Super Mario Maker 2 Review

Super Mario Maker 2 Review

Now you can make horrible, mind-rending Mario courses on the Switch.

Sometimes it feels like the entire Super Mario Maker series is a hellish experiment. It's as if the designers at Nintendo are saying to critics, "Yeah, well you do better!" Occasionally, someone actually does take the design concepts and themes of a proper Mario level and do them justice. Others makes grueling obstacle courses, known within the community as "Kaizo Levels," in honor of the Kaizo Mario World ROM hack. More often though, players attempt to make Kaizo Levels without understanding how they work, turning out frustrating, painful levels that serve only to anger and dismay.

The third user-created level I tried on Super Mario Maker 2 took me 25 minutes to clear. It was a harrowing level on the night version of the forest theme, meaning the waters below were poison, constituting instant death. It's a level so full of "gotcha" moments that I had to get up and go get a drink. Ultimately, I did clear the level—one of three percent of contestants who has as of this writing. I'm still not sure if it's a good level on not.

This is the only way I can make you understand how weird the Story Mode is. | Mike Williams/USG, Nintendo

Constructing a Story

When the Nintendo Switch was released, a port of Super Mario Maker was on the top of my wish list. Super Mario Maker 2 is the answer to that wish. Take the new Story Mode, for instance. This is technically the 100 Mario Challenge from Super Mario Maker, a slew of Nintendo-created levels for players to enjoy. In Mario Maker 2, this is framed as Mario helping a work crew of Toads to rebuild Princess Peach's castle. Each bit of the castle costs coins to rebuild, and each level is a job, offering a certain amount of Coins depending on its difficulty.

It's wonderfully charming though, as Mario has conversations with all of the characters that live near the castle. The Toads themselves are fine, but the standouts are the weird Mario Maker crew, like Mr. Eraser, Undodog, and Partrick. Listening to Mr. Eraser talking about cleaning my sins before he rubs off his eraser head in mid-air is... a surreal experience. Thank you for that, Nintendo. It may just be narrative framing, but at least it's fun.

Story Mode also serves as an illustration of the things you can do with all of Super Mario Maker 2's various parts. Each course is laser-focused on a specific idea or part, telling the player, "This is one way you could use this item in your own courses." One stage tasks you with using the swing claw to never touch the floor, while another uses Bowser's Clown Car and platform paths to create a rough side-scrolling shooter. Combined with Yamamura's Dojo, an extensive set of classes on course design and philosophy taught by a pigeon, Mario Maker 2's single-player content allows the player to undergo a rough internship of sorts.

A Course World of Pain

You can see the credits roll on Story Mode without finishing every course. I personally finished every damn level, though some of those four-star difficulty levels tested me. If you're still not ready to tackle building, you have some other options. There's Course World, for example, which is where all of the user-created courses live. Nintendo has also expanded upon previous options, with pages for New, Popular, and Hot courses. You still can't search by course name, but there are filters for game style, theme, difficulty, region, and tags. Speaking of tags, courses can now have two tags, and the list of tags is more condensed this time around.

Overall, it's much easier to find a course you might enjoy, or a course-maker whose work you'd like to follow. That's not just via Search either, as the leaderboards can show you some of the best course-makers, which courses they enjoyed, or which courses the top players are tackling.

Nintendo realizes that the Switch is a travel companion for some folks, given the addition of Coursebot. Coursebot is a place to store the courses you've created (up to 32 in total), or download any user-created courses to play offline. I treat it like podcasts on my phone; it's a nice feature to have if you know you're going on a trip and are going to be offline for a bit.

Course World adds the new Endless Challenge this time around, a twist on the 100 Mario Challenge. This mode gives you five lives and pits you against a random assortment of user-levels based on your chosen difficulty. I quibble with what Mario Maker considers "Normal" or "Hard" at times, because Endless will have some definite spikes in challenge. You can skip levels freely in Endless Challenge, as score is the final goal, not overall completion of every level.

Super Mario Maker 2 has a heavy focus on multiplayer options. Up to four players—controlling Mario, Luigi, Toad, or Toadette—can tackle a course together, or in a versus mode. (You can choose any character in Course World. Story Mode is always Mario.) The latter seems inspired by the Mario races at the Games Done Quick speedrun events, with all four players moving at breakneck speed to survive and get to the finish line first. Given the recent Mario Battle Royale fan game, this is a fun little addition, though I only engaged with it a few times. There's even a Leaderboard page for the best Versus players, so this might become a big part of the Mario Maker community in the future.

Winners only. | Nintendo

Even without Versus mode, multiplayer is a blast. It's a shame then that Super Mario Maker 2 is a bit weird in terms of when and where you can engage in multiplayer. Locally, you can't enjoy multiplayer in Story Mode or from the Course World. Instead, you have to download courses to Coursebot, and then access local multiplayer there. You can also work together with another player to make a course. There is an option to engage with local multiplayer in Course World, but it requires that every player has their own Switch and copy of the game.

Worse, online multiplayer is with randoms only; there's no way at launch to join up with friends and do co-op or versus play yet. Nintendo has confirmed that the option is coming in a future update, but it's odd that it's missing here. With the push toward playing together, Mario Maker 2 should have fewer barriers.

I should also note that the matchmaking in multiplayer can occasionally lead you to levels where multiple players can't actually progress. Any level that's based on a single item for traversal, whether that's a Clown Car, Koopa Troopa Car, or Dry Bones Shell? Those actually break multiplayer a bit, because they boil down to one player getting through everything alone, while the other players just die.

Nintendo has tried to fit everything in the single screen, to mixed results. | Mike Williams/USG, Nintendo

Course Maker, Course Breaker

That leaves the Course Maker, which is technically the primary focus of Super Mario Maker 2. You're forced to choose either playing on TV with a controller, or on the touchscreen in portable mode. In terms of the controller user interface, Nintendo has made some improvements. Y brings up a radial menu of items that you can flip through with the shoulder buttons, the directional pad lets you easily access options on either side of the creation window, and erase and undo options are right at your fingertips.

It's still nowhere near using the touchscreen though. The Switch allows players to get close to the original Wii U version by allowing you to use the portable touchscreen and your finger. And... it's fine. Doing level creation works fine with your finger. Japan has the option of purchasing a stylus, but I honestly don't think I'd pick up one up. There's nowhere to put it, so I'd likely just lose it eventually. So, if you're dead set on the stylus, import or pick one up, but I'd honestly not bother. I do wish there was a way to connect the portable console to the TV without losing access to the touchscreen though, as that would be the best of both worlds. It makes me miss the mirrored presentation of the Wii U.

Super Mario Maker 2's Course Maker is a bit less... game-y compared to the first title. This one is far more rigid, aimed more at providing players with a robust set of tools to create levels, rather than letting them explore some item combinations. The closest Mario Maker 2 gets to that kind of experimentation is the method for unlocking the night levels.

If you've messed with the Course Maker in Super Mario Maker for Wii U or 3DS, you should feel right at home here. There are a few new options in terms of course styles, themes, and items you can place within your courses. There are five game styles available when you boot up Super Mario Maker 2: Super Mario Bros, Super Mario Bros 3, Super Mario World, New Super Mario Bros U, and Super Mario 3D World. There are also ten course themes—Ground, Sky, Underground, Forest, Underwater, Ghost House, Desert, Airship, Snow, and Castle—compared to the six in previous games. Each theme also has a night version is every style except Super Mario 3D World.

The new radial menu is helpful, but occasionally, you'd just like a straight list. | Mike Williams/USG, Nintendo

The Super Mario 3D World style is odd, because the original game was a 3D title, like Galaxy or Odyssey. What this style does is graft some of the 3D World mechanics onto a 2D Mario. In some ways it actually feels faster and more enjoyable than the New Super Mario Bros style. Unfortunately, it's also missing some features, including night mode andnote blocks.

I honestly could list the new additions all day, because while it looks largely the same at a glance, there's a ton Nintendo has crammed in the new Course Maker. And that's before you get to all the ways that different items can interact. Put a parachute on a Thwomp for some weird fun, or make Mario a lava-gliding Thwomp killer with the combination of the Dry Bones Shell and Spiny Helmet. Part of the fun of exploring Course Maker is finding all the odd systemic intersections of Super Mario Maker 2.

But there are also issues from the previous Course Maker that made their way over to this version. The biggest problem remains moving a whole lot of things at once. If you're deep in the design phase and need to move everything in a level to make space for one last section, you can't. I'm actually unsure that it's something that Nintendo can fix, given the constraints of a console, but it's still annoying for level design purposes.


Death ain't nothing but a heartbeat away. | Mike Williams/USG, Nintendo

Super Mario Maker 2 is a sequel, when all Nintendo really needed to do was port the original over. I'm glad it spent the time and effort though. It's provided ways to help players build better levels, something I hope that some course-creators take to heart. Even if you don't make your own courses, Super Mario Maker 2 provides a robust single-player experience and a gateway into an entire world of user-created levels. It's a shame that the constraints of the platform mean that Super Mario Maker 2's Course Maker isn't quite to the level of the superior Wii U format, but I'm not sure I can completely hold that against the game. New items, new themes, new styles, and multiplayer means that Mario Maker 2 is two steps forward against the one step back; at the very least that means Nintendo is moving the series in the correct direction.

Players now have the chance to make their own hellish, evil Mario levels on Nintendo Switch. Super Mario Maker 2 starts with the foundation established in the first game, and adds new themes, new game styles, and new items. It falters due to the loss of the second screen of the Wii U and 3DS iterations, and the lack of Amiibo costumes hurt, but this is still a fantastic package for a Mario fan or budding level designer.

4.5/5

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Mike Williams

Reviews Editor

M.H. Williams is new to the journalism game, but he's been a gamer since the NES first graced American shores. Third-person action-adventure games are his personal poison: Uncharted, Infamous, and Assassin's Creed just to name a few. If you see him around a convention, he's not hard to spot: Black guy, glasses, and a tie.

Read this next

Check Out This Super Mario Maker 2 Course From the Yooka-Laylee Developers

Playtonic is just the first indie dev Nintendo will shout out via Mario Maker 2.

Latest Super Mario Maker 2 Patch Finally Lets You Play Online With Friends

On top of this multiplayer and quality of life-focused update, Nintendo says new course parts are on the way.

The 25 Best Nintendo Switch Games

Our rotating list of the best games on Switch, now updated for the Nintendo Switch Lite release!

Where Nintendo Switch Online Has Gone Wrong

The reasons Nintendo's online service is flaccid, and what it can do to pump things up.

Nintendo Says There is No Switch Exchange Program

Nintendo of America denies last week's reports of Switch exchanges.

Man vs. Mario Maker 2: Hardcore Jumps, Airship Explosions, and Spiny Rescues

We're back with another round-up of some of the most interesting courses in Super Mario Maker 2!

More Reviews

Concrete Genie Review: A Wonderful World of Color Comes With Caveats

Pixelopus' tale of childhood is certainly easy on the eyes.

Destiny 2: Shadowkeep Review: Moon's Haunted and So Is My Playtime

The lack of new loot and a so-so campaign weighs down an otherwise solid expansion for Destiny 2.

John Wick Hex Review: Excommunicado

An amazing action series yields a one-dimensional tactics game.

Ghost Recon Breakpoint Review: Lost in the Wilderness

The Ghosts face off against the Wolves in new type of Ghost Recon.

More on Switch

Wargroove Is Getting a Free Heist-Themed Co-Op DLC Called Double Trouble

Chucklefish will also introduce some new tools for custom maps and game-wide balance changes.

Little Town Hero Will Last 10 to 20 Hours, According to its Director

Director Masao Taya doesn't play as many turn-based RPGs as he used to, and that informs Little Town Hero's compact campaign.

Pokemon Sword and Shield's File Size is Pleasantly Rotund, Like a Wooloo

You cannot nap on the belly of Sword and Shield's game cartridge, however.

Fortnite Probably Isn't Dead, But Players Can't Help But Wonder What's Next

After a massive explosion, Fortnite users are left with only an eerie void and theories.

Mailbag of the Blood God: What to Play if You're New to RPGs

The Axe of the Blood God mailbag returns with conversation about what to play if you're new to RPGs, Final Fantasy 13, and more.

A New Fortnite Battle Royale Map May Have Been Leaked on the App Store

Fortnite's map has changed a lot over its 10 seasons. Is it about to be replaced?

More Action Games

This Year's Scariest Halloween Costume? Movie Sonic

Ruin Trick-or-Treating for everyone with one easy purchase!

Apex Legends Halloween Event Release Date - All the New Halloween Skins So Far

This guide covers the Apex Legends Halloween event release date, as well as all the new Halloween event skins we've seen so far.

Monster Hunter World Rajang - Track and Kill the Rajang, All Rajang Armor Sets

Here's our guide on tracking and killing the Rajang in Monster Hunter World, including all Rajang armor sets.

Destiny 2 Shadowkeep Exotics List - All New Exotic Weapons and Armor for Shadowkeep

This is our guide to all the new Shadowkeep Exotics, including weapons and armor, featured in Destiny 2 Shadowkeep.