Red Dead Redemption 2's Publishers Are Now in a Legal Fight Against Actual Pinkertons

Red Dead Redemption 2's Publishers Are Now in a Legal Fight Against Actual Pinkertons

The year is 2019 and Take-Two is suing the Pinkertons.

The Pinkertons have issued a cease-and-desist letter to Take-Two Interactive over the fictional Pinkerton agents Andrew Milton and Edgar Ross, who both appear in Red Dead Redemption 2. In return, Take-Two is suing to declare the two characters fair use as part of a historical setting.

The Verge reports that Pinkerton Consulting & Investigations, which still exists today as a subsidiary of Swedish security firm Securitas AB, issued the cease-and-desist notice in December 2018. In its letter, Pinkerton praised the Rockstar Games' "clear affection" for the company, but said it created the false impression that Red Dead Redemption 2 was made with advice from the Pinkerton company.

Take-Two was asked to pay either a lump sum or ongoing royalties for using Pinkerton agents in its game. But Take-Two countered that the usage of Pinkerton agents is protected by the First Amendment.

Take-Two notes that fictional usage of the Pinkerton Agency has been used in many different works of fiction, including other video games like 2010's BioShock Infinite. Take-Two is accusing Pinkerton of trying to profit off of Red Dead Redemption 2's astounding success. Take-Two went ahead and said that "[h]istorical fiction—television, movies, plays, books, and games—would suffer greatly if trademark claims like [Pinkerton's] could even possibly succeed... [Pinkerton] cannot use trademark law to own the past."

Take-Two even cited the critical acclaim garnered by Red Dead Redemption 2, including a review published for the Audubon Society praising its accurate portrayal of bird wildlife.

In Red Dead Redemption 2, players are part of the outlaw Dutch van der Linde's gang as they try and evade the Pinkertons who are quickly closing in on their trail. The Pinkerton Detective Agency was a real-life private securities agency historically associated with their anti-union activities, which included working for private companies to break up strikes. The agency was acquired by Securitas AB in 2003.

For more on how to evade the Pinkertons check out our Red Dead Redemption 2 guide for tips and walkthroughs.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Matt Kim

News Editor

Matt Kim is a former freelance writer who's covered video games and digital media. He likes video games as spectacle and is easily distracted by bright lights or clever bits of dialogue. He also once wrote about personal finance, but that's neither here nor there.

Read this next

Red Dead Redemption 2 PC Specs: Recommended and Minimum Settings

Thanks to a listing on the Rockstar Games Launcher, we have an idea as to the PC Specs for Red Dead Redemption 2. Here are the Minimum and Recommended settings.

Starting Screen | A Great Port Is Always Worth the Wait

Whatever time it takes to make a game feel just right on a new system is well-spent.

Red Dead Redemption 2 is Finally Coming to PC (And Stadia) Next Month

The long wait is over for PC rustlers and wranglers.

Take-Two CEO Says Next-Gen Won't Send Game Development Costs Soaring

Strauss Zelnick seems optimistic about dev costs for Scarlett and PS5.

Zombies May Be Appearing in Red Dead Online, If It's Not a Glitch

Undead nightmare part two, or just another quirky bug?

More News

Blizzard Bans Collegiate Hearthstone Players for Six Months Over Protest Sign

American University's players have received some late judgment.

PUBG's Next Season Will Have Players Flinging Blades and Pans in a Refreshed Miramar

Season 5 will focus on improving PUBG's second map and adds a number of new features, including the ability to toss items and melee weapons.

The Analogue Pocket is Bringing Retro Handheld Gaming Back to Life

Analogue's new device looks like a Game Boy Pocket but supports a lot more than Game Boy classics.

More on PlayStation 4

PUBG's Next Season Will Have Players Flinging Blades and Pans in a Refreshed Miramar

Season 5 will focus on improving PUBG's second map and adds a number of new features, including the ability to toss items and melee weapons.

Bloodlines 2 Delayed to Avoid the Issues That Plagued the Original

Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines 2 is still targeted for 2020, but it'll come out later than Hardsuit Labs had initially hoped.

Fortnite XP Guide - How to Earn XP and Increase Your Level

This is our guide to the new Fortnite XP system, and how you can earn XP to increase your overall level.

Fortnite Medals List - How to Earn New Medals and Refresh the Punchcard

This is our full guide to the new Fortnite Medals system, including how to earn them, and times for the Punchcard refresh.

Fortnite 2 Map - All Named Locations and Landmarks on the New Fortnite Map

This is your overview to the Fortnite 2 map, including all the new landmarks and named locations on the Chapter 2 map.

Why The Division 2 Is Still Hard to Jump Back Into

With the new Title Update and Episode, The Division 2 should be easier to get into, but it's not.

G2A Representative: "Do You Really Think You Could Illegally Obtain 100,000 Keys?"

Speaking with GamesIndustry.biz, G2A's head of communication Maciej Kuc fires back at critics of the key selling marketplace.