Metroid: Samus Returns Review: A Near Perfect Remake of an Underappreciated Gem

At long last, Samus is truly back.

Review by Kat Bailey, .

Metroid II was my first Metroid game. Dark and atmospheric, with memorable monster designs and a great soundtrack, it left a definite impression on me. There was no denying that it was a flawed work, but its sense of creeping horror also made it an underappreciated gem on the Game Boy.

Unlike its predecessor and sequels, Metroid II was deliberately constrained, forcing you to clear each level before you were allowed to advance. It also had a rather different objective from its siblings: Kill Metroids. Lots of Metroids. Exploration was still important in Metroid II, but combat was even more at the forefront than usual.

As with many other 8-bit sequels, Metroid II's differences made it a bit of an oddball in its series, seemingly dooming it to the status of also-ran in discussions of Metroid's legacy. But popular interest has led to not one but two remakes of Metroid II, the second of which represents Nintendo's official stab at adapting it for the modern era.

Developed by MercurySteam (Castlevania: Lords of Shadow), the game that results is generally faithful to Metroid's basic structure, but also takes a number creative liberties. You're still hunting Metroids, but you have many more abilities, and the areas are much, much bigger. It also puts even more emphasis on combat, with far more elaborate enemy encounters and boss battles.

While it has plenty in common with its source material, MercurySteam clearly has their own vision for this remake: one that borrows heavily from Super Metroid. Their take on Metroid II leans heavily toward action, but still incorporates plenty of the complex traversal puzzles that the series is known for. And it works wonderfully.

Metroid: Samus Returns begins with the same premise that animated the original game: Samus is dispatched to SR3888 to wipe out every single Metroid, which is doable because there are apparently only around 40 of them in existence. Samus begins at the surface and slowly delves deep into the planet, where she encounters more and more powerful Metroids as she hunts for their queen. Along the way, she picks up numerous power-ups, including famous items like the Screw Attack and the Morph Ball, as well as some of the newer innovations from Super Metroid.

Like Metroid II, MercurySteam's remake gates progress with pools of acid, which keeps Samus from moving forward until she has cleared out all of the Metroids in a particular area. Outside of that, and the fact that the Metroids steadily evolve into new and more menacing forms, the 3DS remake is pretty much a totally new game.

The differences are evident the moment you first land on SR388 and begin to delve beneath the surface. If you've ever played the original game, you'll notice immediately that the layout of the opening area is totally different... and much bigger. Compared to Metroid II, Samus Returns is absolutely huge, and its areas are correspondingly complex. In true Metroid tradition, you will constantly come upon locked areas, some of which require items that you don't acquire until much later in the game. One side effect of this is that you are encouraged to return to areas you've previously explored: something that was absent amid the relentless forward momentum of the original game.

You won't find much—mostly optional add-ons like missile tanks—but it does have the effect of making SR388 feel like a more coherent whole, as opposed to a series of discrete sections. Plus it's good for completionists.

Aiding your exploration are the sorts of bells and whistles you would expect from a Metroid game. You get a map now, praise be, and teleporters that will beam you to different parts of the planets. These are extremely useful later in the game, when the areas get so big that backtracking becomes time-consuming. Meanwhile, a combination of the shoulder buttons and the touchscreen allow you to quickly activate your Ice Beam and missiles, making combat smooth and exciting.

I commented in an earlier piece linked above that Samus is a real badass in this remake, and that feeling only grows as you gain more abilities. Being able to aim freely with the help of the left shoulder button makes you immensely more dangerous. Your other skills come into play as well: when I ripped an extremely powerful foe from the ceiling with my grappling beam, I wanted to stand up and cheer. It just felt so great.

The combat is by far the most satisfying part of Samus Returns, and there are a lot of underlying factors that make it a success. MercurySteam leans heavily on old-school pattern recognition and never stoops to introducing cheap quicktime events. The battles are also balanced in such a way that your first encounter with a new enemy often pushes you to the brink. Even normal enemies can be daunting when you don't have the weapon you need to easily take them down.

You really feel it before you get your initial abilities, when just a couple hits are capable of killing you almost immediately. Flyers will zip in with their stingers, and until you get your timing right with Samus' new melee attack, you're apt to incur a good deal of damage. Even late in the game, when you're an unstoppable death machine with your Plasma Beam, you will still have to approach some enemies with a tactical mindset as mere damage isn't enough.

This is never more evident than in your battles with the Metroids scattered throughout the planet. These are intricate fights, and without giving away too much, you really have to pay attention to their individual weaknesses if you want to successfully take them down. Your first encounter with a new Metroid form is tense, beginning with a short cutscene in which Samus steps gingerly up to a discarded shell, followed by the new evolution bursting out of the darkness for a grand entrance. After that, you have to learn their complex patterns on the fly, which is especially tough against some of the most powerful evolutions.

These setpiece battles define Samus Returns, and they are infinitely more complex than they were in Metroid II. But there is a tradeoff: these elaborate encounters require their own spaces, meaning that you'll almost never get surprised by a Metroid while you're just exploring (though they will occasionally pop out of the blue). Personally, I missed the variety of fighting a Metroid in a sand trap, or using the Screw Attack to fend off a Gamma Metroid while dodging between a couple blocks high up in the air. But I was able to set aside my misgivings in light of how cool the battles were, especially in the latter half of the game.

The rest of Samus Returns is about getting to these fights, which is where the exploration comes in. In addition to its enemies, Samus Returns has water, lava, superheated rooms, and lots of hidden blocks to bomb. In fact, there are so many bombable blocks that one of Samus Returns' new abilities is a scanner that reveals what you can remove to proceed. The rest of the time you'll find yourself scrutinizing the map and asking, "Where haven't I been yet?" And as the layouts become more complex, you'll find yourself asking that question more and more.

Metroid Game By Game Reviews: Metroid II: Return of Samus

The constraints of portable design helped Nintendo develop smarter expressions of the Metroid concept.

These labyrinths are not difficult to solve—I can't recall ever being genuinely stuck—but that does not make them any less rewarding to complete. The bigger areas in particular take on lives of their own as you uncover new items, access new areas, battle minibosses, and knock out Metroids. Then, when you finally kill the last of the Metroids on that level, you get that satisfying ping from the main shrine to indicate that you're done (no more random earthquakes—now you turn in Metroid DNA to unlock the next area).

Over the course of the 10 hours or so that it took to complete Metroid: Samus Returns—during which I uncovered a scant 40 percent of the map—that loop kept me pretty much glued to my 3DS, eager to find the next Metroid and reach a new power-up. It definitely feels like a Metroid game, down to its updated tracks from Super Metroid and Metroid Prime. I daresay that it's even beautiful, which is not something I say very often about a 2D game with 3D graphics. MercurySteam really pushes the 3DS to the limit, with the late battles featuring some of the best graphics the platform has ever seen.

Best of all: It's minimalist. Samus doesn't have an A.I. boyfriend telling her what to do. She doesn't have deep-seated fears to overcome. What storytelling there is unfolds over a handful of short but highly effective cutscenes, and that's all it really needs.

In almost every respect, Samus Return is a near perfect remake. It grasps much of what worked in the original and dramatically heightens it while minimizing its flaws. There are so many great little touches throughout Samus Returns, from the menacing red eye of the mysterious... thing... stalking you throughout SR388, to the slime dripping in the background of the massive egg chambers at the heart of the planet.

I think there's an argument to be made that its structure is still a bit too rigid when compared to its peers—a holdover from the original game. And without the Game Boy game's weird, dissonant soundtrack, it loses a little bit of its spookiness. But then you get to the egg chamber, and all the sudden the remake feels every bit as creepy as the original. Speaking as a longtime Metroid fan, Samus Returns had me grinning like a maniac.

All told, Samus Returns is a strong comeback that stakes a legitimate claim on being the best game on the 3DS. MercurySteam has executed on this remake wonderfully, sliding in seamlessly with the rest of the series. It's been a long, frustrating seven year wait, but it's great to have Metroid back. Here's hoping it won't be leaving again any time soon.

The Nitty Gritty

  • Interface: An excellent interface makes it easy to seamlessly switch between weapons and access the map, making the combat feel that much better.
  • Sound: MercurySteam wisely doesn't try to mess with success here. Samus Returns mixes tracks from Metroid Prime, Super Metroid, and the original Metroid II, and the results are great.
  • Visuals: MercurySteam really makes use of the flexibility afforded by 3D graphics. The backgrounds are lively and interesting; some bosses make use of the 3D space, and there are little cutscenes sprinkled throughout. The latter half in particular is where Samus Returns really flexes its graphical muscle.

I was delighted by Metroid: Samus Returns. It hits pretty much every note you hope to see in a Metroid game, and MercurySteam's console background is evident in their flair for the dramatic— whether in their introductory cutscenes or their boss battles. Their dramatic reinvention reinvigorates the source material and strengthens the story's bridge to Super Metroid. In short: They nailed it.

5 /5

Metroid: Samus Returns Review: A Near Perfect Remake of an Underappreciated Gem Kat Bailey At long last, Samus is truly back. 2017-09-12T12:00:00-04:00 5 5

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Comments 32

Comments on this article are now closed. Thanks for taking part!

  • Avatar for Modern-Clix #1 Modern-Clix A year ago
    Terrific write up! Metroid 2 was my first Metroid game oddly enough, and I was just a lad back then, so I struggled with the original and never got far with how obtuse it was. Even more so than the first one since your character was so big and screen real estate made everything cramped, so of course I is nonsense of direction. So while I always loved the look and feel of the game, not to mention Samus, I did not fall in love with the series until Super Metroid. I am very happy to read in your review about all the changes and additions to keep it more in line with Super Metroid and the games that came after, and this weekend cannot come soon enough.

    Perfect timing too, since Hurricane Irma left me without power and Internet, so now I have something to help the time go by :)
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for orient #2 orient A year ago
    Probably the last physical 3DS game I'll buy - a fantastic way to go out.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for VotesForCows #3 VotesForCows A year ago
    @Modern-Clix Good luck getting everything back on track, looks like you all have had a rough time of it.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for yuberus #4 yuberus A year ago
    I'm interested in the game, but the melee/counter thing gives me pause. The thing I always enjoyed as I got powered up in the other games was just being able to keep on walking while blasting foes away with strengthened weaponry. Having to waste time waiting to whack them with my arm cannon seems less appealing and gets into a weird combat focus I'm not enthused about.

    That said I did recently go through Metroid II and dug it, so I'm sure the weird holdovers from that game - gated progress, Metroid hunting - are perfectly fine on my end.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Gamer-Law #5 Gamer-Law A year ago
    Excellent review, Kat! I am glad to hear that MercurySteam held true to the Metroid 'formula' while at the same time identifying areas in which they could leave their own mark on this game. The use of parrying in combat is probably the best example.

    Too many years have passed since I last played Metroid II on Game Boy, so I look forward to digging into this one on Friday.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Gamer-Law #6 Gamer-Law A year ago
    @orient - So many people are saying this. Makes me wonder if I will be the only one purchasing Radiant Historia on the 3DS next March???
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for hiptanaka #7 hiptanaka A year ago
    Any comment on Jeremy Parish's thoughts that the melee counter messes up the flow of the game? It does sound a bit annoying if it is the primary way you kill enemies, but it sounds like a really good game regardless.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for SIGGYZtar #8 SIGGYZtar A year ago
    Hmm... I hope combat timing isn't as precise as a rhythm game, but is at higher difficulties. Anyway, great review, especially as Jeremy is so contrarian about this. I will pick it up if after I manage to get my hands on a SNES classic.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for nadiaoxford #9 nadiaoxford A year ago
    (Adam is more of a father figure than a boyfriend.)
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for hiptanaka #10 hiptanaka A year ago
    @nadiaoxford Or a little of both? ... Oh no.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Kat.Bailey #11 Kat.Bailey A year ago
    @yuberus Melee attacks become less important as you progress.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for pdubb #12 pdubb A year ago
    So good to hear. I want to get this game. I am glad they made an official remake to Metroid 2.

    I know you can't officially answer it because AM2R "doesn't exist" but I wonder how the two compare against each other.

    Guess I am gonna have to pick this up to find out.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for BulkSlash #13 BulkSlash A year ago
    Two positive reviews (this one and Nintendo Life) and one negative review (Eurogamer), hopefully that means it's the EG review that's the outlier. Plus I'm now a huge fan of the original Metroid II (I've been replaying it all week, I've got my time down to 1h:45m) so a positive review from Kat who liked the original Metroid II is very encouraging!
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for hiptanaka #14 hiptanaka A year ago
    @BulkSlash Pocket Gamer has another lukewarm one

    But then there are like 40 positive ones, if you look at Metacritic.Edited September 2017 by hiptanaka
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for DrCorndog #15 DrCorndog A year ago
    @BulkSlash I was going to say the same thing as@hiptanaka. According to Metacritic, the EG score is VERY much an outlier.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Lonecow #16 Lonecow A year ago
    Wow this is the best review for it so far.

    Of the Classic Retronauts Trifecta of Parish, Kohler, and Bailey Parish is the outlier. You and Kohler both recalled Metroid II being heavily combat focused and the remake plays off of that, where Parish likened it to being made in the Dark Souls era.

    As Parish has always seemed like the bigger Metroid fan, I don't know who to trust! Perhaps Parish is just afraid of having his heart broken in the end.

    Not that it matters I'm buying it no matter what.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Wellman2nd #17 Wellman2nd A year ago
    @Gamer-Law Shoot, I had forgotten about the Atlus games coming out. Those will require physical purchase.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for chaoticBeat #18 chaoticBeat A year ago
    I am so stoked, I can't wait for Friday. It's been a stressful last couple of weeks. I splurged on the Metroid themed 3DS and I'm going to hook a buddy up with my current one so he can enjoy this game too (and 3DS library).
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Fade2Gray #19 Fade2Gray A year ago
    Very cool. I'm working my way through MH Stories now, but this is next on my 3DS queue.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for choog #20 choog A year ago
  • Avatar for Jonnyboy407 #21 Jonnyboy407 A year ago
    Hyyyyyyyype! Friday can't come soon enough!
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Jonnyboy407 #22 Jonnyboy407 A year ago

    You and be both... Man, this whole no power situation got real old real fast
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for KaiserWarrior #23 KaiserWarrior A year ago
    @nadiaoxford I'd liken him more to an abusive husband, but... ugh. Suffice it to say that I am of the opinion that the kindest reading of Other M is that Sakamoto has very little clue what he's doing as a writer and puts very, very little thought into how his plots can be interpreted if you try to read into them at any depth.

    It's nice to hear that Samus Returns is looking like a good adaptation. I have a lot of love for Metroid 2, and it's really nice to see that Mercury Steam has put together an excellent official product to serve as a 'replacement' for the memory-hole'd AM2R. So interesting that it took another 7-year gap to deliver us a great Metroid game, given the other time such a gap in the series resulted in the double-punch of Prime and Fusion (even if I feel that Fusion is one of the weaker entries in the series).
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Vonlenska #24 Vonlenska A year ago
    This looks like it builds on the parts of Other M I enjoyed (it's 2D! it's 3D! it's both!) and scrapes off all the parts I did not (as much as the game gets deserved flack for its writing, the thing that really crossed the line was the pixel hunt in which you have to find a blonde white woman wearing a white lab coat looking out of a white building in a snowfield. During a blizzard. argh).

    Maybe I'm only seeing it that way because I really liked the parts of Other M I enjoyed and wanted to see another game in that style, without all the cruft. I dunno. Looks good, though!
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for mganai #25 mganai A year ago
    If they remake Super Metroid, wouldn't it be hilarious if they called it Metroid III?
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Pojo86 #26 Pojo86 A year ago
    So glad they got Kat to review this one. Who else would have actually referenced fighting a Metroid in a sandpit from the original?
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for dard410 #27 dard410 A year ago
    I'd really love to play a new Metroid game, but the art style just isn't doing it for me. The screenshots looks garish. Does it look any better on the actual 3DS?
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Lonecow #28 Lonecow A year ago
    @dard410 Of course it does. It's a 3DS game. Name a single 3DS game where screenshots on websites looked good. The games always look better on the actual system.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for himuradrew #29 himuradrew A year ago
    How convinient that my 3DS just dies on me:(
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for davidmt #30 davidmt A year ago
    Deleted September 2017 by davidmt
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for davidmt #31 davidmt A year ago
    Excellent review Kat!

    This past weekend, I decided to pick up the Gameboy original and give it a try. I am an "older" gamer that actually purchased the game new back in 1991. Back then, I wasn't familiar with Metroid (not having a NES), but it was one of the big Nintendo "hyped" releases so I figured it had to be good. I hopped around aimlessly and honestly didn't think much of the game. I put it down thinking I would return to it at some point.

    Fast forward to 2017. I now have more experience with the Metroid series but still was not sure about this game. My opinion sure changed as I started playing it. I loved the simple objective, the enemy counter, and the feeling of progression as I knocked out each and every metroid. I didn't like the fact there was no map, which I understand wasn't even thought up until later. I honestly don't feel I could have finished this game without a gamefaqs map on my computer screen. Respect to anyone that did! I often got lost not knowing exactly where I was, and the areas all looked too similar to me.

    I finished the game tonight at 8:31 hours and can't wait to try again when I get the remake tomorrow!

    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for themblan #32 themblan A year ago
    This game is very disappointing.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for tomjonjon #33 tomjonjon A year ago
    @themblan I think this game is amazing. A great follow up and extension of Super, Zero Mission and Fusion.
    Sign in to Reply