Madden NFL 17 Review: Another First Down

Madden NFL 17 Review: Another First Down

Smart but subtle additions rule the day in the latest edition of EA's football simulator.

Jump to: Page 1 Page 2

I could make a million jokes about infamously conservative LA Rams coach Jeff Fisher calling for two with time expiring and a playoff berth on the line in Madden 17's prologue. It's a flatout crazy moment that could potentially say all kinds of unflattering things about Madden's realism. But here's the thing: Madden's actually pretty good these days.

Over the past couple years, EA Tiburon has made marked progress in improving Madden at the fundamental level, investing a large amount of resources in building blocks like line play, catch interactions, and running locomotion. It hasn't always been better, but take a look back at 2013's Madden 25 or even the far superior Madden 15, and the difference is stark. Madden 17 is a better game in pretty much every way.

Madden 17 is meant to be a culmination of the revamp that began with Madden 15. Next year, EA Tiburon hopes to take what they've built and start adding in some truly cool new features. The question is: How well does the foundation hold up? Let's take a closer look.

For those who are new to the series

Madden NFL is a massive and intimidating game for those coming in for the first time. If you're not already versed the in formations, terminology, and strategy of football, you're apt to feel pretty overwhelmed. To its credit, though, Madden does a better job than pretty much any sports game in familiarizing you with its concepts and getting you comfortable.

It begins with an imaginary game between the newly-relocated Los Angeles Rams and the Washington football team in which you get to enjoy an NFL Films-style story while learning the basic controls. Madden then takes you into the tutorialized Skills Trainer before finally dumping you into the main game. Spend some time in the Skills Trainer and Madden will patiently explains concepts like Cover 1 and Cover 2, as well as the often impenetrable jargon surrounding the game. As tutorials go, it does about as good a job as possible in explaining the insanely complicated game that is American Football.

The new Falcons stadium is in Madden 17, and it looks much better from the inside than it does from the outside.

Once you get properly going, you can choose to play franchise mode, ranked online play, Ultimate Team, and Draft Champions, or you can just play a quick exhibition game with the teams of your choice. Madden 17 also includes a somewhat janky but serviceable custom playbook editor - a holdover from the now prehistoric Madden 12 - and a roster editor. Sadly, there are no historical teams to choose from, and you can't create your own team from scratch, but Madden's customization options are otherwise adequate.

Where you end up spending the bulk of your time in Madden depends on how you like to play. Simulation nuts will likely opt for franchise mode, which allows you to run a team as a coach, an owner, or a player. Ultimate Team, meanwhile, is a card-collecting mode in which you play through solo challenges and build up your own custom team. Finally, Draft Champions allows you to quickly draft a team and take it online.

Of them all, Ultimate Team is probably the strongest, though it is admittedly a bit of a grind. As Madden 17's primary moneymaker, it's the mode that gets the bulk of the attention throughout the year, continually picking up new content and cards each week. It's easy to knock it for being too microtransaction-oriented - MUT practically begs you to buy its various bundles in order to obtain high-level players - but it's not too hard to build up a good team by completing the various solo challenges. Out of all the Ultimate Teams, it has the most to do outside of taking your team online and playing other people.

Franchise mode.

Franchise mode, for its part, does a decent job of simulating the day-to-day of running a football team, though with the caveat that it's a bit dry. Players grow with the help of XP earned by playing games, and there are lots of little updates and news items to keep you engaged. It's single best feature is the ability to invite friends and form an online league with drafts, free agents, and championships. If you want, you can even move a team and create the Mexico City Diablos. Sadly, there's no way to play a basic season with none of the headaches of franchise mode.

Franchise mode is also plagued by a number of legacy issues. Choosing to play as an owner, for example, means being stuck with inane decisions like whether to raise the price of concessions; and if you're the owner of a team like the Jaguars, you're almost guaranteed to run out of money and find yourself unable to sign new players. Player mode, meanwhile, is sterile in the extreme - a narrative-free mode that does absolutely nothing to make you feel like you're an actual player in the NFL. If you want to enjoy everything franchise mode has to offer, then playing as a coach is really the only way to go.

On the field, Madden is an attractive and vibrant football simulation. The stadiums are impressively detailed, and new commentators Brandon Gaudin and Charles have a smooth and natural rapport. If you're at a loss as to which play to pick, the playcalling interface does a good job of recommending context-appropriate plays. When the ball is snapped, on-screen prompts will tell you when to juke or spin, and it's even possible to hand complete control over the CPU and let them do skill moves for you. As in the real NFL, success is a matter of learning how to quickly diagnose defenses and make the right play.

You can nitpick a lot of little aspects about Madden's gameplay - aggresssive catches are arguably still too powerful, for example - but as a football simulator it actually feels pretty good. And if you're willing to really go down the rabbit hole, there are hundreds of hours to be found in Ultimate Team and franchise mode. But at the end of the day, most fans will only be playing to take their favorite team to the Super Bowl (and maybe run up the score on their rivals); and in that capacity, Madden can be a lot of fun.

Jump to: Page 1 Page 2

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Kat Bailey

Editor in Chief

Kat Bailey is a former freelance writer and contributor to publications including 1UP, IGN, GameSpot, GamesRadar, and EGM. Her fondest memories as a journalist are at GamePro, where she hosted RolePlayer's Realm and had legal access to the term "Protip." She is USgamer's resident mecha enthusiast, Pokemon Master, and Minnesota Vikings nut (skol).

Read this next

Ranking the Best Sports Game Franchise Modes: From Madden NFL 17 to NBA 2K17

Which sports game has the best franchise mode? Let's take a look.

Madden NFL 17's Pass/Run Glitch is Currently Killing Online Play

If you want to play online, you're apt to run into widespread abuse of this rather annoying glitch.

Madden Ultimate Team: Tips on the Best Budget Players for Every Position in Madden NFL 17

The MUT players you want to buy if you're building on a budget.

Why Madden NFL 17 Started From Scratch With Its Commentary

Charles Davis and Brandon Gaudin are the new voices of Madden NFL, but the changes to the commentary go much deeper than a pair of new faces.

Reggie Fils-Aimé's Been Up To a Lot Since His Retirement From Nintendo

The former Nintendo of America president has been pretty active.

The 25 Best Nintendo Switch Games

Our rotating list of the best games on Switch, now updated for the Nintendo Switch Lite release!

Former Dragon Age Writer David Gaider Co-Founds Summerfall Studios in Australia

Gaider and fellow co-founder Liam Esler previously worked together at Beamdog.

More Reviews

GreedFall Review

And I'm greed, greedfallin'.

Sayonara Wild Hearts Review

Wild hearts can't be broken.

Logitech G604 Review

Logitech revives another one of its older mice for a new generation.

NHL 20 Review

A conservative update that nevertheless shouldn't be ignored by hockey fans.

More on PlayStation 4

Destiny 2: Shadowkeep Story Previews Tease What Eris Morn’s Been up to All This Time

She may have met the expansion's true Hive villain already.

FIFA 20 Best Defenders: Best Players For CB, LB, and RB

Defenders are the core of any team in FIFA 20. Here are the best defenders that you should absolutely be keeping an eye on.

Man of Medan Endings - All the Endings Explained, How to Save Everyone

In this complete Man of Medan endings guide, we'll be going over the best and worst endings, endings explained, and how to save everyone.

FIFA 20 Best Goalkeepers: Best Players in the GK Position

You’ll need a solid goalie if you want to win in FIFA 20.

Raids, Loot, and Balance: Ubisoft Massive on The Division 2's Challenges Six Months Later

Ubisoft Massive is beginning to firm up the ongoing foundation of The Division 2.

Overwatch's Bastion Gets an Adorable Lego Skin for New Event

Just be careful you don't step on him.

Anthem Transitions to Seasonal Updates as Future Looks Murky

A new update from BioWare makes Anthem's future seem up in the air.

More Sports Games

FIFA 20 Best Defenders: Best Players For CB, LB, and RB

Defenders are the core of any team in FIFA 20. Here are the best defenders that you should absolutely be keeping an eye on.

FIFA 20 Best Goalkeepers: Best Players in the GK Position

You’ll need a solid goalie if you want to win in FIFA 20.

Session is the Skate 4 Fans Have Been Pining For... Almost

Session tries to capture the trial and error of skateboarding, but right now it feels like a lot of the latter.

Football Manager 2020 Switches to Recycled Paper Cases out of Concern for Plastic Pollution

Sega and Sports Interactive are estimating plastic savings totalling 20 metric tons.