Review: Console Wars: Sega, Nintendo, and the Battle that Defined a Generation

If you're interested in the early-'90s battle of Sega v. Nintendo, Blake Harris' tome is exhaustive, required reading.

Article by Bob Mackey, .

In its first few pages, Blake Harris' Console Wars gets off on the wrong—though not completely unexpected—foot: a rambling, unfunny dialogue between Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg, two guys who normally don't rub me the wrong way.

Even though this foreword is fleeting, their dull barbs about the sexual tension between Sonic and Tails had me assuming Console Wars would be another easy, breezy tour of video game history, replete with the standard anecdotes we've all heard a million times by now. "Mario is named after Nintendo of America's first landlord, you say?" It's the kind of disposable, mass-market book on video games you see the most, usually branded with titles like Blip! Bleep! Bloop! How Video Games Rescued the Princess and Took Over the World.

Thankfully, Console Wars avoids this trap, and sticking two Hollywood types in its opening (as well as on the cover) might be a bit of overcompensation on Harris' part. While the history depicted within its nearly 600 pages stretches over five very busy years of video game history, Console Wars excels in its sheer specificity. Much of this information has been collected before, but never so exhaustively, and rarely packaged within a single narrative. David Sheff's long out-of-print Game Over used to be the gold standard for reading up on this particular period of video game history, but Console Wars goes beyond a simple account of Nintendo's 8 and 16-bit dominance by placing the reader squarely in the shoes of its underdog competitor.

By the end of Console Wars you'll know more about the inner workings of Sega than you ever thought possible, though Harris doesn't simply recount basic facts. The majority of his book is written as a dramatization, which functions primarily to build a history by placing important information in the mouths of actual people. So an event as simple as "Tom Kalinske visits Sega for the first time" gives Harris a chance to create a scene which helps characterize his subjects and allows for related information to be dropped in along the way. For the most part, this approach works, though when Harris digs a little too deep into his characters' psyches, his attempts at pathos ring a little shmaltzier than intended.

This device was a smart move on Harris' part, as Console Wars has a lot to say about every excruciating detail of Sega's battle against Nintendo, as well as Sony's dalliances with just about everyone. The logistics behind every price drop, press event, and television commercial are expressed in exhaustive detail, and at the heart of every scene beats a Sorkin-style sense of urgency. Harris' fastidiousness can be a little frustrating at times, though, and while what he presents is rarely irrelevant, a few sections could have been trimmed here and there for the sake of brevity. Console Wars devotes several pages to the VHS/Betamax war, for instance, yet also-rans like the TurboGrafx 16 and the Atari Jaguar only get a middling paragraph each.

Still, these moments of self-indulgence are few in number, and Console Wars does an excellent job of exposing how a dose of healthy competition transformed video games into the massive industry we know it as today. And, unsettlingly enough, Harris' book also shows how much of our gaming tastes have inevitably been formed through the efforts of cold, calculating businesspeople. This isn't a criticism of Harris' writing, but Console Wars is essentially a history of executives and business decisions, and given the hush-hush world of Japanese game development, more interesting stories lurk in the background that will probably never be told—the breakneck development cycle of Sonic 2, for instance, feels like it could merit an entire book by itself. But if you lived through this heady era, Console Wars is a great read as well as a way to relive every unexpected moment of Sega's struggle against Nintendo from the perspective of people much, much more important than you.

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Comments 7

Comments on this article are now closed. Thanks for taking part!

  • Avatar for DogNozzle #1 DogNozzle 4 years ago
    7 out of the first 8 items listed in the "Customers also bought" section for this book on amazon are titled in the format XXX: YYYYYYY. Heh.

    Anyway, going to have to read this just to see why it's 600 pages.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for neilhood #2 neilhood 4 years ago
    And ... ordered the book. Thanks Bob.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for kidgorilla #3 kidgorilla 4 years ago
    I've read through the first few chapters, but I'm really loving it so far
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Exhuminator #4 Exhuminator 4 years ago
    "from the perspective of people much, much more important than you"

    Wow what an egotistical and shitty way to end an article. I'd argue the customers were actually the MOST important people involved in the situation back then, actually.Edited May 2014 by Exhuminator
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Stealth20k #5 Stealth20k 4 years ago
    Honestly, I have no interest in reliving those days
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Mega_Matt #6 Mega_Matt 4 years ago
    Can't wait to read this.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for DogNozzle #7 DogNozzle 4 years ago
    @Exhuminator It's pretty clear from context that that line is describing (in a tongue-in-cheek way) the relationship between the book's subjects and its likely audience. It's not some weird unprovoked attack on the reader... yeesh.
    Sign in to Reply