Phoenix Point Review: Still Trying to Rise

Phoenix Point Review: Still Trying to Rise

XCom creator Julian Gollop returns to the genre he helped kick off, with uneven results.

Playing any XCOM game is a march of despair. Things can go bad quickly in XCOM, but even getting there is a death march. These are the types of games where you'll miss a shot, have a soldier panic, and then see their corpse on the ground all within a few turns. Even outside of combat, there's always that knowledge in the back of your head that things are getting worse. I can count on one hand the times that I actually played XCOM 2 to completion, despite absolutely loving it.

Phoenix Point is the second title from Snapshot Games, the studio founded by Julian Gollop, designer of X-COM: UFO Defense way back in 1994. Gollop has revisited this concept of turn-based strategy a few times, with three X-COM games, Laser Squad Nemesis, Rebelstar: Tactical Command, and Ghost Recon: Shadow Wars. Gollop has reproduced and reiterated on the same formula multiple times over his career. In Phoenix Point, he sticks to what he knows, and in it, humanity is still fighting the good fight against a large alien force that's slowly encroaching on our territory. The only difference here is the true threat is something called the Pandoravirus, a mutating infection that was found by scientists within Earth's permafrost. It came from the ocean!

Phoenix Point owes much of its core to 1997's X-COM: Apocalypse. The Pandoravirus is represented as a mist that slowly engulfs the world as you play; every move, every raid, every research target costs you valuable time and continues the red mist's expansion. Your mutant enemy grows in strength as mist, mutating in response to your actions or lack thereof.

Like Apocalypse, you're also juggling the wants and needs of various human factions. Here the soldiers of the Phoenix Project are pulled between three major groups. New Jericho prizes human purity above all else, believing that superior force is needed to save the world. The Disciples of Anu is a cult that thinks that the mutations of the virus are the next step, working on creating stable human/mutant hybrids. Finally, the Synedrion are technology-heavy, living in hi-tech sealed collectives without any real leadership. I honestly disliked every faction: New Jericho is led by a purity-focused former billionaire, the Synedrion are hopelessly naive, and Anu is a creepy Cthulhu cult. I guess they're better than the virus?

These factions can't co-exist, as they have diametrically opposed ideas about how to survive. As you play, they'll not only ask you which side you stand on, but will also send you on missions that tend to hurt the other factions. Most of this politicking and skullduggery takes place on the Geoscape, an evolving version of the globe. The board game-style play largely works—you're limited in resources, so you're always trading with various faction havens or completing missions to get yourself the equipment and personnel needed to survive. They'll fight one another without your input, and you can ultimately decide where to intercede.

On the other hand, navigating the factions is what most of the mid-game is comprised of, and it's tedious right up until they realize the world is under an alien threat and stop fighting. The faction choice is largely about what sort of gear you want. The Anu have lighter gear with a focus on speed and perception, the Synedrion have high-tech energy weapons, and so on. You can only gain new soldiers through recruitment at faction havens, and they come with their faction's best gear. And since manufacturing new gear is prohibitive due to scarce resources, it behooves you to choose wisely.

Squint and you might think this was modern XCOM. | Snapshot Games

Combat is where Phoenix Point is at its best, and it shows that Gollop hasn't entirely been reusing the same format. Your squad now relies on Action Points and Will Points to make decisions on the battlefield. Action Points go toward movement and standard attacks, while Will go toward class-specific special abilities. Bigger weapons take more action points, and you can even see the difference in your movement options by swapping weapons on the fly. The overall flexibility offers some tactical choices: if you're using a pistol or melee weapon, you could move, shoot, and then move again, while your heavy gunner has to choose between shooting and moving each turn. I enjoy this much more compared to XCOM 2's binary action system.

Another drastic change is the inclusion of a first-person aiming system. You can just point at your target and have the CPU take a shot, but it benefits you to aim yourself in Phoenix Point. At a base level, it offers a system similar to Fallout's VATS, where you can target specific body parts on your enemies to disable them. If you shoot a grunt's launcher arm, that take explosives off the table for that enemy. Pretty simple.

Free aim has additional benefits though. For one, you can blind fire. Phoenix Point has the fog of war for enemies, where enemy position is clouded unless you have eyes on them. You'll have a rough idea of where they are, even if you don't know the exact spot they occupy on the map. With free aim, you can actually just shoot into the fog of war and hope for the best; I've killed countless enemies within the fog, not even realizing they're dead until I come up on their position.

You can also aim at structures and cover, which are destructible. This means if you know an enemy is around the corner, you can just blow a hole in the wall with a heavy gunner, and then have your assault team take care of the rest. Free aim is simply a fantastic system, one I'd prefer the other strategy games steal wholesale. Julian Gollop is the granddaddy of XCOM, but I'm glad to see he's still got some ideas in the tank.

An early version of the squad. Caty has died like three times. | Mike Williams/USG, Snapshot Games

The drawback of the free aim system and destructible cover is that explosives are wildly overpowered. Grenades, Grenade Launchers, and Missile Launchers are amazingly strong, decently accurate, and even if you miss the splash damage will either kill enemies or leave them without cover. I honestly just let my heavy—who I named after USgamer's own Editor-in-Chief Kat Bailey—lob grenades where I think enemies will be and that generally does the trick. Explosives need a few more limitations in regards to overall balance.

Phoenix Point also has a variety problem. The game relies on a lot of procedural generation to populate maps and new havens. A few hours in, you'll have the general lay of the maps: one city type for each faction, and the alien nests. Missions are largely the same: kill everything, grab resources, or don't die while something tries to kill you. Over the course of the game, you'll run into the same tilesets and objectives many, many times. With the limited resources, similar missions, and occasional difficulty spike, it can feel like you're just grinding at times. I think ultimately that procedural-generation was a good idea, but Snapshot needed to add a few more hand-crafted maps to break things up.

Speaking of variety, the enemies are supposed to mutate over the course of play, depending on which factions they overcome and which tactics work against your squad. Theoretically, this means that enemies get more armor in response to my explosive might, or mutate to toward longer-ranged weaponry. And while I definitely noticed that enemies were changing, it should be far more dramatic. Many of the upgrades feel like they're based more on your position in the campaign, rather than anything that specifically happened during your game. I was fighting crab guys, and now I'm fighting crab guys with more armor; there's little indication of that being a meaningful consequence of my actions.

The new aiming system adds a lot of tactical options. | Snapshot Games

Phoenix Point comes from a smaller developer, rather than the deeper resources Firaxis has to draw upon for XCOM, meaning the technical execution isn't 100%. I wish there has far, far more soldier customization, as part of the fun of these games is sending your friends, family, and coworkers into combat. The armor customization itself is fine, but it would be better with something like more facial options. The hair options simply look terrible, like plastic laid on top of the characters' heads. Voice acting is likewise rough. And Phoenix Point has a general number of bugs: enemy turns that hang, the occasional mystifying tactical choice by the AI, and certain effects like fire not landing where it should.

None of this is a deal-breaker, and it's stuff that Snapshot Games can hopefully clean up for future patches. And it'll have plenty of time to too: in its crowdfunding drive, it's promised five DLC releases in total.

Phoenix Point carries the general DNA of X-COM: Apocalypse forward. It's got some great ideas, but it's a little messy. A little more polish, and some more variety, and I think Phoenix Point can stand at the top of the strategy heap. You can see the seeds of something greater, it's just not there yet.

Phoenix Point fits firmly on the foundation of modern XCOM, but rethinks combat with an action point system and the ability to free aim. While the latter seems like a gimmick, it's actually a wonderful tactical option that pushes the strategy forward. It's a shame then that a reliance on procedural generation leads to a lack of variety, weapon balance isn't great, and the technical execution is rough. Phoenix Point is a great starting point for something amazing, but it's not quite there yet.

3/5

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Mike Williams

Reviews Editor

M.H. Williams is new to the journalism game, but he's been a gamer since the NES first graced American shores. Third-person action-adventure games are his personal poison: Uncharted, Infamous, and Assassin's Creed just to name a few. If you see him around a convention, he's not hard to spot: Black guy, glasses, and a tie.

Read this next

Phoenix Point Reaches Funding Goal With a Month To Go

Julian Gollop's return to the genre he helped build is fully funded.

X-COM Designer Returns To the Genre With Phoenix Point

Julian Gollop is crowdfunding a new strategy game everyone!

Kairi Joins the Battle in Kingdom Hearts 3's Re Mind DLC, Out Next Month

A leaked trailer shows off new playable characters, additional exploration of Scala ad Caelum, and more.

What's Your Favorite PlayStation Memory?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | This week is the 25th anniversary of the PlayStation, so let's look back on our fondest memories of Sony's first consoles.

The Elder Scrolls: Legends is "On Hold" at Bethesda

Bethesda's collectible card game is getting put in storage for the foreseeable future.

25 Years Ago, Breath of Fire 2 Was My First Journey to Kill God, and It Was Good

Even the world's worst translation can't destroy a good yarn about slaying the Lord.

With Reconstruction Complete, Starbreeze is Pinning Its Future on Payday

After a tough year for the publisher, Payday seems like its best bet.

More Reviews

Life Is Strange 2 Series Review: Brothers, A Tale of Two Wolves

Life Is Strange's sequel has wrapped up, so our journey with Sean and Daniel has come to an end.

Pokemon Sword and Shield Review: The Promising Dawn of a New Generation

After all the controversy, it turns out that Pokemon Sword and Shield is actually pretty darn good.

Google Stadia Review: A Muddled Stream of Consciousness

Google's vision of our gaming future is still in the future.

More on Mac

How Guildlings Went From a Satellite-Level Management Sim to Social RPG

"We had no idea we were making a JRPG until we were almost at full JRPG."

Gris Is Coming to PS4 Next Week With Retouched 4K-Ready Artwork

Plus, there'll be a "PlayStation-exclusive secret homage."

Inside Neo Cab, the "Nowpunk" Noir Indie That Is One of 2019's Most Underrated Games

We speak with Chance Agency's Patrick Ewing about the twists and turns of the studio's "Nowpunk" noir.

Shovel Knight's Final Expansions Are Coming Next Month

They'll mark the end of Treasure Trove, but not for our brave blue Knight.

WoW Shadowlands Finally Adds Black and Asian Facial Options for Human Characters

Now Black and Asian players can make characters that look more like themselves.

More Strategy Games

Wargroove Developers Respond to Criticisms of Whitewashed Voice Cast

"We want to be honest about what happened."

Starship Troopers Will Become an RTS Next Year

For those still clamoring for Starship Troopers games.

USgamer Holiday Gift Guide 2019: For the Traveling Gamer

If your special someone is always on the go, here's some ideas to make those delayed departures sting a little less.

Fire Emblem: Three Houses Finally Adds Another Gay Romance Option For Male Byleth

Small spoiler warning: we'll be detailing the new S-Rank character for male Byleth.