Is Storage Wars' "Huge Game Find" Really Worth $45,000? Probably Not

Bargain hunter Rene Nezhoda allegedly made a lot of money off old Atari games on Storage Wars. Get ready for an excited phone call from your grandmother.

Opinion by Nadia Oxford, .

Growing up, I didn't treat my video games and consoles with care. I cut up my Final Fantasy III SNES box for a school project. I scribbled in my NES instruction booklets. I banished old systems to the bottoms of closets and toy boxes when I received upgrades.

It's because of people like me that the secondary games market is thriving. There's a big demand for old, neatly-boxed games accompanied by instruction booklets that don't feature characters screaming swear words in red crayon. Unfortunately, since most people treated their collection with the same lack of reverence I did (we're #1!!), hale and hearty games are hard to come by – especially games released in limited quantities towards the end of a system's lifespan.

Double Dragon IV PS4 Review: Retro - to a Fault

It looks like an NES game. It sounds like an NES game. It even plays like an NES game. But Double Dragon IV is actually brand new.

In other words, collecting retro games is an expensive and complicated hobby, but too many people believe old games are extraordinarily valuable, period, regardless of what condition they're in, or how common they are.

That's why a recent episode of Storage Wars has some retro game collectors rolling their eyes. A buyer named Rene Nezhoda secures a locker full of what appears to be vintage game stuff for $1500. He brings in notable retro game collector Phillip "Fluffy Gamer" Braden to sort out the trash from the treasure, which is a good move. They paw through the collection, and a few noteworthy finds get a bit of screentime, including Bubble Bobble 2 and S.C.A.T. for the NES (what an unfortunate acronym), and M.U.S.H.A. for the Genesis. Bubble Bobble 2's loose cartridge and S.C.A.T.'s cartridge go for around $150 - $200 on eBay. M.U.S.H.A.'s cartridge goes for about $300.

Not bad. The final haul is estimated at $45,000, though we really don't have a good idea of how the crew reaches that number. We just see boxes of random stuff with numbers ticking up and up – including a box containing an NES and some old VHS tapes. The camera also flashes by some interesting finds, like a Vectrex vector-display console from 1982. An in-box Vectrex can earn you $600+ on eBay, but the Vectrex we see in Storage Wars is loose and dusty. We don't know if it works.

"Why didn't anyone buy our game? It has the coolest name ever!"

There are other brief flashes of "treasure," like a box full of Game & Watch systems. This could be another potentially decent find, but the word here is "potentially." We don't see the names of the Game & Watch handhelds Nezhoda and Braden find (some units are worth more than others), nor do we receive any indication that they're even working. Jumbled boxes of Atari games are valued at thousands of dollars.

You can see footage of the find here, though the sound's been turned way down to avoid a copyright strike.

I don't doubt Nezhoda made back his $1500 without a problem, but I'm skeptical about the final tally of $45,000. Career retro game trader Pat "The NES Punk" Contri is certain Nezhoda's supposed treasure trove isn't worth anything close to $45,000. His friend Ian Ferguson, who helps run a used game store, concurs.

If you feel like putting some numbers together, Nezhoda shifts through some of his finds game-by-game, each one marked with an asking price. As some of the commenters on his videos point out, many of the games are well above eBay prices. Nezhoda has also called out Contri for saying the games aren't nearly as valuable as Nezhoda believes they are.

Retro video games are serious business.

"Metallic Uniframe Super Hybrid Armor." Had to look that one up.

I'm not deeply involved in the collecting community; I just have a passing interest and a general knowledge of how things work. Nezhoda may have scored $45,000 worth of games in a dusty storage room. If he did, good for him! But if I had to guess at a number or forfeit my life, based on the info we're given in the episode, I wouldn't say his find is close to $45,000.

However involved you are (or aren't) with used game collecting, however, there's a lot to take away from all this hot drama. For starters, approach Storage Wars with a pocket full of salt: The show is currently entangled in lawsuits for allegedly rigging "big" finds.

Second, approach all stories about how "thousands of dollars worth of video games might be in your basement!" with a dumptruck full of salt. Your yellowed SNES isn't worth much, nor is your library of childhood NES games – unless you happened to collect the likes of Dragon Warrior II, III, and IV. And if you have a box full of Atari 2600 games, for what they're worth you may as well carry the cartridges into the woods and take pot-shots at them with a BB gun.

If you read this site on a regular basis, this is all probably review. Just be sure to educate well-meaning parents and grandparents who watch programs like Storage Wars, then call you excitedly to say you should sell your "Nintendo tapes" to pay off your student loans.

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Comments 8

  • Avatar for yuberus #1 yuberus 10 months ago
    I will say there are a number of 2600 games that routinely sell for $100+, and coupled with stuff like MUSHA, Bubble Bobble 2, etc. it could certainly be a haul worth tens of thousands of dollars. But yes, it does depend pretty heavily on what kind of stuff is in there. That said, given how cheap games were in the 90s when, I assume, most of these were purchased? Could very easily be a treasure trove.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for nadiaoxford #2 nadiaoxford 10 months ago
    @yuberus Oh, were there some high-selling Atari games in there? I was under the impression those are suuuuuper rare because Atari just flooded the market with junk nobody wanted (part of the reason for the crash, obvs, haha).

    I assumed, probably idiotically, that if they found anything resembling a Stadium Events-level game, they would've shown it off instead of going for footage of broken-down Colecovision mini-arcade units.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Lane #3 Lane 10 months ago
    I dunno - the law of averages means most of what you're going to find is going to be bog standard stuff that you can barely give away, unless the original owner of the storage bin was actively hoarding rare hardware and software - and from the condition it was in, I doubt that was the case. The only way it would total $45K is either through sheer volume, or a couple of truly rare finds - like a NIB Air Raid cart for the 2600 or Stadium Events, etc.Edited 3 times. Last edited April 2017 by Lane
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for riderkicker #4 riderkicker 10 months ago
    Best thing about games, if it works it's worth its price. Unlike comic books which are pretty tough to keep in the condition you originally got it, and you hope your most valuable issue doesn't become a Fair from a Fine.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for yuberus #5 yuberus 10 months ago
    @nadiaoxford I don't remember the footage entirely but I'm pretty sure I saw Swordquest Waterworld in there, and that's certainly a game that hovers around 100 bucks. Throw in stuff like Quadrun, Rescue Terra I, Halloween, Texas Chainsaw Massacre, or the Commavid library and you could clean up decently.

    Like $45k seems pretty optimistic but I could believe it.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for SatelliteOfLove #6 SatelliteOfLove 10 months ago
    M.U.S.H.A. stands for "Most Ultimate Slaying Head-banging Awesomeness"

    Also, finds like that don't come nowadays unless you stumble into The Gerstmann Collection or something.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for yuberus #7 yuberus 10 months ago
    @SatelliteOfLove I really miss collecting in the late 90s/early 00s. I paid 7 bucks for MUSHA at a Gamestop, and 5 bucks for Gun-Nac at a flea market! Gunstar Heroes? $20 in a lot of like 10 games. Outright handed a box full of Genesis RPGs from a guy who didn't want them anymore. $2 for a pair of rare Odyssey2 carts and a Pong unit. $150 for a Neo Geo and two games (fatal Fury and Cyber Lip). Just insane deals left and right by today's standards!

    And now I can't believe I ever thought $150 for a complete Panzer Dragoon Saga was robbery.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for michaelburns64 #8 michaelburns64 10 months ago
    I actually *could* pay off my student loans with my game collection, but I'd rather stick to my quest of one day owning every SNES game in existence than feel secure in the knowledge that I don't own anything to anyone.

    Like you said, it's complicated.Edited April 2017 by michaelburns64
    Sign in to Reply