Madden Lawsuit Moves Forward as EA Sports' Free Speech Defense Fails

Madden Lawsuit Moves Forward as EA Sports' Free Speech Defense Fails

As far as the Supreme Court is concerned, EA knew what it was doing when it used the likenesses of former NFL players.

The U.S. Supreme Court has rejected EA Sports' free speech defense in the lawsuit involving the Madden franchise, according to a report by Reuters. The lawsuit was filed on behalf of former NFL players, who contend that EA is using their likenesses without compensation.

Electronic Arts pays a license fee to the NFL to use the likenesses of current NFL players, but it hasn't paid any fees for the likenesses of former NFL players. EA Sports previously argued that the use of the likenesses was "incidental" and protected by free speech laws. A previous ruling in January 2015 disagreed with this contention, as did the high court in this case.

"EA's use of the former players' likenesses is not incidental, because it is central to EA's main commercial purpose - to create a realistic virtual simulation of football games involving current and former NFL teams," Circuit Judge Raymond Fisher explained in the ruling for the appeal in January 2015.

The lawsuit was filed on the behalf of former NFL players, including Tony Davis from the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Vince Ferragamo from the LA Rams, and Billy Joe DuPree from the Dallas Cowboys. EA Sports argued that the use of likenesses was coincidental, as the names weren't used within the game, only the basic visual attributes. The ruling above and this current ruling have shot down that defense.

This is a similar case to the one filed by former college football players in relation to NCAA Football. The result of that case was EA Sports ultimately decided to cease development on its annual NCAA titles. Here, EA Sports probably won't drop Madden NFL, but it's likely that previous players' stats and likenesses will be removed for the game completely. The lawsuit in this case involved the use of likenesses from 2001 to 2009.

The case in question is Electronic Arts v. Davis, U.S. Supreme Court, No. 15-424.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Mike Williams

Reviews Editor

M.H. Williams is new to the journalism game, but he's been a gamer since the NES first graced American shores. Third-person action-adventure games are his personal poison: Uncharted, Infamous, and Assassin's Creed just to name a few. If you see him around a convention, he's not hard to spot: Black guy, glasses, and a tie.

Read this next

Apple Arcade is Way Cooler Than You Think. Here are 10 Games to Check Out

Apple Arcade has dozens of neat games, so we highlighted 10 from its launch lineup that are a bit under the radar.

Apex Legends Season 3 Starts in a Couple Weeks, Here's What's Changing With It

On top of confirming Crypto, Respawn wants to make its battle royale more competitive than ever.

Batman's Lego and Arkham Trilogies Are Free for One Week—No Will Arnett or Origins Though

Gotham's grittiest and goofiest are free for a limited time on Epic Games Store.

How Queen Latifah Became a Last-Minute Addition to Sayonara Wild Hearts

Developer Simogo tells us how one off-handed suggestion landed them a major celeb.

Warframe Developer Responds to Recent Wave of Negative Reviews on Steam

Several issues with the Chinese Warframe community brought on a torrent of negativity.

Shenmue 3 Was a Much Simpler Game Before Deep Silver Agreed to Publish It

In the Beginning, there was only story and quick time events.

We Dare You to Eat This Pile of Ancient Pokemon Food

Expiration dates are just suggestions.

More News

Apex Legends Season 3 Starts in a Couple Weeks, Here's What's Changing With It

On top of confirming Crypto, Respawn wants to make its battle royale more competitive than ever.

Batman's Lego and Arkham Trilogies Are Free for One Week—No Will Arnett or Origins Though

Gotham's grittiest and goofiest are free for a limited time on Epic Games Store.

How Queen Latifah Became a Last-Minute Addition to Sayonara Wild Hearts

Developer Simogo tells us how one off-handed suggestion landed them a major celeb.

Warframe Developer Responds to Recent Wave of Negative Reviews on Steam

Several issues with the Chinese Warframe community brought on a torrent of negativity.