Super Mario Odyssey Surpasses Super Mario Galaxy in Every Area... Except One

Super Mario Odyssey Surpasses Super Mario Galaxy in Every Area... Except One

You've made a bunch of wonderful worlds, Nintendo. Let me live in them.

Need help capturing enemies, beating bosses, or moon-gazing? Check out our Super Mario Odyssey guides.

Comparing Super Mario Odyssey to Super Mario Galaxy is like comparing water to air. I need both in my life; there's no question about it. Take either one away, and I'll shrivel into a husk and blow away on the next strong breeze.

Dramatics aside, it's important to hold a game studio's best works against each other. Doing so grants us insight into how the studio's development process has changed over the years. We also get to see how a newer work improves over an older one-and the ways in which it degrades, too.

Fancy hat-loving gold Chomps have lost touch with the people. We need a Revolution.

While there are a couple of small things I prefer in Galaxy over Odyssey (Mario's movements feel a little more fluid, possibly due to the frequent instances of low-gravity environments), I generally find Odyssey the more interesting game of the two. I appreciate the constant changes in scenery, and the endless checklist of things to hunt. However, there's one category where Galaxy pounds Odyssey into the ground: Story.

Story is such a minor thing in mainline Mario games, it's almost silly to lodge a complaint whenever Nintendo skimps on it. But as it turns out, once you have a taste of competent storytelling in a Mario adventure, it's hard to turn back. Super Mario Galaxy's storybook interludes-completely optional side-quests that let the player learn the history of the demi-goddess Rosalina-narrate a simple but very sweet story that makes it impossible not to like the space-faring newcomer.

Unfortunately, the connection we're allowed to feel with Rosalina in Galaxy is a rare moment. Mario series creator Shigeru Miyamoto, is notoriously anti-story with Mario games. He told Wired in a 2009 interview, "With the Mario games, you don't need to have such a complicated setting where you have these particular characters with complicated backstories that can weigh down the bright and fun feel of the game."

No-a time for the sadness! Woo hooo!

Putting aside how Mario Galaxy contains some of the most colorful, whimsical, and imaginative settings Nintendo has ever created despite the existence of Rosalina's story book, Rosalina's gradual revelation benefits Galaxy's pace. You wrest a few Power Stars free from Bowser's control, return to the ship and unwind with story time, then go out and do it all again.

Mario is a long series with a very crowded cast list, but Rosalina's storybook helped cement her as a favorite character. Rosalina's speedy adoption into the fandom fold proves well-executed storylines can be beneficial to the series, not detrimental.

Miyamoto's fears about seeing the Mario universe hobbled by meandering stories aren't baseless, but he should put more faith into the Mario series' current producer, Yoshiaki Koizumi, who slipped Rosalina's story past him. Koizumi coined Rosalina's story, and directed its telling. He's built lore for Zelda games, including the story of Hyrule's Three Goddesses. He clearly knows how to weave a good tale.

Mario Odyssey does allow itself some interesting bits of trivia, e.g. the T-Rex is a female (uh, until Mario possesses her, I guess?).

Mario Odyssey suffers just a touch from Miyamoto's hesitance to let his series deliver a narrative. Mario travels to different lands in this game and meets different races previously unknown to us. He meets sentient caps that live in a foggy, London-inspired town drenched in moonlight. He races with rotund seal pups that shelter from the worst of their cold environment in an underground warren. He fights bunny rabbits who dual-wield careers as wedding planners and assassins, and as I pointed out yesterday, that's amazing. He travels to a metropolis overseen by the woman who was there when it all started. But whenever I said "I'd really like to know more about these people," I was usually denied.

Am I the only one who wants to know how Pauline went from "Imperiled maiden shrieking for help on top of a construction girder" to "Mayor-Queen of an endless city?" I can't be. And heck, I want to know more about that kingdom. You know the one I'm talking about.

That's not to say there aren't moments when Mario Odyssey lets me lean in and get a better look at its people. The level maps designed as travel brochures are a delight, and the NPCs occasionally say things that tell me more about the lands they live in (you'll be OK, Sad Bus Stop Guy in New Donk City). Still, I wish Nintendo trusted itself enough to tell another story like Mario Galaxy's-and I wish it trusted us enough not to get bored by text boxes with more than ten words in them.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Nadia Oxford

Staff Writer

Nadia has been writing about games for so long, only the wind and the rain (or the digital facsimiles thereof) remember her true name. She's written for Nerve, About.com, Gamepro, IGN, 1UP, PlayStation Official Magazine, and other sites and magazines that sling words about video games. She co-hosts the Axe of the Blood God podcast, where she mostly screams about Dragon Quest.

Read this next

The 25 Best Nintendo Switch Games

Our rotating list of the best games on Switch, now updated for the Nintendo Switch Lite release!

Best Video Games for Kids in 2019

If your children are starting to show an interest in video games, this list of family-friendly games should be on your shopping list. Best Kids PS4 Games, Family Xbox One Games, Child-Friendly Switch Games

Super Mario 64 Hack Mod De-Makes Super Mario Odyssey's Sand Kingdom

Welcome to the new Sand Kingdom! Watch out for sharp edges.

New Video Outlines the Crazy Fast History of Super Mario Odyssey Speedruns

Super Mario Odyssey hasn't been around for long, but it's already been the home of some amazing speedruns.

Super Mario Odyssey and The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild are Getting VR Updates for Labo

Both games will get free updates to add VR content in time for Nintendo Labo VR.

More Articles

What's Your Favorite Console Revision?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | The Switch Lite is out today, so let's look back on the history of console revisions.

What's Your Favorite Dreamcast Game?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | With the Dreamcast turning 20 this week, let's talk about our favorite Dreamcast games.

A PSA for the USG Community: Why We're Wiping Our Comments Archive

A note from the editor on why we're scrubbing the comments.

What's Your Favorite SNES Game?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | With Nintendo Switch Online boosting its library, tell us about your favorite SNES game.