Pokémon X & Y Versions Multiplayer Review

While Pokémon’s single-player content remains frozen in 1998, Game Freak has built something far more modern with X/Y’s online components.

I didn’t expect much from the online modes in Pokémon X and Y. Between Nintendo’s historically reserved approach to the Internet and the rather stagnant single-player campaign in Pokémon X & Y Versions, I anticipated little more than the same basic trading and battling options we’ve had since Diamond & Pearl released more than five years ago.

Just imagine my surprise when, upon connecting to the internet with my copy of Pokémon Y for the first time, dozens of friends and total strangers literally greeted me as they populated the bottom screen of my 3DS. Not only were they writing out passive messages à la Twitter or the Miiverse, they were also boosting my stats remotely, offering trades, and challenging me to battles on the spot.

Previous games in the series had online modes that, by comparison, come off as weirdly segregated from the rest of the experience. To initiate a network battle in Pokémon Black or White, for instance, you’d have to travel to a Pokémon Center, talk with the NPCs on the second floor to select either a trade or battle, choose the type of match from singles, doubles, triples, or rotation battles, and, finally, connect to the Internet and enter either ranked or unranked matchmaking. With X & Y, the entire online component is available on the lower screen at all times. It makes a huge difference.

You can use the touch screen to interact with your friends list, people you’ve traded or battled with previously, and even random folks from the other side of the planet.

Voice chat is another unexpected addition that vastly improves the multiplayer experience in Pokémon X and Y. Online trades in particular benefit from this feature, finally allowing real-time negotiations between distant players. Unfortunately, the games restrict chat to people on your 3DS friends list, and the quality isn’t so hot. Worse yet, there doesn’t appear to be any way to disable the in-game audio without simultaneously muting voice communications, so you might find your smack talk drowned out by the blaring soundtrack. And, strangely, while you can activate voice chat with any one friend whenever you like, it pauses gameplay for the duration of the session unless you’re currently engaged in a battle or trade with that player.

Online battles are more flexible this time around. You can customize several aspects of the rule set when challenging friends, including restrictions on the level of Pokémon, whether or not you can equip more than one of the same item per team, as well as limits on certain legendary and event-only Pokémon. On top of the standard ranked and unranked variants of each battle style, matchmaking also includes a new format of ranked matches with unusual rules designed to change every season. For example, when the Special category opens in December, only the 68 Pokémon introduced in X and Y will be able to participate. There’s a lot of potential here, and I love the idea of an evolving competitive playlist that lives outside the conventional metagame.

Previous generations of Pokémon had issues with players powering down their consoles whenever defeat seemed imminent. Not only would this prevent them from accumulating a loss on their own profile, but it also denied the other player the victory they would have earned. I’m pleased to report that this is no longer a problem with X and Y -- now any sudden disconnection counts as a loss for the offending player. Rage quit at your own peril.

Pokémon X and Y make trading faster and easier than ever before.

Trading hasn’t changed too much, though the convenient access to online trades and voice chat should encourage more people to participate. The Global Trade Station, a kind of worldwide database for asynchronously swapping Pokémon, is back once again, but it still lacks any filters for sorting Pokémon by specific abilities, natures, moves, or alternate forms. So long as it’s missing that functionality, the GTS will continue to have limited usefulness for hardcore players.

The new Wonder Trade system adds a fun option for exchanging Pokémon with people the world over. These blind trades match users up at random, instantly switching their pre-chosen Pokémon -- all with no advance knowledge of what they’ll receive in return. In theory, you could offload a useless Caterpie and score a level 73 Charizard in the process. Of course, you’re far more likely to inherit something from the other player’s reject pile, but the unpredictability makes Wonder Trades super addictive.

Spread the word: only jerks spend their O Powers on themselves.

O Powers, the other big online feature added with X and Y, let you grant temporary boosts to yourself or others. You can use them to improve the odds of capturing Pokémon, increase the rate of experience gain, heal injured monsters, raise stats, and even lower the price of goods in stores. These abilities draw from an energy pool that recharges over time, but because they level up with use and require less energy when applied to other players, O Powers naturally foster charitable behavior. They’re a clever way to directly impact someone else’s experience without actually entering their game.

Overall, I’m really impressed with X and Y’s multiplayer implementation. While the franchise’s single-player content remains largely frozen in 1998, Nintendo has built something far more modern with X and Y’s online components.

Pokémon X and Y feature surprisingly progressive multiplayer for a Nintendo game. They more than make up for any lingering interface quirks with inventive and fun new modes.


Tagged with 3DS Handhelds, gamefreak, Nintendo, Pokemon, Pokemon X, Pokemon Y, Reviews, The Pokemon Company.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Read this next

What Final Fantasy 14: Shadowbringers Has to Say About Today's Real World Problems

Final Fantasy's latest expansion draws on our experiences to tell a fantastic story.

Nihon Falcom's President on Why It's Not Supporting Switch More, Lessons Learned From Ys 8, and Hopes for the Next 5 Years

The state of Nihon Falcom, one of the oldest RPG studios in existence, in 2019.

You'll Have To Play Cyberpunk 2077 At Least Three Times To See How Life Paths Pan Out

Where you come from will affect where you go, and how.

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate Breaks Series Record For Evo 2019

A huge turnout for Ultimate's debut year.

Devotion Dev Gives Re-Release Update and the News Isn't Great

A re-release isn't off the table, but probably not happening soon.

Axe of the Blood God: Fire Emblem: Three Houses, Dragon Quest Builders 2, Switch Lite, and More!

Kat and Nadia finally have some new RPGs to play. Here's what they think of Fire Emblem: Three Houses and Dragon Quest Builders 2!

More Reviews

Dragon Quest Builders 2 Review

With these hands we will destroy, and with these hands we will rebuild.

Final Fantasy 14: Shadowbringers Review

Now, this is a story all about how, our life got flipped—turned upside down.

Sea of Solitude Review

I'll send an SOS to the world.

Outer Wilds Review

And tomorrow comes. It’s a world, it’s a way.

More on 3DS

The Wii U And 3DS Both Have The Same Number Of Upcoming Games... One

THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | Nintendo sticks to its traditions of focusing on families and pretending its older hardware is still viable.

Axe of the Blood God Talks About RPGs Born of Non-RPG Game Franchises

Mega Man X be like, "This 'RPG hero' thing can't be too hard, right? ...Oh no."

Animal Crossing New Leaf Cheats and Secrets

Here's our guide to all the Animal Crossing New Leaf cheats and secrets you can uncover in the 3DS game.

Late Nintendo CEO's Iwata Asks Feature to be Compiled Into a New Book

Satoru Iwata's popular feature will be the basis of a new book.