God of War's Strong Reviews Complete Sony Santa Monica's Return From the Brink

Why God of War was more of a hail mary than most people realize.

Feature by Kat Bailey, .

"Four years ago was a dark time for this studio," Sony Santa Monica chief Shannon Studstill told an assembled group of journalists last month. The press was in Santa Monica to see a playable version of God of War for the first time, and this was to be Sony Santa Monica's big moment.

It might not seem like it now that reviews are showering God of War with praise, but this revival was a hail mary of sorts for Sony Santa Monica. At its nadir in 2014, Sony Santa Monica was rudderless and racked with layoffs amid the cancellation of its new IP. The studio behind some of PlayStation's most successful franchises had been relegated to a supporting role on the likes of Fat Princess: Piece of Cake, The Order: 1886, and Bound. Tomorrow's release of God of War will be its first internally developed game since 2013's God of War: Ascension.

It's the end that awaits many studios if they aren't careful. Consider Raven Software—formerly known for high quality shooters like Star Wars Jedi Knight II: Jedi Outcast, Raven has long since been relegated the role of support for Activision's various Call of Duty ventures. Its most notable project in recent years is the Call of Duty: Modern Warfare remaster that was controversially bundled with Infinite Warfare.

God of War: Ascension nearly killed the series.

In 2014, Sony Santa Monica seemed in danger of suffering a similar fate. The God of War franchise had clearly run out of gas by this time, with God of War: Ascension and its new multiplayer mode being met with middling reviews. Having resolved Kratos' story in God of War 3, the follow-ups were mainly prequels, which made the series feel increasingly stale.

Kratos as the angry antihero was likewise becoming a relic of the past. God of War director Cory Barlog acknowledged as much in an interview with USgamer last month, "I think Kratos in his original incarnation reflected how we viewed things and the time period. The time period had not a lot of anti-hero icons, and it kind of began something in a way. Over time, though, things change. They need to change. I'm not the same person I was 20 years ago. I don't think he should be either. But I think he's a lot of the reflection of us: who [David Jaffe] was, who I was, who the team was."

Sony Santa Monica needed something fresh and new. The studio's answer was a sci-fi game reportedly codenamed "Darkside," which purportedly featured dinosaur-like enemies and a heavy emphasis on exploration. Concept art that was rumored to be from the game leaked in early 2017.

When Barlog returned to the studio in 2013, development on the new project was in "full swing," he remembers. Coming off of the successful reboot of Tomb Raider for Crystal Dynamics, he wanted to have a crack at reviving God of War. Sony's leadership was resistant, believing that God of War needed to lay dormant after exhausting its momentum with Ascension. Barlog got his way, though, and God of War was greenlit.

Less than a year after his return, layoffs rocked Sony Santa Monica. The studio's new IP was canceled, triggering a round of cuts that included veteran level designer Jonathan Hawkins and others. God of War 3 director Stig Asmussen, who was leading the project, subsequently departed to join Respawn Entertainment.

Leaked concept art from Sony Santa Monica's new IP.

Barlog remembers it as a tough time for Sony Santa Monica. "We had never experienced that level of getting knocked down. I do feel like we got knocked down twice. I felt a tremendous amount of responsibility because I had been part of the studio since basically the beginning. God of War 1 was when the studio really started to find its way, and I was part of that. So much of this studio is part of my own creative legacy, and it's important to me that we all stay on the path I feel we all want to be on."

Barlog says he doesn't ever want to experience those days again. "There were a lot of good people we don't get work with anymore because we went and made some decisions that we probably look back on and think we have to do better. That line, 'Do better,' has motivated us. There's no point in us worrying whether or not what we did was good or bad. We just need to do better, we need to push, and every single day be true to that vision we had. Accessibility, pick up and play, fun. Deliver on the promise of the back of the box."

With Sony Santa Monica's new IP dead and buried, all of the studio's eggs were essentially in one basket. It may be an exaggeration to call God of War the studio's final shot, but in the unpredictable and cutthroat world of triple-A development, one failure can put any studio on the brink. Sony Santa Monica couldn't make its new IP work, and suffered layoffs as a result. Failing to hit the mark with God of War would have hurt even more.

Now with less than 24 hours to go before God of War officially launches, it appears that Sony Santa Monica can breathe a sigh of relief. It is currently enjoying a 95 on Metacritic, making it the highest-rated PlayStation exclusive of all time. Strong sales are almost certain to follow.

The new God of War is a comeback both for the series and Sony Santa Monica.

It's not easy to completely update a faded IP. Recent attempts to bring back Gears of War, Mass Effect, and other notable franchises have been met with shrugs or even disaster. And Barlog wasn't shooting for just an update—he was shooting for a complete and total overhaul. For all of Sony Santa Monica's experience, God of War could have easily missed the mark.

Indeed, in talking about God of War back in 2015, I wrote, "Another God of War is inevitable, if only because the name still means something, which is currency in this day and age. But as for whether it will ever reach the heights of the three numbered games, it's kind of doubtful."

Now it seems as if God of War is destined to not only meet the high standard set by the original trilogy, but greatly exceed it. Four years after the period Studstill characterized as a "dark time," it appears that Sony Santa Monica is all the way back. And even with all the advantages conferred on it by being a first-party studio with a high-quality IP, that qualifies as a minor miracle in this unstable industry of ours.

God of War launches tomorrow. In case you missed it, here's our God of War review. You should also check out our God of War guides as you dive into Kratos' newest adventure.

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Comments 14

  • Avatar for cldmstrsn #1 cldmstrsn 4 months ago
    God of War 1 and 2 were just the coolest in 2005-2007. I played the first God of War in just one sitting when it came out in 2005. It made me feel kind of like DMC did in 2001. Big sets and fun gameplay. God of War 2 was even better because I had just bought a PS3 and a new TV and was able to play it "upscaled." I lived with a bunch of room mates and they all just sat watching me play for hours in the front room.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for NiceGuyNeon #2 NiceGuyNeon 4 months ago
    I'm happy for them. I can't stand the original tbh but I'm happy they turned things around. Highest rated PS4 exclusive isn't a bad notch to put in you resume.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for donkeyintheforest #3 donkeyintheforest 4 months ago
    It's nice when good reviews result in good sales.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for AceOfCakez #4 AceOfCakez 4 months ago
    Never played the God of War series back in the day because after researching it, it definitely looked like something not for me. But after researching up on this new GoW, this definitely seems like something up my alley. I hope that I'll enjoy it as much as the critics did.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for mobichan #5 mobichan 4 months ago
    I am glad for their success, but it is kind of sad to be a single IP studio. Too bad we couldn't see if they are capable of making something else. I guess this shift in GOW is similar to RE4 reinventing that staling series?

    As for his comment about anti-heroes at the time, I find that a bit hilarious. Comics and movies had done the anti-hero concept to death by the late 90's and games had been pushing it too. GOW 1 was always billed as Greek mythology as seen through the lens of Heavy Metal magazine. That kind of vanished when Jaffe left and the series seemed to become something with less tooth to it (but maybe more marketable).
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for AndreasStalin #6 AndreasStalin 4 months ago
    The Norse mythology concept intrigues me, anything else about the GoW reboot sounds pretty run-of-the-mill, but what do I know it might take me by surprise, after all I really enjoyed both Tomb Raider reboots AND both GoW 1&2 on the playstation 2 AND also both of the psp God of Wars. And btw that metacritic score might drop as more reviews are added, it usually happens to most games.Edited April 2018 by AndreasStalin
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Kuni-Nino #7 Kuni-Nino 4 months ago
    I’m happy that they found their footing again. I’ve always thought of Santa Monica as one of the best studios in the world. It would’ve sucked to see them shuttered.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for The-Challenger #8 The-Challenger 4 months ago
    Considering the success of GoW 1-3, the success of this entry hardly comes as a surprise.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Kat.Bailey #9 Kat.Bailey 4 months ago
    @The-Challenger Tell that to Gears of War 4.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for The-Challenger #10 The-Challenger 4 months ago
    @Kat.Bailey They should have let Epic create it. The Coalition just couldn't measure up. Also, Gears 4 came after Microsoft purchased the, insert "obligatory Microsoft ruins everything" comment.Edited 2 times. Last edited April 2018 by The-Challenger
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for marchughes #11 marchughes 4 months ago
    @AndreasStalin Its not a reboot....Its a direct sequel to GOW 3.....Why do people keep thinking its a reboot. He still has the scar on his right eye, he has the giant scar through his stomach from the end of 3....Just because they decided not to add the number 4 doesn't mean something is a reboot. It just means they decided not to use the numbering scheme....
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for AndreasStalin #12 AndreasStalin 4 months ago
    @marchughes yeah I know it’s a continuation of Kratos story it just feels like they kind of rebooted the concept of God of War in a way, if you know what I mean? Maybe more like a reimagination? Anyway thanks for clearing that up.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Kat.Bailey #13 Kat.Bailey 3 months ago
    @marchughes It's a reboot in every way that matters. It's a complete reimagining of the formula after an extended absence. It's Superman Returns in game form.

    So yes, it's a sequel. But it's also an obvious reboot.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for thomaskash #14 thomaskash 19 days ago
    I am very happy with returned things.
    Clash Royale PC Online Game Servers
    Sign in to Reply