News of Octopath Traveler Mobile Reminds Me Why I'll Never Get Used to Free-to-Play RPGs

Free-to-play mechanics mesh fine with some genres. RPGs aren't one of them.

Ever read a video game headline that spurs a sharp, excited inhalation of breath followed closely by a slow, exhausted exhale? That's what happened to me earlier today when I read "A new Octopath Traveler game is coming—"

[Inhaaaaaale]

"—to smartphones!"

[exhaaaaale]

Yep, it's true. Octopath Traveler, the eight-way RPG that wound up being a surprise hit on the Switch last summer, is getting a new game later this year. It's a prequel that's specially engineered for mobile, so look for swipe controls on top of [double exhale] free-to-play mechanics.

I'm not disappointed this Octopath Traveler prequel, which is subtitled "Champions of the Continent," is coming to mobile instead of the Switch. In fact, I only intend to feel let down if the game isn't brought westward (so far there's no indication the game is leaving Japan). I'm just a little wary. I've shrugged off free-to-play mechanics in a lot of genres brought to mobile—puzzle games, strategy games, MMOs (I'm currently playing the mobile version of Ragnarok Online, an MMO I've loved on-and-off since 2003)—but single-player menu-based RPGs still feel weird as free-to-play games. I can't get over it. I'll try Octopath mobile if it arrives on our shores, but I doubt I'll stick to it. I feel menu-based RPGs are the epitome of games that let you sit back, relax, and think about anything but timing. A looming stamina bar blows that feeling apart, not to mention potential worries over being restricted from the best party builds unless you gamble for powerful warriors through expensive Gatcha games.

I know I'm in the minority on this one, at least as far as the larger world is concerned. Free-to-play menu-based mobile RPGs are huge business in Asia thanks to Granblue Fantasy and Final Fantasy Brave Exvius. Even Nintendo gave us a free-to-play RPG with the recently-released Dragalia Lost, though it didn't make the impression Nintendo and Cygames hoped for. It's possible the enormity of Granblue and Brave Exvius soaked up everyone's time, excitement, and money. If Square Enix insists on going free-to-play with the new Octopath game, it might have an uphill climb. Then again, basing any sort of gashapon game around an established property isn't a bad bet, as the continued success of Fire Emblem Heroes reminds us.

Here's something I'm thankful for, though: When Octopath Traveler director Tomoya Asano tweeted about the mobile prequel news today, he reassured his followers a "proper" sequel is coming. Well, sort of. He said, "Everyone waiting for a new game on console, we're sorry, but production will take a little while longer, so in the meantime, we hope you can enjoy [the smartphone game]!" (Thanks, Gematsu). I choose to take that as an admission Octopath mobile is a low-resource in-between title meant to hold us over until we see what's truly next for Octopath Traveler and / or Bravely Default. It's not as if Square Enix has been shy about hinting something is coming.

Still, I can't stop myself from sending out a useless wish that the Octopath prequel will let us pay a one-time access fee like the olden days of mobile RPGs (remember Final Fantasy Dimensions 2?)—or even let us pay for content chapter-by-chapter (remember the first Final Fantasy Dimensions?). I suppose the latter is possible, and "free-to-play" might mean "free-to-start" in this case. Given how angry the world got at the "free-to-start" business in Super Mario Run, however, I doubt it.

I suppose it is what it is, and I intend to give Octopath Traveler: Champions of the Continent a fair shake if it comes Westward. I just need to clear some space off my dumb phone before I can even think about downloading it. Hm, how about I get rid of Ragnarok Online mobile…?

Nah, I'm good.

Tagged with Android Devices, Free-to-Play, iPads, iPhones, Opinions, Role Playing Games, Rpgs, Square Enix.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Read this next

Octopath Traveler Prequel Announced for Mobile

There will be full endings for all 8 characters.

Bravely Default Twitter Account Excites Fans by Posting Teaser Featuring Octopath Character

Octopath Traveler made a splash on Switch, why not Bravely Default?

Nadia's Top 10 Games of 2018: Diablo Dungeons & Dragons

Let me show you my Pokeymans. And my Dragon Quests, my Octopaths, and my sushi rolls.

The Best Video Game Music of 2018

Put down whatever you're doing. It's time to celebrate game music.

USG Game of the Year 2018: Community Pick

You voted, now here are the results!

The Year in RPGs That Was 2018, Part 1

AXE OF THE BLOOD GOD | Kat and Nadia look back on Octopath Traveler, Pokemon Let's Go, Fallout 76, and more.

More Opinions

The Castlevania Anniversary Collection is Good, but Still Has a Couple of Chipped Fangs

We break down the positives and negatives of Konami's latest effort to cater to the vampire hunter dwelling within you.

Who Needs a New Splinter Cell When You Have This VR Stealth-Action Kayak Game

Phantom: Covert Ops, a new Oculus Quest and Rift S game, elevates a baffling premise to silly fun.

Starting Screen | Why 2019 Has Thus Far Been an Underwhelming Year for Games

After being spoiled for two solid years, we've hit a major lull. Will it get better in the second half?

Madden 20 Franchise Mode is Finally Getting Something It's Needed for Ages: Narrative

A closer look at the Scenario Engine, which could make Madden's franchise mode feel more alive than it has in years.

More on Android

Mario Kart Tour Beta Impressions are Out, and It Looks Like It Has Some Heavy Microtransactions

Details from Mario Kart Tour's closed beta includes how microtransactions work.

Mario Kart Tour Beta Dates, Platforms, Price, Features - Everything we Know

The Mario Kart Tour beta will be launching shortly in May 2019, before the full game releases later on in Summer.

Pokemon Go June 2019 Community Day - Slakoth, Date, Exclusive Move, Bonuses

Here’s what you’ll begetting up to for the Pokemon Go June Community Day.

Report: Riot Games Working With Tencent To Develop Mobile League of Legends

But it's not likely you'll be destroying Nexuses on the go this year.

Fortnite Fortbytes List - All Fortbyte Challenges and Rewards

Fortbytes are brand new to Fortnite Battle Royale for Season 9, and there will be new Fortbyte challenges available to find every day.

GTA Vice City Cheats - Unlimited Money Cheat Code, All Weapons Cheats PC, PS4

We’ve got all the GTA Vice City cheats, from tanks to weapons and beyond. PC Cheats, PS4 Cheats, PS3 Cheats, Xbox, Mobile, iOS, Android.

More Free-to-Play Games

Pokemon Go June 2019 Community Day - Slakoth, Date, Exclusive Move, Bonuses

Here’s what you’ll begetting up to for the Pokemon Go June Community Day.

Horse Haven World Adventures Diamonds - How to Earn More Diamonds

Diamonds allow you to get ahead in Horse Haven World Adventures. Here’s how to get them.

Horse Haven World Adventures Coins - How to Earn More Coins

Coins are the main form of currency in Horse Haven World Adventures. Here’s how to earn more Coins.