Where I Am Setsuna Went Wrong, and How Lost Sphear Can Give Tokyo RPG Factory Another Chance

Tokyo RPG Factory deserves another shot at its craft, but first it needs to pick up the ball(s) I Am Setsuna dropped.

Analysis by Nadia Oxford, .

Today we learned Square-Enix's Tokyo RPG Factory, the studio behind I Am Setsuna, has another title in the works called "Lost Sphear." We'll see it in early 2018 for the Nintendo Switch, the PlayStation 4, and PC.

The news has me wrapped up in mixed feelings. Let's discuss.

First, "Lost Sphear" is a weird and confusing title ("Oh, 'Sphere?' Like a baseball?" "Well, no – it's spelled 'S-P-H-E-A-R"), but we're at the point where complaining about Square-Enix's odd RPG names is as useful as complaining about the sun in Africa. Moving on.

USgamer's RPG Podcast Reviews I Am Setsuna with Kotaku's Jason Schreier

AXE OF THE BLOOD GOD: We welcome fellow RPG booster Jason Schreier to the show for the first time to discuss Trails of Cold Steel and I Am Setsuna.

I'm honestly glad to see Tokyo RPG Factory is working on another project. I respect the studio's modus operandi, which is to make simple but enjoyable RPGs that hearken back to Square-Enix's best days on the Super Famicom and SNES. I'm happy the studio exists, and I'm looking forward to seeing more of Lost Sphear, goofy name or no.

But I'm also a bit worried. While I Am Setsuna tries to walk the path forged by Chrono Trigger's legacy, it stumbles every third step. Much as I want to adore Tokyo RPG Factory's snowy, silent world, myriad imperfections pull me out of the game every time I try to settle in.

I talked about some of I Am Setsuna's problems with Kat and Kotaku's RPG guru Jason Schreier on Axe of the Blood God last year. Not to sound self-important (too late!), but I think my grievances are worth re-visiting so we can catalogue the mistakes Tokyo RPG Factory hopefully won't re-visit with Lost Sphear.

I Am Setsuna's main character, Endir, is as blank as a white sheet after laundry day: The protagonist for I Am Setsuna is a stoic young man named Endir who makes a living as a mercenary. Endir is also a member of a tribe that wears masks, so it's not hard to understand why he's rather cold and detached from his fellow party members (read: Boring).

I Am Setsuna has beautiful character designs, but said characters' personalities are as flavorless as melted snow.

Thing is, silent protagonists shouldn't automatically be doomed to carry oatmeal-grey personalities. Crono from Chrono Trigger is highly likeable. Link rarely puts more than two words together, and he manages to capture our hearts time and time again. Silent protagonists aren't exactly the personification of a Shakespeare soliloquy, but no-one is asking them to be. We just want to have a clear guess at their likes, hates, and motivations.

It's a shame Endir is so flat, because his cat-eyed mask and nomadic lifestyle prompt a lot of questions. What was his life like before he met up with the eponymous Setsuna? Was he born into the Masked Tribe, or was it a position he ascended to? What motivates him to help Setsuna and the others? I Am Setsuna has a lot of opportunities to let us fall in love with its protagonist, and they're all squandered.

Not to put too fine a point on my argument, but Archive of Our Own, an online library that holds over 1000 fanfictions based on the Icelandic children's show LazyTown, has zero works about I Am Setsuna. That's how bland its hero is.

"Deep Crow! Oooooh noooo!"

I Am Setsuna's cooking feature is cold and unappetizing: Cooking and eating can be a memorable way to buff up your character in a game. I still dream about Odin Sphere's succulent-looking soups, hearty stews, custard-covered puddings, and sizzling chunks of meat.

I Am Setsuna lets you cook up meals that boost experience and restore health, but there's rarely any motivation to do so. There are easier ways to restore your party's health, and while the recipes you garner sound tasty (I'd like some winterwhistle soup, please), you don't get to see (and drool over) the finished product. Even the ingredients you gather to make them show up as simple shining spots on the snow.

Yeah, I guess you can use your imagination, but imagination sucks. Plus, a game set in a cold climate shouldn't be shy about feeding up its heroes. What's more restful on a winter's day than some soup or hot tea?

Speaking of winter–

Hope you like white.

I Am Setsuna's wintry landscape is beautiful, but tiresome: I come from the land of the ice and snow, and I can confirm I Am Setsuna captures the dim but savage heart of winter. The watery light through pine trees, the muffled sound of powder crunching underfoot, the hush that invariably accompanies falling snow … I Am Setsuna's July release almost made me nostalgic for my least-favorite season.

Almost. Winter's beauty gets pretty old pretty fast in real life, and it does in I Am Setsuna, too. Exploration is a big draw in RPGs, and even if game after game has us re-treating the same terrain – castles, deserts, swamps, and what not – the change in scenery is appreciated, even if only on a subconscious level. Deserts are usually my least favorite game environment, but I started aching to see sand when it gradually became clear I Am Setsuna is All Snow All the Time.

The trailer for Lost Sphear shows off different environments, so that's encouraging. Hooray! Green fields!

Stick your head in that hole, Endir. C'mon, I'll give you ten bucks.

I Am Setsuna's spartan soundtrack is pretty, but the lack of variety is noticeable: If I get reamed for any opinion on this list, it'll be this one. I Am Setsuna's soundtrack, which is 95% piano compositions by Tomoki Miyoshi, cries out for variety at the same volume as the game's graphics. While the solitary piano is a powerful mood-setter when used sparingly, you quickly notice something's missing when song after song comes bonging at you. I was about two hours into the game when I said, "Oh … I guess we're just getting a piano, huh? All right, cool."

I Am Setsuna's Magic Consortium and Spritnite adds needless complexity to an otherwise simple battle system: I Am Setsuna's combat system is almost a one-for-one translation of Chrono Trigger's. You fight enemies where you find them (instead of transitioning to a battlefield), and characters can combine skills to execute combo attacks. Many of the names and functions for I Am Setsuna's skills come directly from Chrono Trigger, e.g. "Cyclone," "Cleave," and "Aura."

There are two major problems with I Am Setsuna's battle system. First, its similarity to Chrono Trigger's own system invites direct comparisons. That makes it very hard for I Am Setsuna to stand on its own merits – and Chrono Trigger is a really high bar to reach for.

So close to Chrono Trigger, so far away.

Second, the few measures I Am Setsuna takes to separate its battle system from Chrono Trigger's just mucks things up. Characters in the former don't just learn techs as they level-up like they do in the latter. Instead, you learn magic and skills in I Am Setsuna by gathering and selling material components that can be made into equippable "Spritenite."

In other words, learning new skills in I Am Setsuna involves keeping and carrying every scrap of material you win off monsters – even if a lot of it winds up being garbage – selling it to the Magic Consortium, and then buying it back in a new, usable form. It's an awkward and inefficient way for I Am Setsuna to differentiate itself, especially since the game is engineered to be a bare-bones straight-forward RPG.

I understand Tokyo RPG Factory produced I Am Setsuna on a very limited budget, so some of its flaws are definitely on Square-Enix. If you want a team to make a game that brings back memories of your SNES classics, Square, don't give that team $5 to work with.

That said, not all of I Am Setsuna's problems require costly fixes. A better story. Characters that are more fleshed-out. Heck, even palette-swapped graphics can be used to great effect (look at A Link to the Past for an enduring example. Even Chrono Trigger keeps things fresh by having the party re-visit old maps under new circumstances).

As someone who adores classic JRPGs, I want with all my heart for Tokyo RPG Factory to do what its name implies: Manufacture simple but personable RPGs like the ones I loved as a kid. Here's hoping I Am Setsuna helped the studio find its footing, and that it knocks Lost Sphear out of the park.

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Comments 14

Comments on this article are now closed. Thanks for taking part!

  • Avatar for Talraen #1 Talraen A year ago
    I think you may be underestimating the actual cash cost of having a good story and good characters. That stuff takes time and people!
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Lord-Bob-Bree #2 Lord-Bob-Bree A year ago
    I really wanted to like I Am Setsuna, but... it just lacked in too many ways. I kind of wonder how much it could be improved if someone went through it, rewrote everything, and tried to fix up the battle system.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for nadiaoxford #3 nadiaoxford A year ago
    @jamesdowd15 Undertale, a game that produced some of the most beloved RPG characters of all time with a $50,000 budget, says hello!

    Stardew Valley and Cave Story, two games with great characters and single-person teams, do likewise. ;)
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for SatelliteOfLove #4 SatelliteOfLove A year ago
    Seeing seasonal cold in this is interesting, as Cold Steel 2 didn't do this except for the coldest of regions (wierd nitpick but still).

    But that muffling quiet of dead winter spread to the soundtrack as well as what you said. It's rather monotonous to even think about.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for link6616 #5 link6616 A year ago
    My issue with OST isn't that it's bad. I've justified my purchase of Setsuna by the amount of time I've spent listening to the OST on youtube... I love it.

    But... as a game soundtrack it really does feel bland, even though as pieces of music to listen to it's one of my go tos.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Tetragrammaton #6 Tetragrammaton A year ago
    @nadiaoxford: Very true, except Undertale, Stardew Valley and Cave Story were one-man projects that were put together over the course of YEARS. They're also some of the most exceptional exceptions of indie gaming, period. Is it really a fair comparison?

    I agree that this new game needs all the fixes you've suggested and then some, but good writing isn't easy, so it shouldn't be expected to be cheap. I think we both can agree on that sentiment. ;)
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Thad #7 Thad A year ago
    I think Setsuna is a fine first effort, and I look forward to Sphear improving on it.

    Here's what I said about Setsuna when I played it.

    I like the sound of the "pieces of the world are disappearing; you have to recover them" hook; sounds like DQ7. Which puts it in the same territory as CT (and could bode well WRT your point about reusing environments effectively).Edited May 2017 by Thad
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for TernBird #8 TernBird A year ago
    @nadiaoxford You mentioned Odin Sphere, too--that game was made by a team of only 12 people. (Provided, the fight against Odette showed it. Woof, that slowdown...)
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for TheWildCard #9 TheWildCard A year ago
    I hope they sets their sights much higher than "aggressively average" like Setsuna was. To be honest I'm not confident after seeing the trailer.Edited May 2017 by TheWildCard
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for dsparil #10 dsparil A year ago
    I don't entirely disagree for the most part, but I still enjoyed it quite a bit. It isn't grind heavy unless you want it to be, the difficulty is reasonable, equipment is kept simple and the story is nice enough.

    The description of buying spritnite is a little harsh though since it doesn't mention the actual annoying part. Selling item drops to buy spritnite is cribbed directly from FFXII, and the main way to make money aside like in FFXII since monsters only drop items. I don't think that part is complicated at all. It's the fact that there's something like 10 different ways to defeat an enemy e.g. with a fire element attack (Fire Kill), with a status effect (Status Kill), dealing excessive damage (Over Kill), that can have a different drops attached to them, and they're not guaranteed. You basically need a guide to know exactly what spritnite you can even get.

    The overarching problem is that it's a simple game with a simple story but with a raft of added complexity that is unnecessary and ignorable. I never felt the need to cook anything to get by. Spritnite can have fluxations that enhance their effects, but the game is easy enough without them. Singularities, which give positive effects, can randomly occur during battle, but they happen very infrequently. Spritnite availability could have been tied to story progress instead, and the most basic ones are strong enough to finish the game anyway.Edited May 2017 by dsparil
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for InexactQuotient #11 InexactQuotient A year ago
    @elraf27 I'm sure that was a typo, but I'm really enjoying the idea of a dev team allocating funds to a hug budget. It'll really come in handy for team morale during crunch!
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for nadiaoxford #12 nadiaoxford A year ago
    @InexactQuotient Who needs benefits when you have huuuuuuugs?
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for theinternetisodd #13 theinternetisodd A year ago
    @elraf27 This is my favorite thing. I want a hug budget.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for IPA #14 IPA A year ago
    Any Setsuna fans out there? It's on my Switch list but this article really put the hurt on my enthusiasm...
    Sign in to Reply