Five Nights at Freddy's is Getting a New Game, Much to Critics' Dismay

Five Nights at Freddy's is Getting a New Game, Much to Critics' Dismay

The announcement of a new Five Nights at Freddy's game, Sister Location, is causing series creator Scott Cawthon to undergo an unfair barrage of hate.

Indie game developer Scott Cawthon declared he was done with his enormously successful Five Nights at Freddy's (FNAF) franchise after the release of Five Nights at Freddy's 4 last summer (excepting the series' spin-off RPG, FNAF World, which is currently being retooled). But much like the grime that collects at the baseboard of a Chuck E Cheese's arcade game, the Five Nights at Freddy's series is apparently sticking around for a while.

This particular FNAF title doesn't have a number taped to its rear, however. Instead, it has a subtitle: "Sister Location." As the teaser on Scott Cawthon's main site reminds us, there never was just one.

This is true. Previous games FNAF games have made mention of Freddy Fazbear Pizza's "sister location," and fans have spent hours speculating about whether or not certain games have occurred in said sister location. One thing's for sure: We're visiting the sister location this time, and at least one horrifying animatronic is waiting for us, as per usual.

It's hard to make out what the animatronic is -- all we have to go on is an unsettling outline displayed on the teaser image linked above -- though some fans speculate it's a hellishly twisted take on Fisher-Price's famous Chatter Phone. The Chatter Phone was in the background of Five Nights at Freddy's 4, and the games take place across the '80s, so it's not an outlandish guess.

(Did you know Fisher-Price still makes and sells the Chatter Phone, rotary and all?)

Ring ring. Get the phone. It's Death.

Sister Location's reveal prompted a big reaction, and not just from FNAF fans. The franchise, as well as Scott Cawthon himself, has attracted a huge array of haters. The first game's popularity with YouTubers hasn't earned it many fans amongst more traditional gamers, whereas others believe Scott has milked the franchise dry by releasing four games in the space of a year.

The FNAF series certainly isn't above criticism, though it's unfair to call the games copy-paste jobs: Scott makes new character models and environments for each title. He also adds twists to each game's survival-horror element, like having to rely on your sense of hearing to stay safe in FNAF 4.

Scott promises Sister Location is much different from his previous works and is full of surprises, so he's probably taken some of his critics' words to heart. Either way, he's determined not to let his haters get him down.

"Don't feel bad about anything," he said in the Steam community for FNAF 4. "I'm here for the fans and supporters of the franchise. Haters gonna hate. It doesn't bother me, so don't let it bother you."

"We got that new four-player Ninja Turtles game!"

However you feel about the FNAF series, attacking Scott Cawthon over its existence is mean-spirited. No game creator deserves to have hate heaped on them because you believe there's no justification for their game's popularity, but Scott has been unfailingly supportive towards the general gaming community. He gives shout-outs to other indie projects, he encourages his fans to be kind towards each other, and he makes sizeable donations to charity streams, including $250,000 to St Jude's Children's Hospital in March 2015, and over $50,000 to the June 2015 Zeldathon.

Scott Cawthon exudes a patient kindness that's all-too-rare in the games industry these days. However you feel about his work, or even the (oft-impassioned) fandom he's created, there's no call to lob attacks directly at him. The nice thing about video games is that there are thousands of them across a multitude of systems, and you don't have to even look in the direction of FNAF if you'd rather not.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Nadia Oxford

Staff Writer

Nadia has been writing about games for so long, only the wind and the rain (or the digital facsimiles thereof) remember her true name. She's written for Nerve, About.com, Gamepro, IGN, 1UP, PlayStation Official Magazine, and other sites and magazines that sling words about video games. She co-hosts the Axe of the Blood God podcast, where she mostly screams about Dragon Quest.

Related articles

Cyberspace Is Looking Slick in the System Shock Remake

You can't jack-in with the remake's new demo yet, but you'll want to leave meatspace behind.

Xbox Throws Shade Over Who Believes in Generations

Microsoft and Sony are talkin' bout my generation.

Rev Up Those Next-Gen Hype Cycles

THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | Can Sony's PS5 game showcase announcement finally get us excited for the new systems?

Respawn Is Working on Apex Legends Content as Far Out as Season 11

Those far-off plans include a desire to "double down on story" in the battle royale.

You may also like

What Do You Hope to See at Next Week's PS5 Showcase?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | Next week is perhaps the biggest look yet at what awaits PS5. What do you want to see?

Why I'm Still Playing Gradius 35 Years After Its Original Release

On its 35th anniversary, the Vic Viper lives on.

USG Game of the Month: If Found Teaches Us There's Beauty in the Wake of Suffering

If Found is about the pain of change, and the growth that comes of that struggle.

PlayStation CEO Jim Ryan Talks Keeping PS4 Owners Happy Into Next-Gen

Noting that many won't buy a PS5 "for a couple of years," Sony sees a "responsibility" to serve its PS4 base.