Two Legal Experts On Why Battle Passes are Better Than Loot Boxes (Legally Speaking)

Two Legal Experts On Why Battle Passes are Better Than Loot Boxes (Legally Speaking)

Two attorneys discuss their new book on video game law, and answer a few of our questions.

With ROM sites shutting down and governments cracking down on loot boxes, the legal world of video games can seem quite byzantine at times. Enter Greg Boyd and Sean Kane, two attorneys who specialize specifically in video game law, and they share their expertise to readers in their new book "Video Game Law – Everything You Need to Know about Legal and Business Issues in the Game Industry."

We got a chance to speak with Boyd and Kane and ask some legal questions of our own. Namely, whether we'll see a sequel to the biggest legal drama in video games in some time: loot boxes.

"The book has 12 chapters and it's really aimed at the general video game audience," says Greg Boyd who co-chairs the interactive entertainment group at Frankfurt Kurnit alongside Sean Kane. "We deliberately didn't write a textbook in the hardcore sense of a textbook used in a law class." Instead, each chapter of the book covers a legal topic in the video game world whether it's game ratings, gambling, or licensing, something Kane specializes in.

A Star Crate (Loot Box) formerly in Star Wars Battlefront 2.

Considering that an entire chapter is dedicated to gambling and video games, I asked whether we could see a similar situation play out with Battle Passes, a recent trend in video games that offer in-game rewards for completing specific milestones or in-game challenges. The way Battle Passes are designed seem to be specifically counter to loot boxes where players might not even know what kind of prizes they'll win.

"People think of loot boxes as rolling a die, but the fact is that the die can be different for different players is pretty revelatory for some folks...and at a certain level maybe that feels a smidge unfair if it's not disclosed," says Boyd about loot boxes. "Battle Passes strike me as a substantial improvement."

"I generally agree with Greg," says Kane. "A lot of states allow you to win an item – pay to win an item. So, it's based on your skill, your knowledge, your abilities. So, under that law, Battle Pass I think are much, much better...The way that most battle passes are set up I think are kind of state-of-the-art in the industry. And they shouldn't have a reason to have regulators questioning them."

"It's much better than a black box mechanism where you don't know what you're going to get if anything," adds Boyd. "And not to say that those are impermissible, but the battle pass systems are an improvement certainly in disclosure and are likely to hold up better under scrutiny."

While this is an informal conversation on the topic, it's interesting to get an opinion on Battle Passes as more and more games adopt them. Games like Rocket League and PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds have announced battle pass systems following the success of the program in Fortnite Battle Royale. It's probably not a coincidence that both PUBG and Rocket League were flagged by the Dutch Gaming Comission for their loot boxes.

So are battle passes the future of the video game industry? Fortnite certainly has found success with the system and as Boyd and Kane say in our conversation, Battle Passes are in a stronger position against regulations.

For more check out "Video Game Law – Everything You Need to Know about Legal and Business Issues in the Game Industry" which is currently available from book sellers.

Matt Kim

News Editor

Matt Kim is a former freelance writer who's covered video games and digital media. He likes video games as spectacle and is easily distracted by bright lights or clever bits of dialogue. He also once wrote about personal finance, but that's neither here nor there.

Related articles

GDC 2020 Has Been Postponed

This year's Game Developers Conference will no longer be held in March due to novel coronavirus concerns.

A Doom Crossover Would Be up to Nintendo, but id Sure Loves Those Animal Crossing Memes

Executive Producer Marty Stratton talks id Software's relationship with Nintendo, the state of Doom Eternal's Switch port, and more at PAX East 2020.

Everything Else That Happened in Gaming While Coronavirus Dominated the Headlines

THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | COVID-19 concerns dominated headlines, but they were far from the week's only noteworthy news

You may also like

What Game Do You Replay At Least One Per Year?

COMMUNITY REQUEST | Let's talk about the games we never quite finish playing.

House of the Gundead Fits the Chaos of Enter the Gungeon in an Arcade Cabinet

The Enter the Gungeon spin-off makes a number of risky genre moves, but is better off for it.

Kerbal Space Program 2 Devs on Why Development Was Brought In-House

At PAX East 2020, we catch up with the developers at the newly formed studio behind Kerbal Space Program 2.

USG Game of the Month for February 2020: Nothing

GAME OF THE MONTH | It was a bit of a dry month in terms of standouts.