Game Developers Weigh In On Pokemon Sword and Shield National Pokedex Cuts: "I'm Surprised They Didn't Cut It Years Ago"

Game Developers Weigh In On Pokemon Sword and Shield National Pokedex Cuts: "I'm Surprised They Didn't Cut It Years Ago"

It's a lot of Pokemon.

During E3 2019, Pokemon series developer Game Freak announced that Pokemon Sword and Shield would not carry forward every Pokemon from previous generations. Fans were unhappy, and a pretty nasty campaign swirled up around the deletions coming to the National Pokedex. But for an experienced take, some game developers have commented on what it means to actually build out a Pokedex in Pokemon.

An anonymous Tumblr account called Ask A Game Dev recently addressed the "Pokemon controversy" in response to a reader question: "Do you think the reasoning they cut the Pokemon is because of animation and graphics that a lot of people are complaining about?"

One of the references to this being the case is from our own interview with Sword and Shield's director and producer, where producer Junichi Masuda told us:

"There are a couple of different parts to the thinking behind it, but really the biggest reason for it is just the sheer number of Pokemon. We already have well over 800 Pokemon species, and there's going to be more added in these games. And now that they're on the Nintendo Switch, we're creating it with much higher fidelity with higher quality animations."

Masuda also addressed balance in the battle system and allowing new Pokemon the room to shine in their own way, but the graphics part has been what the outrage train has glommed onto.

The game dev in question is blunt about the National Pokedex. "There’s a very good reason every professional game developer I’ve spoken with about the Pokemon thing has basically said variations on the same thing: 'Holy crap, they need to update that many? I’m surprised they didn’t cut [the National Pokedex] years ago!'"

The game dev goes on to break down how much work goes into every detail of a single Pokmeon, using details and assets from a 2017 CGWorld feature on making Pokemon. There's the model, the details, the base colors, the base textures, the shadow map, normal map, shadow mask, sometimes a light map... It's an exhaustive list, and that's just building out the shape and color.

A common rebuff is to point out that previous gens have already had these, and that things can port over. On this alone, it's easy to note that previous Pokemon games were mostly on the 3DS and prior handhelds. Aside from Let's Go Pikachu and Let's Go Eevee, there's not much basis to work on for the new platform, and transferring over models isn't as simple as 1:1, as the anonymous game dev puts it.

Don't just take it from them, though. Xavier Garcia, an artist at EA, posted in a ResetEra thread last week to comment on the idea of "future proof" assets for the many, many Pokemon.

"Updating your engine so it uses modern physics, modern shaders, better animation based solutions, different kind of lighting etc REQUIRES you to check every single old asset you are importing, thats unavoidable! Maybe the polycount needs to be changed, maybe the rigs are acting funky, maybe the textures dont work well with the new lights, maybe all new materials for every creature need to be made."

A longer post on the r/pokemon subreddit also breaks down the nitty-gritty of the differences between models in Pokemon Sword and Shield, and models in previous Pokemon games.

The gist is, as several developers here and elsewhere have said, making games is tough. Masuda and others have since made statements clarifying and sympathizing with distraught fans. But keep in mind the human toll that goes into making these games, and also that every Pokemon is someone's first. Sword and Shield still looks to deliver what Pokemon does, on an even grander scale than before. So maybe it's okay to not get overly worked up about making some cuts, for both Pokemon and Game Freak's sake.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Eric Van Allen

News Editor

Eric is a writer and Texan. He's a former contributor to sites including Compete, Polygon, Waypoint, and the Washington Post. He loves competitive games, live music, and travel.

Read this next

Pokemon Sword and Shield Ditches the Trainer School, Much to Everyone's Relief

I learned how to catch Pokemon from a drunk old man, and that's good enough for me.

Pokemon Sword and Shield Will Let You Wander Into Supremely Overlevelled Pokemon

You ventured into the wrong patch of tall grass, Trainer.

Pokemon Sword and Shield's File Size is Pleasantly Rotund, Like a Wooloo

You cannot nap on the belly of Sword and Shield's game cartridge, however.

Sobble's Popularity Surprised Game Freak, Plus More Interesting Facts About Pokemon Sword and Shield's Starters

Pokemon Sword and Shield's starters can't wait to meet you. Except Sobble. It's shy.

More News

Crusader Kings 3 is Happening, And It Has Some Much-Requested Features

The fan favorite strategy series from Paradox is back in a big way.

Humble Monthly Is Getting a Name Change and a Higher Price Point

Humble Monthly will soon be no more, with Humble Choice taking its place.

Final Fantasy 14's Nier: Automata Raid Gets a Release Date and a Ton of New Details

Final Fantasy 14 continues to consume all things Square Enix.

More on Switch

Blizzard's Very Bad October Just Keeps Getting Worse

THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | Blizzard's ban on Hearthstone player Blitzchung catches the ire of Republicans and Democrats alike.

Baldur's Gate's Complex Interface Translates Surprisingly Well to Switch

Beamdog's Infinity Engine collections find great ways to bring those games to consoles.

Return of the Obra Dinn's Creator Reminisces on Getting Its Iconic Style Just Right

"After working on non-graphical stuff for so long, I took a moment to reflect on what I had with the visuals. It wasn’t great."

More Family Games

Luigi's Mansion 3 References One of the Best Horror Films of All Time

Crazy things can happen when your back is turned.

Watch Dogs, Far Cry 3: Blood Dragon, and More Set to Get Animated Series

They'll be a little more family-friendly, though.