Looking Backward and Forward with the Final Fantasy Team

Kitase and Toriyama reflect on the series' changes and the path to reinvigorated success.

Preview by Jeremy Parish, .

When I interviewed the leads on Lighting Returns: Final Fantasy XIII the other day, we spoke primarily about that game and, to a lesser degree, the HD remaster versions of Final Fantasy X and X-2 (along with some general philosophical questions). I was particularly intrigued by Motomu Toriyama's thoughts on revisiting Final Fantasy X-2. Probably best known as the director on all three titles in the XIII/Lightning saga, Toriyama actually made his debut in the director's chair with X-2.

"Looking back on the development environment of the original games, the director would have to code too," he mused. "I’d be building the scripts for the mini-games or menu screens and event scenes as well. I was able to do a lot of things on my own.

"When the original Final Fantasy X and X-2 were released, I was able to see the developers’ personal tastes reflected in the programming. Nowadays, on the PS3, everything has shifted to being tool-based. The role of the director is more about guiding each group or each section, as far as what direction they should go building their tools together. It comes out very polished and very professional, but at the same time, it’s harder to see the flavor of the individual developers in different things. That’s what I’ve noticed over the years."

Rikku's ribs: Now presented in HD for that authentic emaciated look.

It's not difficult to draw a line between the troubled development cycle of FFXIII and the poignance of his retrospection. Toriyama takes heat for many of XIII's unpopular elements and for the stories he's penned for these games as well as others (including The 3rd Birthday), and certainly some criticism is fair. Still, I'm increasingly of the opinion that he and the rest of his team have been caught in an impossible place between the Final Fantasy series' legacy of high-spec visuals and Square Enix's slow-to-adapt internal production processes. Their internal developers have a learned a lot of hard lessons since the brash proclamation that FFXIII was going to be so extraordinary it would have to consist of three games back in 2006 (an announcement that has come true, but not in the way they intended).

XIII in particular suffered from a notoriously wasteful development cycle that reportedly focused on creating artwork and graphical assets for most of its gestation period only to have half of those assets thrown out at the end, with the rest of the game being bolted together at the very last minute. In contrast, Lightning Returns looks to have been built beginning primarily with its world and systems first; as a result, it's less visually spectacular than its predecessor, but seems a lot more like the kind of game Final Fantasy enthusiasts will actually want to play. Burdened as he is with the expectation to make games as content-rich as classic Final Fantasies but as visual spectacular as eight-hour linear first-person shooters, I can certainly understand Toriyama's nostalgia for bygone times.

That being said, he was far more reticent when I asked about his thoughts on Sony and Microsoft's next-gen platforms, immediately deflecting the responsibility to answer to his boss, producer Yoshinori Kitase.

Lightning mostly uses lightning attacks in the E3 demo; here Snow uses ice. Vanille, of course, will use spice-related attacks.

"As far as the information that’s been revealed," Kitase answered, "some details have been shared on the PS4 for a while now, with things like the share button. Just yesterday we saw Microsoft and their ability to share gameplay video that you can take by yourself and share it with the world. It’s interesting that, in the past generation change, they’d be boasting about improved graphics quality and processing power. This generation, it seems like they’re more focused on the ability to share and connect with each other.

"Seeing that, with Lightning Returns, we’re trying to get a head start on this trend. We have plans to incorporate options to share. You can take screenshots from the game and share it on your social networks. That’s something we think is interesting and we’d like to take advantage of."

Again, it's not difficult to connect the dots; Kitase and Toriyama appear to have accepted the fact that staying at the cutting edge of graphics is a game for a handful of studios that can sink extraordinary amounts of money into a single project and outsource most of the labor to external teams, something that the Final Fantasy series -- whose installments sell two million copies, not the 10 million necessary to sustain that sort of investment -- can't necessarily afford to do. Clearly, they see (correctly) the next-generation race as one of features and extensibility rather than a race to the next graphical plateau (frankly, the Xbox One and PS4 titles on display here at E3 are barely distinguishable from high-end PC games).

I get the impression that Kitase and Toriyama see an opportunity to put Final Fantasy at the forefront of the industry again, though I don't know that simply adding Twitter support to the game will do the trick. Still, it's a start. As someone who remembers the days when you could pick up a new Final Fantasy and play something you'd never experienced before, I wouldn't mind seeing the series clawing its way back to the cutting edge again -- and given the cheers that greeted the Final Fantasy XV announcement at Sony's press conference, there's are still a lot of people out there who share the sentiment.

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Comments 10

  • Avatar for Baleoce #1 Baleoce 4 years ago
    The FFXV trailer gave me chills. I hope they are able to turn this around and bring the series back properly. I was a fan of how FFXII attempted to re-envision Final Fantasy for a new era, besides the relatively dull story, everything else felt great. FFXV looks like it could be on track for that approach, but I think they might be able to take it a step or two further this time. Time will tell :)
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for pjedavison #2 pjedavison 4 years ago
    I really liked FFXII, but you're right, the story was dull. Even after it inexplicably became Star Wars at the end.

    I actually didn't have as much of a problem with XIII as some people seem to, but I'm really, REALLY excited to see more of XV.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for speakeasywylie #3 speakeasywylie 4 years ago
    I'm excited for XV too. It has an Advent Children feel.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for speakeasywylie #4 speakeasywylie 4 years ago
    I'm excited for XV too. It has an Advent Children feel.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Shinta #5 Shinta 4 years ago
    I don't think they really believe that twitter support is their ticket to being number 1 in the industry. It's just a small additional feature. It's neat though. When you factor in that Lightning has 100 costumes now, and accessories, and the ability to customize color on all of it, people are all going to have unique outfits and will want to show them off a bit.

    As far as their commitment to cutting edge graphics, XV more than answers that question. They're right at the forefront, as always. If you had any doubt, watch Agni's Philosophy again.

    They aren't abandoning cutting edge production values. They are just becoming better at anticipating what to invest into each project and are more flexible. They're investing different amounts into Lightning Returns and XV because they will sell different amounts. They are investing less in Drakengard 3 because it won't sell big either.

    This is exactly what they need to get good at so their sales projections are more accurate and they can have a wider range of medium tier and top tier content that can all be successful.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for jeremy.parish #6 jeremy.parish 4 years ago
    Not Twitter support per se, but social integration. It's a value-added feature for now and I'm glad they're experimenting with it, but I don't think LRFFXIII necessarily lends itself to that sort of thing.

    As for the cutting edge... Agni is just a demo, and all I could think when I saw it was, "Oh god, it's happening all over again. FFXV looks great, yeah, but it's been in the works for years (and has supposedly been targeting next-gen for a couple of years now) -- not a viable development model.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Dreamcaster-X #7 Dreamcaster-X 4 years ago
    I'm looking forward to XV more than any other FF since XII. XIII was a big letdown to me but I've been impressed with what I've seen of XV. Really hoping it's the one that puts the franchise back on the tracks!
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Kuni-Nino #8 Kuni-Nino 4 years ago
    Hopefully LR turns out well. I find myself sort of rooting for the game as weird as that sounds.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Riverking #9 Riverking 4 years ago
    The time mechanic looks interesting. Hopefully it will force the player to make some hard decisions and add a bit of replay value.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Shinta #10 Shinta 4 years ago
    They have been working on XV for years, but that doesn't mean that they've been working on it this entire time with a full team and zero extenuating circumstances.

    PS3's cell architecture hobbled Crystal Tools from the start and they ran into massive delays like most people did on PS3. The jump to HD development was also tougher on everyone than usual generation leaps.

    XIV also had major issues and set the game back quite a bit.

    Nomura confirmed that they've really only been working on XV in its current form for a little over a year. They didn't have anything close to a full Versus team all this time. They simply showed the CG trailer way, way too early.

    Luminous has real time editing and they're now doing overspec development on PC, as well as getting comfortable outsourcing parts. PS4 has a friendlier development environment than at virtually any other time in Playstation's history. This is going to make things faster and easier on everyone.

    Their development pipeline is already greatly improved. They rebuilt the entirety of FFXIV: ARR in 2 years. Their model is going to work just fine as long as the sales are there for games like XV, and Kingdom Hearts 3, and I think they will be.Edited June 2013 by Shinta
    Sign in to Reply