Firewatch PlayStation 4 Review: Into the Woods

Campo Santo's debut provides some great, low-key character drama—even if the end may leave you feeling a little empty.

Review by Bob Mackey, .

Though walking simulators have only recently sprung into existence, their developers have managed to hone in on the key element that makes them so effective: loneliness.

In some ways, it's a practical choice: Most of these games are made by small teams with small budgets, making convincing character models (with convincing acting) an expensive proposition. But a game world nearly free of people does offer other benefits. As we've seen with games like Gone Home, The Vanishing of Ethan Carter, and Leviathan: The Old City, a sense of solitude can fully suck you into a fictional world, drawing out details you might not have noticed while surrounded by talking heads. And for Firewatch protagonist Henry, this loneliness comes as the main benefit of his new gig as a fire watchman: After losing his partner of eleven years to early onset dementia, he just needs a place to—for lack of a better phrase—get his shit together.

At the outset, that's all we really know about Henry. After Firewatch's brief, text-only prologue sums up the course of his tragic relationship, we're immediately introduced to his new life and new companion: Delilah, who we only interact with via Henry's trusty walkie-talkie. This job seems to attract a certain type of person, since Delilah has some baggage of her own, and prefers to keep people at arm's length despite her own apparent loneliness. Most of Firewatch's four hours explore the growing relationship between Henry and Delilah over the course of a summer—one that pulls the two into some mysterious and often dangerous circumstances by the end.

While a good deal of Firewatch's fairly large woodland area can be explored from the outset, it mostly follows a reliable formula of Henry heading out to solve problems discovered by Delilah, like rowdy teens setting off fireworks, or a downed power line. As Henry makes his way to these various destinations (using a handy map and compass), he can reach out to Delilah with his walkie-talkie to gain a little insight on the world around him. Firewatch brings plenty of opportunities to sit back and soak up the gorgeous scenery, but Campo Santo never leaves Henry alone for too long: Even when there's nothing particularly interesting in front of Henry, Delilah is likely to reach out, if only to provoke a reaction. (She's like that.)

Of course, there's more to Firewatch than the relationship of Henry and Delilah set against a life of mundanity, and after about an hour, it's clear that someone—or something—is out there watching him. For the most part, this change in direction brings out some of the best interactions between Henry and Delilah: With the stakes raised and their jobs (and possibly lives) on the line, heightened emotions allow the characters to break down the mental walls they've built for the sake of self-preservation. After your first few initial tasks, the remainder of Firewatch mostly involves investigating the mysterious happenings targeting our two main characters.

While I enjoyed the character drama throughout, Firewatch doesn't quite stick the landing. Without spoiling things, the finale seems a bit too rushed, almost as if Firewatch knows its central mystery is a bit contrived and wants to pull you out of the experience before you can dwell on it. And Henry and Delilah's relationship never really pays off, either. While the two certainly become more familiar with each other, they don't really go through the character arcs you'd expect them to. By the end, it's hard to tell if Henry has overcome the emotional trauma of losing his wife, or even if Delilah has softened a bit. There's something to be said about the value of nuance and realism, but, then again, the various happy endings from Gone Home still stick with me three years later.

Even with its problems, Firewatch stands as a worthwhile debut from Campo Santo. Though it limps to the finish line, having a smaller, more personal story explored through the medium of video games still comes as a pleasant change of pace. Firewatch might not bring the same emotional heights of other walking simulators, but it's still a warm and pleasant way to burn through an afternoon in the splendor of virtual Wyoming.

The Nitty Gritty

  • Interface: Given that your interactions with the game world are very basic, there's not much to screw up here.
  • Lasting appeal: Even if it only lasts a handful of hours, you're not likely to get more out of Firewatch by immediately jumping back in.
  • Sound: While most of Firewatch only offers ambient woodland sounds, Chris Remo's moody soundtrack pops in at just the right time to give certain scenes the proper emotional weight.
  • Visuals: Veering away from a more photorealistic look, Firewatch's stylized forest setting is visually stunning.

Firewatch doesn't provide the same emotional heights or satisfying conclusion you'd expect from such a story-heavy game, but Campo Santo definitely shows promise with their debut project. Even if it won't have you reaching for the tissues by the end, this woodland walking simulator still provides a pretty great way to burn through an otherwise unoccupied afternoon.

3.5 /5

Firewatch PlayStation 4 Review: Into the Woods Bob Mackey Campo Santo's debut provides some great, low-key character drama—even if the end may leave you feeling a little empty. 2016-02-17T01:00:00-05:00 3.5 5

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Comments 6

Comments on this article are now closed. Thanks for taking part!

  • Avatar for orient #1 orient 2 years ago
    It's not perfect, but I loved every minute of this game. The world was extremely inviting and the wilderness felt real to me, which is a tremendous achievement for a game that is essentially a few arenas connected by corridors (gorgeous, lush corridors).

    I admit that the conspiracy angle felt a little out of place, like they weren't completely confident in a game solely about 2 people talking, so they cooked up a narrative twist to keep things exciting. That maybe stole some thunder from the characters' relationship, but I don't know if a happy ending would've fixed anything. I think it should've felt more bittersweet if anything, but their relationship just didn't have enough time to blossom. But maybe that was the point, I don't know.

    Also, I really hope we're not sticking with "walking simulator" to describe games like this from now on. That'd be a real bummer.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for kidgorilla #2 kidgorilla 2 years ago
    Man, based on these comments, the people that play Firewatch really want me to work from home. Tell me you guys see the humor in this
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for camchow #3 camchow 2 years ago
    Personally I felt the ending was fine. Pretty down to earth and a reminder that sometimes people just don't do what you would expect them to do, some people are just aloof. I know I've dealt with a few people like Delilah in my life.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Ralek #4 Ralek 2 years ago
    "While the two certainly become more familiar with each other, they don't really go through the character arcs you'd expect them to."

    I agree, but I actually think that was kind of the point, just as the ending was maybe just that, unexpected on purpose, or more to the point defying expectations. Any kind of 'real' conspiracy, as seen in thousands of movies, TV-shows and games before, would have actually cheapened the game in my book. Just as any 'real' drama and resolution to the core relationship would have just meant, that Firewatch was just one of many.
    I would say though, that still means it will disappoint a number of people, and one could argue, that while they managed to defy expectation, they did not really manage to replace those expectations with something substantial.
    Anyways, I had a good time playing it, not to mention that it was utterly gorgeous (though I'm probably biased in that regard, seeing as I'm a huge Olly Moss fan^^).

    I want to point out, that the PS4 version did not really run smoothly for me. There were plenty of hiccups along the way, with what felt like FPS being all over the place, and dropping really low each time the game saved, plus the game did crash on me once, so ... I would suggest waiting for these isues to be ironed out with a patch, as they did hurt the experience for me.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for bobservo #5 bobservo 2 years ago
    @orient "Walking simulator" started off as a derogatory term, but fans of the genre gradually embraced it, and I think it works. It's certainly less clunky than "first-person narrative adventure" or whatever else you would call something like this.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for orient #6 orient 2 years ago
    @bobservo Hmm, I think it still is derogatory and reductive, even if some people have embraced it. It doesn't describe what these games are about at all. Interactive drama? Narrative exploration game? These seem like much better options that don't require an eye roll.
    Sign in to Reply