through Hope County, doing as you please. It's meant to be fun. You'll shoot bulls having sex to the tune of Sexual Healing so you can collect their meaty bits for the local Testicle Festival. In one mission, the player is forced to hunt through piles of dog poop for a missing key card. Every Clutch Nixon side mission has you racing through the fire and flames in a mad time trial backed by Nixon's special theme song. There's an entire questline backed by local scientist Larry Parker's obsession with local crop circles and lost alien technology. There's also a whole host of notes and plaques that are just there for a laugh.

Both parts work for me, but the problem with Far Cry 5 is they never meet. There's little acknowledgement that this is all taking place in the same world, so most of the time, it doesn't feel like it is.

Another game I recently reviewed, Yakuza 6, is a savant when it comes not only establishing several different moods, but in making them all feel like they exist in the same world. Kazuma Kiryu's stomping grounds of Kamurocho have him dealing with the attempted murder of his foster daughter, phone apps becoming sentient, the takeover by Chinese Triads, and a cat cafe without cats.

The magic of Yakuza is Kiryu himself, who acts as the sounding board to everything: a moral center for the serious parts, and a straight man for the comedy. Kiryu's own commentary is what makes everything fit together into what I like to call "hyper-reality". It's not real, but it's believable and consistent because Kiryu keeps everything together.

In Far Cry 5 the glue is theoretically the player character, but the Rookie is silent throughout the whole game. The only commentary is you talking to yourself out loud. There's nothing established within the world that brings both halves together. There's little acknowledgement of one side in the other.

The cult missions generally have you interacting with the Seed family one-on-one. In some cases they spill out into the open-world, but they generally only interact with supporting characters that share the same tone. Serious characters for serious situations. Worse, the set up for these missions generally has you being taken or knocked out, essentially teleported from one world to the other.

a random plaque in Far Cry 5.

Zany characters Hurk Jr., his cousin Sharky, Larry Parker, or film director Guy Marvel aren't really touched by the horror of what's happening in Hope County. They're inconvenience by it at most. You never see Hurk really have to interact with Jacob, the Seed who controls his homeland, or vice-versa. One never really comments on the other and neither does the protagonist.

So there's no connective tissue. It's not "normal" and "crazy", it's two different types of "normal". Far Cry 5 never really comes together as anything resembling a cohesive whole. Which is a shame, because I enjoyed both parts, though the "fun romp" won out over the main narrative for me. One excelled, while the other falters a bit when it comes to sticking the landing. But I can't talk about that without getting into endgame spoilers, so more on that next week.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Mike Williams

Reviews Editor

M.H. Williams is new to the journalism game, but he's been a gamer since the NES first graced American shores. Third-person action-adventure games are his personal poison: Uncharted, Infamous, and Assassin's Creed just to name a few. If you see him around a convention, he's not hard to spot: Black guy, glasses, and a tie.

Related articles

Final Fantasy 7 Remake's Developers Tried to Avoid Playing Favorites With Tifa and Aerith

Co-Director Naoki Hamaguchi and Producer Yoshinori Kitase tell us about giving Tifa and Aerith equal time, how their vision for the remake evolved over time, and more.

Major Game Delays Due to COVID-19 Have Only Just Begun

With games like Wasteland 3 and The Last of Us Part 2 already delayed, we're just beginning to see the effects of the virus on gaming.

Need help?

Apex Legends Vaults - Where to Find the Vaults and How to Open Them

Need to know how to find a Vault Key in Apex Legends to open one of the three vaults? We've got you covered.

Gears 5 Collectibles - How to Find All Collectible Locations

Here's our guide to the Gears 5 collectible locations, including Act 1, Act 2, Act 3, and Act 4 collectibles.

Devil May Cry 5 Devil Breakers - Devil Breaker Arm Abilities in Devil May Cry 5

Here's our complete breakdown of every Devil Breaker arm ability for Nero in Devil May Cry 5.

Sekiro Tips - How to Beat Every Boss and Survive in Sekiro Shadows Die Twice

This is our complete beginner's guide to surviving Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice, including a list of essential tips and tricks.