In Which Lavish Praise is Heaped Upon Two Old Game Boy Color Re-Releases

The joy of playing a pair of utterly brilliant, twelve-year-old Game Boy Color classics for the first time results in a review that needs no score.

I freely admit that I’m a nerd. But just how big of a nerd is about to be revealed as I lavish ridiculous amounts of praise on a pair of creaky old Game Boy Color cartridges from 2001. The games in question are The Legend of Zelda: Oracle of Ages, and The Legend of Zelda: Oracle of Seasons. And I’m talking about them because they were both given a new lease of digital download life on 3DS virtual console a few weeks ago, and have been plucking at my gaming heartstrings ever since.

Jaz Rignall Editorial Director

Here’s why. Back in 2001, I wasn’t paying any attention to the Game Boy Color, or indeed any older systems. Instead, I was focused on the emerging new generation of consoles – PS2 and Xbox – while spending whatever other spare time I had obsessively playing the first-generation PC MMOs. There was no time for anything else, and consequently, this duo passed me by completely. I was pretty much unaware of their existence until I was given two review codes a few weeks ago. That was a very nice surprise – it’s not often I get two brand spanking new old classics to play.

So to make the most of the experience, I did a little research to catch up on this “lost” pair of Zelda titles, and was surprised to find that they were supposed to be a trilogy, each game representing a different aspect of the Triforce. I was also surprised to find that these were the first games in the franchise’s history to be created by a third party developer – Capcom-owned Flagship. I didn’t know much about the team, but I certainly knew the history of its lead, Yoshiki Okamoto, whose resume looks like it was cribbed from a list of my all-time favorite coin-ops. Amongst many games, he created Gyruss, Time Pilot, Gun Smoke, Final Fight and Street Fighter II.

All that piqued my interest immediately, and I became even more intrigued as I read that Okamoto and Miyamoto had worked closely together to create an ingenious password system that enabled each game in the trilogy to interact with one other. The idea being that whichever game the player started with, he or she could use codes they found in that game to unlock secrets and items in the other games. Unfortunately, this system turned out to be more of a challenge than was initially anticipated, so the trilogy was downsized to a duology that was eventually released in May 2001, a mere month before Game Boy Color was consigned to history by the newer, more capable Advance.

Jumping into these games completely fresh, I was immediately struck by the retro-ness of their presentation. These are classic, top-down, NES-style games that I imagine felt a bit out-of-date in 2001. But now, thanks to the fact that retro games are looked upon as products of an era rather than obsolete technology, both these games feel like treasured artifacts from the 8-bit era. And it’s at this point my legs start going all wobbly and I begin to come over all sentimental-like.

Two timelines, many puzzles, The Legend of Zelda: Oracle of Ages is the more mentally challenging of the pair.

Experiencing Oracle of Ages for the first time left me in an odd kind of emotional turmoil. Here I am playing something that’s brand new to me, but at the same time is punching me in the face repeatedly with a fist that has “nostalgia” tattooed all over it. I’m feeling the old-school love, but enjoying the discovery of something familiar, but totally new. As I watch the clunky, stilted text fly by, and guide my tiny little Link sprite around the simplistic landscape, poking at stuff with his trusty sword, I slowly, but surely begin to slip back into an earlier gaming mindset. Oh right, this is a classic arcade adventure, with lots of exploring, and tons of tricky, yet slap-your-forehead-obvious-when-you-solve-them puzzles. There are all sorts of secrets sequestered away in obscure corners of the game that I need to find, so I must leave no tufty bush unshaken. And oh right. This game comes from a time when adventuring was dangerous, and where the foolhardy got mashed by monsters if they weren’t careful. Yep. This ain’t easy, and my repeated boss battle failures almost resulted in muscle-memory flinging-of-controller to the floor, until I remembered that I’m holding a 3DS, and not an indestructible joypad of yore. It took a while to adjust to this old-schoolin’ style, but it came back soon enough.

Oracle of Ages is more puzzle-heavy than I expected, and makes full use of its dual timeline scenario, forcing you to think very creatively to solve some devilishly tricky conundrums. It reminded me a lot of the similarly functioning Ocarina of Time, which my mind was fooled into thinking was newer, even though this older-looking game is actually three years its junior.

I’m still hacking my way through the game as I write this, eking out the experience into nightly chunks so I can savor it. I’ve had to look up some of the puzzles I’ve encountered because they confounded me, but each time I’ve done that, I’ve cursed myself for doing so. Because in classic Zelda style, the answer was always staring at me in the face.

Legend of Zelda: Oracle of Seasons is the harder game of the two, thanks to its slightly more combat-oriented gameplay.

I did have a quick go of Oracle of Seasons, for the purposes of this review. But I didn’t get too far, as I really want to play through Ages first. My immediate reaction is that it seems more action-oriented, and definitely a lot harder than its twin. Almost like Ages is the more cerebral of the pair, while Seasons is more focused on brute force. As such, I’m glad I ended up starting with the slightly less reflex-intensive game, because I’m hoping that the gear I’m getting while on my travels in Ages will stand me in good stead for Seasons’ seemingly more dangerous adventure. Plus the slightly more forgiving Ages is also helping me rediscover my old-school skillz without quite the frustrations I’m sure I’d have had should I have started with Seasons first.

Together, these games comprise two very complete halves of a greater whole. Both parts Venn Diagram fairly closely in terms of boss battles, puzzling and general exploring, but separate when it comes to their approach and scenarios: the thinker is centered around two time lines, where the brawler focuses on overground and subterranean environments.

To me, both feel like the gaming equivalent of classical literature or music. They have a style, presentation and design that represent gaming from a past era: they look old, but yet they’re timeless. They’re amongst the best of their breed, and perhaps will never be bettered – because ultimately, anything that tries to be like them is either an homage, or a knock-off. Perhaps I’m waxing way too lyrical here, but I believe these games will be enjoyed for decades to come by hardcore gamers curious about the secrets and machinations of the design and structure of these minimal, classic games.

Sure, they look simple. Their sound is crude. They’re sometimes almost unfairly hard, and can be frustrating and fiddly to play. But damn, they’re just so brilliant and involving, and so incredibly rewarding. On the surface they are rudimentary, yet they create an experience that transcends the limited technology upon which they were built.

These are true classics, and I love them. Deeply love them. I’m not even going to bother to rate them, because you already know the score – and you already know whether or not you need to buy them.

Tagged with 3DS Handhelds, PC, Puzzle, Reviews, Zelda.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Read this next

"The Nightmare Is Far From Over:" How the Artist Behind Garfield Gameboy'd Dreamed up His Four-Color Horror Show

LumpyTouch's mock-playthrough of an unreleased Garfield horror game is a terrifying, pus-filled labor of love.

The 25 Best Nintendo Switch Games

Our rotating list of the best Nintendo Switch games, now bigger than before!

Sega Explains Why Team Sonic Racing Opening Cutscene is Missing on Switch

The size limitations on the Switch cartridge is to blame.

Apex Legends Downward Spiral Continues After Reported Second Consecutive Decline in Revenue

Analysts report double-digit losses for Respawn's battle royale.

Marvel Ultimate Alliance 3 Adds More X-Men to its Roster

It's not just Wolverine showing up for the fun.

More Reviews

Observation Review

An eerie space station adventure that's derailed by some questionable design decisions.

Team Sonic Racing Review

After having his license revoked, Sonic is back behind the wheel.

Rage 2 Review

Bullets flying, fists crunching, and bodies falling. Rage is back with its own flavor of rip and tear.

Logitech G502 Lightspeed Review

One of Logitech's most-loved designs returns.

More on 3DS

The Best Resident Evil Games: Every Resident Evil Ranked From Worst to Best

In this ranking of the Resident Evil games, we decide which ones are Tyrant-grade and which ones are basic, brain-dead zombies.

Geodude Evolved into the Mascot of Japan’s Iwate Prefecture

Geodude might get massacred by Grass-types in Pokemon battles, but he's a real swell mascot.

Detective Pikachu is on Track to be the Highest Grossing Video Game Movie Ever, But It Might Not Be Enough

Detective Pikachu is on track to become the highest grossing video game film, but it's not necessarily the juggernaut we expected.

Which Pokemon Would Be Your Partner in Detective Pikachu's Ryme City?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | "[Insert Pokemon name here]! I choose you!"

Detective Pikachu Roundtable: What We Think After Seeing the New Live-Action Pokemon Movie

Which Pokemon won Detective Pikachu? Is it the best video game movie ever? And who is the best human character outside of Bill Nighy?

More Puzzle Games

The 25 Best Steam Games: Now Updated for 2019

A rotating list of the best games on Steam may seem impossible on the surface, but against all odds, we've done it!

Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons is Coming to Switch With Co-Op and Director's Commentary

Josef Fares will be giving the inside look into Brothers.

Observation Review

An eerie space station adventure that's derailed by some questionable design decisions.