Starting Screen: Fire Emblem Heroes and the Stages of Regret

The inevitable regret that comes with spending on a free-to-play game, plus the rest of this week's game releases and news.

Column by Kat Bailey, .

Starting Screen is our weekly column featuring news, commentary, and music to help you get over your case of the Mondays.

It usually begins with a deep sense of frustration and impatience.

I almost never go into a free-to-play game with the intention of spending money, least of all a free-to-play mobile game. But if I spend enough time with it, I usually hit a roadblock. And that's when they get me.

It happened to me over the weekend with Fire Emblem Heroes. I had an okay team fronted by Marth, but two of the slots felt like liabilities. I swapped around characters, growing increasingly frustrated with my limited pool of options and the pace at which I earned orbs-the currency necessary for earning new characters. I was still completing the story stages at a reasonable pace, but I felt like I had hit a bottleneck.

Finally, I took a deep breath and purchased 23 orbs for $12.99. And I immediately felt like a hypocrite.

You may recall me railing against Nintendo's embrace of microtransactions in an editorial last week. For the record, I still feel that way. After the article went up, I had a long conversation on Twitter about the ways in which microtransactions tend to compromise game mechanics, particularly slot machine games like Fire Emblem Heroes. But despite all of that, Fire Emblem Heroes still managed to get its hooks in me over the weekend, leading to the scenario above. Happens to the best of us.

Obviously, this isn't the first time I've spent money on a free-to-play game. At times, I've even spent far more money than intended. The cycle tends to go like this:

    1. I hit a roadblock: My team is taking too long to improve. There's a keystone card that I need for my lineup. A special variant of my favorite player is available in Ultimate Team.

    2. I finally break and spend money: I buy a pack. Or maybe a bundle.

    3. I hit the slot machine: I start ripping packs, or I start drawing from the slot machine, convinced that I'm about to get a major boost. Usually I get a lot of crap and maybe one or two cards worth using. If I'm extraordinarily lucky, I get something really rare. Most of the time, though, all I get is a lot of regret.

    4. Regret: I feel a deep sense of irritation and regret at spending a bunch of money on digital characters, even if I get lucky and manage to draw something really great. I look at my shiny new character and think, "I spent $15 on this?

    5. Repeat.

I actually might be the exception on this front. Many people are happy to not only spend money on free-to-play games, but spend lots of it. An entire culture has grown up around simply sitting on Youtube and ripping packs for new cards in Ultimate Team, or plugging the slot machine in Fire Emblem. From time to time I ask developers what they think of this culture. Their response is usually to shrug and say, "They've having fun!" Then they go back to counting their money.

The Bizarre Gaming Culture of Madden Ultimate Team

Why the Madden Ultimate Team community is the strangest gaming culture Kat has ever experienced.

Compared to a lot of the games I've played (I've spent an unholy amount of money on Hearthstone), Fire Emblem Heroes is admittedly a lesser offender. My quick infusion of cash gave me the characters I needed to round out my team, and I've since been plugging through the story missions on Hard to level up my new characters and unlock more orbs. I'm still at it because there's just enough there in terms of depth to feel like I'm not completely wasting my time, and because I suppose I like Fire Emblem and desperately wish I had Takumi or Lyndis god damnit.


But despite being relatively benign, Fire Emblem has left me the same vague sense of regret over spending money that I feel when playing other free-to-play games. It's interesting the psychology involved, because in a way I haven't spent anymore money than I might have if FE Heroes were a premium game with an upfront cost. I suppose the difference is that free-to-play games are generally money pits by design, and that by spending cash I'm just feeding the beast.

This isn't the first time I've spent money on a free-to-play game, though, and it's unlikely to be the last. Free-to-play is already pretty much impossible to avoid, and that will increasingly mean taking the good with the bad in games like Hearthstone, Fire Emblem Heroes, and FIFA. In other words, the cycle continues.

This Week's Best Game(s)

Nioh: After years in the proverbial wilderness, the outfit best-known for Ninja Gaiden returns to its hardcore roots with Nioh-a Soulsborne dungeon crawler that swaps knights for samurai. I wound up handing Nioh off to Soulsborne expert John Learned, who managed to knock it out in less than a week and offer up a detailed review. I am both impressed and terrified. Nioh will be out February 7th.

Game Music to Get You Through Monday

It's bleak and rainy here in San Francisco, so music from Super Castlevania 4 feels appropriate this week. Super Castlevania 4 was one of the Super Nintendo's earliest games, which makes its use of the SNES sound chip particularly impressive. Along with Final Fantasy IV and The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past, it's a great early example of the amazing tunes the SNES would push out throughout its life. As usual, Nadia has a more in-depth look here.

Quick Thoughts

  • Another Fire Emblem Heroes though: Someone mentioned to me on Twitter that it needs much more robust Arena Dueling support. I wholeheartedly agree. At present, you only fight CPU-controlled parties, making it easy to abuse the fairly limited AI. It's a shame that it doesn't support PvP, as that would give the game's community and its overall longevity a nice little boost. Then again, it would mostly just be pay-to-win as everyone dumped money into getting five-star characters. Sigh. See what I mean when I say that microtransactions ruin everything?

  • For those who are tired of hearing about free-to-play, Jaz has this list of the best walking simulators in his weekly Digital Gems column. Walking simulators tend to be controversial in the way they emphasize story over anything resembling traditional gameplay; but when done well, they feel like the ultimate realization of what we were trying to accomplish with FMV games way back in the mid '90s. Personally, I tend to prefer interesting systems to interesting narrative, so I tend to avoid walking simulators, but there are some interesting games on this list. What do you think?

  • In case you missed it, Mike took a look at indie development on the Switch, which I've maintained will be a good indicator of the system's ultimate success. From the looks of it, the Switch may have an image problem. The familiar faces like Yacht Club are in place, but more than one indie developer has told me that they don't think that the Switch is a good fit for their game. This may be the kind of issue that only strong initial sales can fix.

  • Polygon got a bunch of crap from "hardcore gamers" for not being able to finish Nioh in time for the review embargo last week. My response? Give them a break. Hitting a review embargo is an insanely stressful thing at the best of times, and Nioh is harder than your average Soulsborne game. I ended up freelancing it out in part because there was no way in hell I was going to be able to finish it up myself, and I've spent my fair share of time with the Souls games. There's worse shame than struggling to finish a game that's deliberately designed to kick your ass in the space of six days.

  • Hearthstone's next expansion really can't come fast enough. I'm about done with Pirate Warriors and Aggro Shamans.

  • Over in the Guardian, Eurogamer alum Simon Parkin reflects on the shame and self-doubt that comes with being a videogame critics in times like these. It's actually more positive about games criticism than it seems at the outset.
  • Kotaku has this story of GameStop employees dealing with the "Circle of Life" program, which establishes even stricter individual quotas for pre-orders, rewards cards, trade-ins, and used games. Anyone who's followed GameStop over the years will know that this is nothing new; but as digital delivery becomes more and more important, it seems that GameStop is doubling down. The lesson, as always, is to avoid GameStop when you can.

  • Axe of the Blood God: In this week's episode of the RPG podcast, Nadia and I wondered what the heck is going on with Final Fantasy VII Remake. It's a fair question. When all Square has to offer is a new piece of key art, you have to wonder when exactly we'll see the first episode of the much-anticipated remake. Right now it's look like next year might be the earliest we get it.

  • Off-topic: I was in a car driving home from Tahoe on Sunday, so I missed a large chunk of the Super Bowl. But I did manage to catch the part that mattered: the final drive in New England's mindblowing comeback over Atlanta. Suffice it to say, it's one of the all-time great sports moments I've ever seen, and I can't believe that this stuff keeps happening to Boston fans. If we're all lucky, Tom Brady and Bill Belichick will see this as their moment to hang it up and go out on top. But if the past couple years are any indication, Brady will probably keep playing until he's 50.

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Comments 9

  • Avatar for Roto13 #1 Roto13 A year ago
    I don't think I could bring myself to spend money on something as random (and stacked against you) as Fire Emblem Heroes summoning. It'd be one thing if I was guaranteed some kind of positive return. If I could grind down heroes and use them to power up my existing ones a noticeable amount, or if I was guaranteed that every set of 5 characters would have at least one rare one. After earning and spending 80 orbs on 20 characters and getting one or two that are particularly good, by desire to put money into it is less than 0. (And, in fact, I uninstalled the game last night.)

    Meanwhile, I'm totally find buying plays in Nintendo Badge Arcade and have sunk a ton of money into it because I rarely fail to get exactly what I'm after with a set of 5 plays.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Compeau #2 Compeau A year ago
    I just beat the main story of Fire Emblem Heroes today. I haven't spent any money on the game, and probably never will. The gacha mechanic isn't attractive enough to me: I could spend $40 on orbs and still not get the characters I want. Plus, the game gives players plenty of orbs through the course of normal gameplay to obtain a bunch of quality warriors, and I never hit a roadblock in progression.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for DrCorndog #3 DrCorndog A year ago
    As far as I can remember, I've only ever spent money on two F2P games:

    Pokemon Go. And let's face it, this game was so novel and so big that just being a part of it was exciting (even if the game itself was pretty...bare-bones.

    Team Fortress 2. I spent money here because the game itself was so fun that I WANTED to buy something, not because I was forced to. If more F2P games were like this, I'd love the model.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for MetManMas #4 MetManMas A year ago
    Maybe it's just 'cuz I'm averse to AAA multiplayer-centric titles and I own a garbage phone and thus haven't really gotten into mobile gaming, but I haven't been able to justify spending cash on F2P titles. I might occasionally pick up some frivolous DLC for a game like costumes, but that's generally a "I have some Console Fun Bux left over after buying a game and I don't see another game I'm interested in at my price range" thing for me.Edited February 2017 by MetManMas
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for SatelliteOfLove #5 SatelliteOfLove A year ago
    "You will spend money on this game like the big fucking schmuck you are."

    Back of the box quotes done right, (if the game had one).
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for mathieust-onge17 #6 mathieust-onge17 A year ago
    @Roto13 there is a possitive return, you are guaranteed a 3 star hero (1 star being the lowest) and the game offers you plenty of free orbs ( so far i had enough free orbs to do 4 draw of 5 hero, thats a total of 20 free hero) also the game tells you how much % chance you have to draw a hero of X stars.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for mathieust-onge17 #7 mathieust-onge17 A year ago
    You say the pace at which
    you gain orbs is very slow but the game just throught
    the whole story line and all difficulty gives 135 orbs!
    thats 7 times 5 draw! and all for free.

    also saying that slot machine games like fire emblem heroes
    compromise the game mechanic is very untrue, in the end it
    depend on the company, some game you will absolutely need
    rarer units/cards etc.. to go further in the game and yes that
    is bad design. On the other hand some game like fire emblem
    does it very well, permitting all heroes to get to 5 stars.
    so even if you get that "shitty" 3 star hero, with time, it
    can become a very good unit.

    these games are designed to make you want to
    spend money on them
    but at the end of the day you are an adult and you
    make the choice to put the money in.

    and last thing i wanna add is, not everyone has the
    money or is willing to spend on a premium game with an
    upfront cost.
    and that is why F2P games are so popular even if alot of
    people deny it.
    You get to spend when you want on what you want and you
    don't have to take a risk by buying the game first before
    knowing if your gonna like it or not.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for VotesForCows #8 VotesForCows A year ago
    On the Gamestop issue - I used to work in Game (one of their competitors in Ireland) around 2004/5. We never had any pressure like that. There were plenty of used games in the store, but generally we all just tried to be as helpful as possible with customers - even advising them not to buy some things if we felt they were inappropriate (buying GTA for their kids, for example).

    I guess the retail business has changed a lot, which is a shame cos it was a really nice place to work back then.Edited February 2017 by VotesForCows
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Roto13 #9 Roto13 A year ago
    @mathieust-onge17 What happens when you run out of story missions? And 3* characters are crap.
    Sign in to Reply