Persona 4 vs Persona 5: Which One Should be on our Top 25 RPG List? We Want Your Thoughts!

Persona 4 vs Persona 5: Which One Should be on our Top 25 RPG List? We Want Your Thoughts!

AXE OF THE BLOOD GOD | Nadia and I discuss which Persona game deserves to be in the #9 slot in the Top 25 RPG list, and we want your thoughts, too!

Axe of the Blood God is our weekly RPG podcast hosted by Kat Bailey and Nadia Oxford. You can find the previous episodes here.

We've reach #9 in our Top 25 RPG countdown, but this one is gonna be a little different, mostly because I'm stumped on what it should be [download link here]!

As I explain in the podcast, I've known for quite awhile that the #9 slot would be going to a Persona game. But should it be Persona 4, or Persona 5? I've said before that I prefer to steer clear of games that came out last year, but I still have to give some serious consideration to Persona 5, which on paper at least is much-improved from Persona 4 (at the very least it's much bigger).

Nadia and I use this episode to hash out our feelings on the subject. We talk about how they became so popular in the first place; why Persona 4's story is much more than a Scooby Doo murder mystery, and why their battle systems work. We also return to some of the controversies, including Persona 5's localization and Persona 4's infamous gay panic. (WARNING: MAJOR PERSONA 4 SPOILERS AND SOME PERSONA 5 SPOILERS).

There's a lot to unpack with both of these games, but there's no question that they're both some of the most influential JRPGs of the past decade. But which one should go on the list? We'd love to hear your thoughts! We'll have a final answer when our write-up goes live later this week.

Where to find us (Subscribe, rate, and review!)

Show Description

Persona 4 was a transformative RPG in many respects. Persona 5 might be even better. But which one should be represented in our Top 25 RPG Countdown? Kat and Nadia are still torn, so they've decided to hash it out in podcast form, comparing and contrasting their impacts, their immense positives, controversies, and more. Whichever one you support, it's a tribute to two outstanding RPGs.

Music from Axe of the Blood God is courtesy of Lena Chappelle, who has also contributed the themes to Active Time Babble and Roleplayers' Realm. I also use music from the RPG Music Pack over at rpgmaker.net. Check it out!

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Kat Bailey

Editor in Chief

Kat Bailey is a former freelance writer and contributor to publications including 1UP, IGN, GameSpot, GamesRadar, and EGM. Her fondest memories as a journalist are at GamePro, where she hosted RolePlayer's Realm and had legal access to the term "Protip." She is USgamer's resident mecha enthusiast, Pokemon Master, and Minnesota Vikings nut (skol).

Read this next

Please Just Let Us Date the Persona 5 Guys

A new update to P5 Royal either indicates hope or rubs salt in the wound.

What Makes a Good RPG Romance? Axe of the Blood God Finds Out

With Fire Emblem: Three Houses now out, Axe of the Blood God takes a closer look at what makes good RPG romances.

Who's Your Favorite Video Game Cat?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | Morgana? Cait Sith? Tell us who your favorite video game feline is.

How Does Fire Emblem: Three Houses Stack Up Against Persona, Bully, and Other Games With School Settings?

We don't need no education, but video game characters are another story.

The 25 Best PS4 Games: Now Updated for 2019

Our rotating list of the best PS4 games, now updated again for May 2019!

More Articles

What Game Would Be Better If You Had to Carry a Baby Around With You?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | Death Stranding's out, so let's think about what games would be better if you nurtured a baby.

What's Your Favorite Sports Game?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | Deadspin forever.