Metroid: Samus Returns Review Impressions: Samus is Such a Badass in MercurySteam's Remake

MercurySteam leans heavily into the combat in their remake of Metroid: Samus Returns.

Analysis by Kat Bailey, .

Looking back, it's funny to think how limited Samus was back in the original Metroid II.

Sure, she had access to a variety of beams and missiles, and the Screw Attack made her all but invincible. But c'mon, she couldn't even shoot diagonally. Against Metroids that loved to swoop in from above, that was kind of a problem.

Still, at least it was an improvement over the original Metroid, where you needed an upgrade just to shoot across the screen. Baby steps and all that.

I've been taken aback by how different this game is. But it's different in a good way.

Metroid: Samus Returns, the Metroid II remake due on the Nintendo 3DS in a couple weeks, is light years beyond all that. Not only can Samus shoot diagonally, she can aim anywhere you want on the screen. If you happen to be turned around, she'll even twist back to point her cannon at your target—a move that's essential for solving certain puzzles.

I won't lie, it's taken some getting used to. I went in expecting a remake that hewed a bit a closer to the source material—maybe not a straight update, but at least something close to it. Instead, outside of the basic structure, Metroid: Samus Returns feels like a completely different game. A lot of that is owed to Samus' updated abilities.

Many of the tweaks are subtle but essential. The Ice Beam, for example, can only freeze and not kill (unless you're fighting a Metroid), and the effect lasts barely more than a second. Happily, once an enemy is frozen, you can hit the shoulder button to activate your missile launcher and take them out. Conversely, your regular Charge Beam is easily accessible from the main menu, and it's just as capable of blowing enemies out of the sky.

One effect of these changes is that the combat moves at a much faster clip. Enemies are much more aggressive in Metroid: Samus Returns, and simply pouring shots into them is rarely the most effective way to take them out.

Melee attacks are one of your main weapons in Samus Returns.

Take one of the flying enemies that you encounter relatively early on. In the original game, they would sort of buzz around in the air, presenting an annoying aerial hazard but not much else. In Samus Returns, they are extremely aggressive, zipping in and doing large amounts of damage with their stinger. Simply shooting them isn't sufficient: you have to use Samus' new upward melee attack to time out its charge and stun it. Later you can freeze and kill it with missiles, but you have to be quick, as they can strike before you know it.

In making the creatures of SR388 so aggressive, MercurySteam has correctly realized that the core of Metroid II is its combat. Yes, you fight in other Metroid games as well, but the very essence of Metroid II is hunting down and killing Metroids. And so they've subtly doubled down on the combat, forcing you to engage with each creature in an interesting and tactical fashion.

It definitely pushes that aspect further than other games in the series; and as I said, it takes a bit of getting used to. But there's no denying that feeling that you are Samus: the badass bounty hunter of intergalactic folklore. I'd go as far as to say that it feels a little like she's powered a few moves from her various stints in Super Smash Bros.

And I kind of like it.

The Matter of the Metroids

Then there are the Metroids themselves.

I mentioned that SR388's creatures are far more aggressive, and Metroids are certainly not excluded from this. Even the humble Alpha Metroid—little more than cannon fodder in Metroid II—can give you a pretty good fight if you're not prepared.

The Metroid battles are where you will find your greatest challenge, as well as indications of your growing power. My first encounter with an Alpha Metroid caught me offguard because I was expecting to just pump five missiles into it and move on. I wasn't expecting a full-blown battle.

The Alpha Metroid is actually kind of dangerous now.

Instead it hovered out of my reach, occasionally swooping in for massive damage. It also... uh... poops on you. And let me tell you, Metroid droppings do a lot of damage.

If you've been paying any attention, you'll know that you need to stun it with a swipe of your melee attack, giving you an opportunity to pump a half-dozen missiles into its vulnerable underbelly. If you're the patient sort, you can also just stand and shoot at it from the ground, but that's not recommended in light of the Metroid fecal matter raining from above.

Where it gets kind of awesome is when you obtain the Ice Beam. Anyone who's ever played a Metroid game will know that Metroids simply hate being frozen, and Samus Return's Metroids are no different. If you hit its underside with a charged up shot from Ice Beam, a massive ice crystal forms and it starts drifting around sluggishly. With a little patience, you can then blast it into oblivion.

I came upon all of this fairly organically, and it was a cool moment when I did. It was much more satisfying than the old method of simply finding a Metroid's weak spot and firing missiles until it was dead. I have a lot of love for the original Metroid II, and some of its Metroid encounters can be pretty intense, but I like the depth afforded by the battles in Metroid: Samus Returns.

Samus Returns brings me back to my favorite moment in Metroid Fusion.

Actually—and I consider this high praise—it reminds me of the final battle in Metroid Fusion, where you go toe-to-toe with an Omega Metroid. I always loved that fight, not just because it actually acknowledged that Metroid II's unique forms existed, but because it took what was essentially a static sprite and made it awesome. It was the full realization of everything I had imagined when I first read about how terrifying the Omega Metroid was meant to be.

So if battles with an Alpha Metroid are this interesting, I can only imagine what it must be like to tangle with an Omega Metroid.

I'm still relatively early in my review process, so I'll have some updated thoughts down the line. I'm still a little up and down on the graphical presentation—if you listen to The USG Podcast you'll know that I'm not a fan of the 2.5D look—but right now I'm more up than down. There's no denying that it's very different, but so far it's different in a good way. And it all begins with the combat.

Metroid: Samus Returns will be out September 15 on the Nintendo 3DS.

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Comments 17

  • Avatar for BulkSlash #1 BulkSlash 5 months ago
    I'm not sure about the decision to have such aggressive regular enemies. When I'm trying to explore an area to find where to go next the last thing I want is overly belligerent enemies constantly bothering me, especially if I've left a room and returned and they've all respawned.

    Maybe it won't be that bad, but I'm really hoping I don't end up preferring AM2R as I can't play that on the go like I can a 3DS game...
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Kat.Bailey #2 Kat.Bailey 5 months ago
    @BulkSlash It's annoying at first, but once you get the flow, it's fine.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Wellman2nd #3 Wellman2nd 5 months ago
    But wait, if the Ice beam only freezes for a second or two, does that mean we can't freeze certain enemies to use as platforms?
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Kat.Bailey #4 Kat.Bailey 5 months ago
    @Wellman2nd You can freeze enemies to use them as a platform (and in fact, it's required for certain puzzles). But you need to be quick about it.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for StrwbrryJams #5 StrwbrryJams 5 months ago
    It's good to hear that they are understanding the theme of M2.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for donkeyintheforest #6 donkeyintheforest 5 months ago
    how much does the game rely on the right analog nub stick thing? is it kinda a twin stick shooter like shadow complex or could you enjoy this with a non-new 3ds?
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Kat.Bailey #7 Kat.Bailey 5 months ago
    @donkeyintheforest I don't think I've used the right analog nub at all.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for BulkSlash #8 BulkSlash 5 months ago
    @Kat.Bailey That's good to know! Are some of the weapons auto-fire? All the videos have shown Samus firing off laser blasts at a rate my thumb would struggle to match. Likewise, is there an option to use the accelerometer to aim? The aiming in the videos looked really smooth like it was being done with something other than an analogue stick.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Kat.Bailey #9 Kat.Bailey 5 months ago
    @BulkSlash None of the weapons I've found are auto-fire that I can see. The shots are extremely quick.

    Also, you hold the left shoulder button to aim.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for hiptanaka #10 hiptanaka 5 months ago
    Sounds good.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for steve-mcsteve #11 steve-mcsteve 5 months ago
    How does this compare to MercurySteams other work? I get people (incorrectly) despise it, but Castlevania: Lords of Shadow 1 had amazing artistic design and Gabriel Belmont was such a bad ass.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for donkeyintheforest #12 donkeyintheforest 5 months ago
    @Kat.Bailey oh awesome! I thought they mentioned it in the announcement thing during e3, but i was only half paying attention cause it wasn't even during their presentation. thanks!!!
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Flipsider99 #13 Flipsider99 5 months ago
    @BulkSlash Yeah, I'm worried about this as well. It seems like a bad design decision to make enemies so aggressive, and combat such a central focus in a Metroid game.

    What makes this more worrisome is that this is a pattern with Mercurysteam, who made the exact same mistake with Castlevania. They clearly didn't "get" what Castlevania was supposed to be about and their big mistake was placing all of the emphasis on "action." It sounds like they're making the exact same mistake with Metroid.

    Metroid should NOT be an action game. The emphasis should be on exploration first, action second. I'm not saying it's impossible to make a good Metroid game using the concepts mentioned in this article... but this is Mercurysteam we're talking about. They've never made a good game. I don't trust them to pull this off, quite frankly.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for hiptanaka #14 hiptanaka 5 months ago
    @Flipsider99 As far as I understand, Mercury Steam has never made a great game, but most of them have been good. They have the technical prowess. With Nintendo's financial support and directing role, I'm optimistic they have what it takes. Plus, the whole thing came to fruition because Sakamoto was impressed with the prototype Mercury Steam had made, so it's not like they just outsourced an idea to some random studio.

    I think the fact that the Lords of Shadow games were God of War with Castlevania skin can be attributed to Konami. Mirror of Fate then borrowed more from Lords of Shadow than it did from the Igavania games. I haven't played it, but it seemed to have really dragged out fights and a smaller number of bullet sponge enemies, focusing on combos and that sort of thing. I've also heard it deemphasised exploration. From what we've seen and heard about Samus Returns, it seems a lot better, with quick combat, environmental puzzles and hidden areas to incentivise exploration.

    We won't know for sure until 9/15, but I'm optimistic.Edited 2 times. Last edited September 2017 by hiptanaka
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for moochan #15 moochan 5 months ago
    Glad to hear the game is great. Hearing Mercury Steam was the developer made me worry. "But Nintendo wouldn't allow them to mess it up!" Other M have a few words for you. Been a good while since I sank my teeth in a good Metroid game but I can't wait.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for BulkSlash #16 BulkSlash 5 months ago
    @Kat.Bailey Thanks Kat! It's odd they don't have auto-fire as the original game had it. I suppose with the Charge Beam in this game it would be impossible to have both. I'm replaying the original GB Metroid II right now... :D
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Fallout2 #17 Fallout2 5 months ago
    @moochan Eh, Other M was more combat heavy than I would have liked, but there were a lot of secrets if you went hunting. Its main failing was the characterisation which, unfortunately, came straight from Sakamoto.
    Sign in to Reply