Super NES Classic Reviews Game by Game #10: Secret of Mana

Join us as we review every Super NES Classic game. Next up: A real gem of an action-RPG that has some rough edges.

Review by Nadia Oxford, .

Join us as we review all the games on the SNES Classic Mini Edition in chronological order!

Out of all the games on the SNES Classic Edition, I think Square-Enix's Secret of Mana will deliver the hardest nostalgia-punch to players. Its soft colors, restful music, and straight-forward fairy-tale plot all embedded themselves in my soul when I first played the game at 15, and I doubt I'm alone. Hearing the whale-call on the title screen still whisks me back to high school fast enough to give me whiplash.

Everyone has their comfort games they retreat to when they've had a hard day at work, and need an electronic blankie. Secret of Mana is one of mine. I've played this action-RPG classic more times than I can count, which makes it possible for me to appreciate every nook and nuance.

It also means I'm intimate with Secret of Mana's flaws, and I love dissecting them in the company of anyone who'll listen.

Secret of Mana's development history is gonzo, but it's a unique kind of craziness that was only possible during the '90s. The industry was in upheaval as developers waffled between keeping their games on cartridges, or making the jump to CD storage. Sega already had its Sega CD add-on, and Nintendo planned to answer back with its own CD add-on for the SNES (and that's a gonzo story by itself).

"I live here you jerk."

Secret of Mana was initially planned for the "Nintendo PlayStation," but when the add-on was canned, Squaresoft had to perform major surgery on its game to make it fit on a Super Famicom / SNES cart. Some of the cut content became Chrono Trigger down the road, but the game we're talking about now is the journey of a young outcast boy who finds a sword lying in a puddle, picks it up, and dooms the world.

"I...put my hands around it and pulled, basically?"

Secret of Mana carries the heart and soul of The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past. You take up a variety of arms and swing them at foes who get up in your business on your journey to save the world from a power-hungry Empire. Along the way, you learn magic spells (offensive and defensive), meet friends who help you fight, and journey through deserts, tundra, and sacred forests. You even meet a white dragon who carries you on its back, and these flights make lovely use of the Super Nintendo's Mode-7 capabilities.

But even though Secret of Mana is as imaginative as A Link to the Past, it lacks its mentor's solid form. There are a lot of bugs, possibly a consequence of the game being cut up and stitched together to fit on an SNES cart. Worse, the AI that controls your secondary characters is dumber than rocks, and it will often put said characters behind rocks. You can only progress as a team, so prepare to backtrack often and clear away blockages.

We've got moogles!

Frankly, travelling with your companions in Secret of Mana is a bit like travelling with a dim-witted friend who somehow keeps slamming the seat of their pants in every door you pass through. Unsticking them time and time again is irritating, but hey, they're your friend and you love them. The SNES version of the game lets two flesh-and-blood players take up the reins in place of the game's feeble AI, but that requires a Multitap accessory, and I doubt the SNES Classic Edition supports chunks of third-party hardware. At least the console comes with a second controller, so there can be two of you to cut away obstructive bushes and grass from the third idiot.

Secret of Mana also has one hell of a difficulty spike early in the game when you're expected to take on a boss character with the apt name "Spiky." This monstrous jerk of a tiger can deal huge damage, jump out of range, and stun-lock you. Here's a tip: Use the bow and arrow to reach him when he leaps on the towers. Otherwise, pray. I have no idea why Squaresoft decided to make this fight so hard – it's one of the hardest in the game, honestly – and I expect it's a dropping-off point for a lot of frustrated players.


It's a shame, because what Secret of Mana lacks in its systems, it more than makes up for in its graphics, sound, and even its characters. The Pure Lands you visit towards the end of the game still ranks as one of my all-time favorite RPG dungeons. It carries a solemnity and awe that rises above the rest of the "Good Guy vs Bad Guy" struggle ongoing outside its green borders.

And, despite Secret of Mana's simple story, there's a fun chemistry brewing between its characters. The male hero (Randi) is primarily interested in saving the world, while the female sidekick (Primm) is chasing after her kidnapped boyfriend. There's no forced romance between the two, which is nice, and it's also nice to see a woman character on a quest to rescue a man. It was rare to see two platonic friends of the opposite sex quest together for different reasons in the '90s, and unfortunately, it's still rare today.

Secret of Mana is a game that's best enjoyed with a pair of rose-tinted glasses, but I think newcomers will find a lot to love despite the adventure's flaws. Give it a thorough playthrough – if you can push past that damn tiger.

Secret of Mana's bugs and poor difficulty balance at the start of the game keep it from rubbing shoulders with the very best the SNES Classic has to offer, but gosh darn, it might be one of the most charming games on the system.

4 /5

Super NES Classic Reviews Game by Game #10: Secret of Mana Nadia Oxford Join us as we review every Super NES Classic game. Next up: A real gem of an action-RPG that has some rough edges. 2017-08-08T20:45:00-04:00 4 5

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Comments 22

Comments on this article are now closed. Thanks for taking part!

  • Avatar for theinternetisodd #1 theinternetisodd A year ago
    i've been replaying this game lately and my kids adore watching me play it, i'm sure largely due to the bright vibrant colors, incredible character/enemy design and enthralling soundtrack (the ost is also often requested during long car rides). they refer to spikey as "that mean witch's nasty tiger pet" which is pretty dang accurate.

    i also have a very specific memory of being in a boss fight, entering the menu, turning up the volume on the old crt tv i had in the room i shared with my older brother, and leaving it like that for hours while i did my chores. it was awesome.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for SargeSmash #2 SargeSmash A year ago
    While the game is indeed a bit rough around the edges, I don't know if I even cared or noticed all that much when I first played it. I absolutely remember reading the multi-issue Nintendo Power coverage, which didn't help me contain my envy very much as a non-SNES owner at the time...
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Vonlenska #3 Vonlenska A year ago
    This isn't my favorite Mana game (anyone who knows me has heard me gush about some aspect of Legend probably more than they'd like), but it's still one of my favorite games. It has its flaws, but the music and art are beautiful, the world is uniquely weird and it just has a certain adorable, whimsical, bucolic charm. It was the thing that made me really pay attention to games in the first place.

    Also, confession time. The AI getting stuck behind things is definitely an annoyance, but when a friend and I played the game as children we found a creative way to vent our frustrations. There's a little closed-in area in the moogle village where you can block the only entrance/exit. And NPCs can be pushed around. So, yeah, we jailed the entire village. Sorry moogles.Edited 2 times. Last edited August 2017 by Vonlenska
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Roto13 #4 Roto13 A year ago
    I liked this game but I could never get that into it. I wish we'd gotten Seiken Densetsu 3, though.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Dorchadas #5 Dorchadas A year ago
    I played the game for the first time last year and I loved the graphics, loved the music, and hated everything else. The cuts from the surgery were just too obvious.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for riderkicker #6 riderkicker A year ago
    I still wait for the day you and Kat can set up Netplay for some two player adventuring.Edited August 2017 by riderkicker
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for SatelliteOfLove #7 SatelliteOfLove A year ago

    Them kids have good taste.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for NiceGuyNeon #8 NiceGuyNeon A year ago
    I tried playing this game on my phone and got about halfway through before the novelty that I was playing JRPGs on my phone wore off. Part of me wants to give it another go because I did thoroughly enjoy what I played, but part of me is also like, but yeah there are other games to play....
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for VotesForCows #9 VotesForCows A year ago
    @Vonlenska Its good to make villagers fear you when you're an RPG hero(ine).
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Nuclear-Vomit #10 Nuclear-Vomit A year ago
    The game has the two best enemies in a RPG... The Duck Soldiers: Mad Mallard and Captain Duck.
    They are Badass.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Gamer-Law #11 Gamer-Law A year ago
    Secret of Mana is arguably my favorite game of all time. Yes, it contains many of the flaws that others have noted here, but those are largely superficial imperfections in an otherwise deep and meaningful experience.

    The game's story and character interactions stand the test of time. The characters were well-developed and memorable even decades after the game's release. In fact, many of today's game developers could learn from Secret of Mana.

    Nadia may very well be right--the time and place you are at in life when you first played Secret of Mana may have shaped how you felt about the game. I can remember when it released and how drawn in I was from the outset. I cannot wait to pick up a SNES Classic and experience this gem again.Edited 2 times. Last edited August 2017 by Gamer-Law
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for sylvan #12 sylvan A year ago
    Some of my fondest gaming memories are of my first play-through of Secret of Mana. In fact I think that game is responsible for my long love affair with JRPGs. FF VI and Chrono Trigger just sealed the deal. Despite its bugs and insane difficulty spikes I still think this game is a near masterpiece. Almost nothing quite as creative and inspired as Mana comes out of Japan any more. And the game has had major influences on action RPGs and JRPGs in general.

    I will agree with the ridiculous tiger battle. Actually, all of the boss fights in this game were pretty goddamn tough. But that tiger... no joke that fight basically boils down to luck. So, so worth it though.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for theinternetisodd #13 theinternetisodd A year ago
    @NiceGuyNeon i would 100% recommend playing it on anything that is not a mobile phone/tablet. touch controls + action rpg = sadness. grab it on wii vc and give it a go.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Monkey-Tamer #14 Monkey-Tamer A year ago
    Co-op RPG before it was cool. My brother got it in the 90s and found another copy in a bargain bin at a record store he gifted to me. I'll probably play through this game every few years until I die.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for MARl0 #15 MARl0 A year ago
    Huh, I don't remember there being any difficulty spikes in this game. It's been awhile since I last played it, but I've played through it 5 times over the years.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Pandalulz #16 Pandalulz A year ago
    @Vonlenska I thought i was the only one who liked Legend. Sure it's absurdly easy and systems like crafting are completely pointless, but it's absolutely gorgeous, and I loved how there are a billion ways to complete the game that weren't at all obvious, so many wonderful side stories.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Vonlenska #17 Vonlenska A year ago
    LoM is sincerely one of my all-time favorite games! It looks and sounds beautiful, and the writing is actually pretty strong once you shrug off expectations of a standard JRPG Epic Journey. I like the "short story collection" format; there's a lot more charm and depth to its world and storytelling than it often gets credit for.

    Brownie's new game Egglia is probably as close as we'll ever get to a sequel. I've been playing it off and on for the past week, and it's hitting all the same notes--gorgeous art and music, super charming world and characters, breezy but fun systems.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Pandalulz #18 Pandalulz A year ago
    @Vonlenska I have not heard of Egglia, but I'm looking it up right now.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for warrenzephaniah #19 warrenzephaniah A year ago
    Deleted August 2017 by warrenzephaniah
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Jeremiah-Jones #20 Jeremiah-Jones A year ago
    I'm glad to hear it hasn't aged that badly. I played that game to death as a kid. I actually preferred the weapon system in this game to Legend of Mana's though I played both to death and loved both.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for link2701 #21 link2701 7 months ago
    The PS4 version of Secret of Mana is awesome... Totally recommended!
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for kelsobelso #22 kelsobelso 5 months ago
    Good article. I played it when I was 12 when it first came out, had been reading about it for awhile. I didn't notice any of the flaws in the game at the time though. It's just what it was. I'd rank this as my 2nd favorite SNES game of all time. I only put Zelda ahead of it b/c that game was so polished in design, etc...basically flawless, like Mario 3.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Evavosper #23 Evavosper 4 months ago
    SNES is the best console always. I was read a ton of articles help with dissertation about Super NES Classic game but its incredible much more satisfyingly deep exploration was than all the other stuff. It had so much incredible games. I do want a SNES Classic edition!
    Sign in to Reply