Vagrant Story's Localizers Dispel Myths About the Script in New Interview

John Learned talks to the translators who gave life to Vagrant Story's English script. Don't miss it!

News by Nadia Oxford, .

We learned a lot about Final Fantasy VII through Matt Leone's excellent oral history, but there was one factoid that didn't come as a surprise: Square-Enix put very little thought into the game's translation.

Game translation and localization was a rough business through the '80s and '90s. There were certainly exceptions – Ted Woolsey's translation of Final Fantasy III SNES and Chrono Trigger remain legendary to this day – but if anything, some of the comments from Final Fantasy VII's developers in Leone's oral history make it clear Square Japan never realized Woolsey had talent.

True Tales from Localization Hell

COVER STORY: Three veterans of video game translation recount their most harrowing projects.

But Final Fantasy VII's western success convinced Square-Enix to do better with its translations on a consistent basis. 2000's Vagrant Story for the PlayStation marks a clear turning point for Square-Enix's localization efforts. Translator Alexander O Smith worked hard with localization editor Richard Amtower to bring life to Yasumi Matsuno's grim, rusty medieval world.

USgamer contributor John Learned interviewed Smith and Amtower, and the exchange unveils a lot of new and interesting information about what it was like to be part of such a pivotal moment in Square-Enix's story writing history.

On adding thematic voice to Matsuno's original dialogue without destroying the original meaning: [Smith:] "Part of the spin added came as a reaction to the rich setting of the game, not to fix any 'shortcomings' in the script. If the setting is a pseudo-medieval European setting, while the Japanese language should stay fairly standard (there weren't many Japanese speakers in medieval Europe), the English really wants to at least nod its head toward that time."

On adding imagery via wordplay: [Smith:] "There was also a lot of nudging of words going on to help support the imagery in the game. In the original, the city of Lea Monde is referred to as a 'farm' for undead, but this was changed (with team approval) to a 'spring,' and all the words related to the dark power of the place changed to fit that theme—words like 'surge,' 'stream,' and 'well.'"

On playing with (appropriate) pop culture references: [Smith:] "Yeah, the room names were a fun challenge, because the Japanese names were very long, and we didn't have anywhere near the space in English to directly translate, which gave me free reign to translate very, very loosely. I also took a queue from Matsuno's many homages to Queen songs and lyrics, by throwing in some Bauhaus references in keeping with the gothic feel of some of the areas in the game. Some samples:

"Direct Translation: Mineshaft where (someone) spent all their strength for the one they loved.

"Final English: Passion of Lovers."

Game localization is a fascinating subject, and Learned's interview with Smith and Amtower is a treasure house of insight. Be sure to check it out.

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Comments 6

  • Avatar for Godots17thCup #1 Godots17thCup A year ago
    I've been meaning to play Vagrant Story for years and years (I even bought the PSOne Classics port a while back), but its reputation for being very difficult if you can't wrap your head around its mechanics always ends up scaring me off. Maybe I'll finally rectify that later this year.

    Anyway, I genuinely love getting these in-depth looks at the localization process, whether it's Alexander O. Smith, Ted Woolsey, Ace Attorney (Janet Hsu sometimes posts interesting nuggets on Capcom's Ace Attorney blog during the lead up to a new game), XSEED (their official Tumblr tends to post really good stuff, and Kotaku had a great piece a couple years ago about what an ordeal Trails in the Sky was to bring over), Dragon Quest or Final Fantasy.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for cldmstrsn #2 cldmstrsn A year ago
    @Godots17thCup just use a guide and you will absolutely love it and it will help you get a grip on the mechanics.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for SatelliteOfLove #3 SatelliteOfLove A year ago

    Not That Guide, though.

    Find the logic, not the minutiae, Godot's, as VS is a game based on game design logic, not game design duct tape. It's also very "CRPGish" in that in other ways.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for kidgorilla #4 kidgorilla A year ago
  • Avatar for alex32 #5 alex32 A year ago
  • Avatar for Arvis-Jaggamar #6 Arvis-Jaggamar A year ago
    I WILL replay this one of these days. And this time, I'll know what I'm doing.
    How I beat this game as a 16-year-old with no internet access is beyond me.
    Sign in to Reply