Super NES Classic Reviews Game by Game #13: Super Punch-Out!!

Join us as we review every Super NES Classic game. Today: Do your patriotic duty. Punch a fat clown.

Review by Nadia Oxford, .

Join us as we review all the games on the SNES Classic Mini Edition in chronological order!

I like to think that people who pick up the SNES Classic Edition because they remember loving Super Mario World, Street Fighter II, and Super Mario Kart as a kid will be pleasantly surprised by one other game on the menu: Super Punch-Out!!.

Punch-Out!! is one of those games everyone played on the NES, at least in North America. Mike Tyson's name was attached to the scrappy boxing title for a long time, which did a lot to move copies. People who plucked the game off the shelf for Tyson's name were subsequently delighted to discover one of the best (and one of the most unconventional) 8-bit sports games of all time.

All that love, and yet comparatively few people heard the good word about Super Punch-Out!! for the SNES. To this day, I wonder why. I suppose the lack of Tyson's name on the box was a hindrance – not that his reputation was sparkling through the latter half of the '90s. I'd also guess Super-Punch Out!! was simply overlooked; by the time it launched in September 1994, the SNES' library was bursting with goodies, and a couple of huge releases (Final Fantasy III, Donkey Kong Country) were just up the road.

Never trust a Canadian. Wait--

But with the SNES Classic, Super Punch-Out!! gets another chance. I'm glad for that. It's a gem of a title that's a good deal of fun to bash through.

Super Punch-Out!! looks and plays a touch differently from its NES predecessor, which may cause a small torrent of confused noises to escape the throats of people who aren't overly-familiar with the Punch-Out!! series' history. That's understandable. Super Punch-Out!! is less of a direct sequel to NES Punch-Out!! and more of a console realization of the series' arcade roots.

"How to Win: Don't fight Bald Bull, maybe."

While most of us never got to play Punch-Out!! and Super Punch-Out!! in the arcades (myself included), Super Punch-Out!! on the SNES is a good realization of what the games looked, sounded, and played like on arcade cabinets. A generic player character takes the place of bold Little Mac (my biggest complaint about Super Punch-Out!!, frankly). The upper half of the boxer's body is visible across the lower half of the screen, and the full body of your opponent occupies the upper half. You and your rival beat the snot out of each other until one of you goes down for the ten-count (KO) or is knocked down three times (TKO).

Super Punch-Out!! also hews close to its arcade origins by letting you hulk up via a power meter in lieu of earning Punch-Out!! NES's star punches. The power meter charges as you land successive punches without getting hit yourself. Once it's full, you can unleash powered-up attacks at the cost of a small delay. The meter empties if you're knocked down.

I admit Punch-Out!! NES has a charm Super Punch-Out!! lacks; watching tiny Little Mac literally jump to reach his opponents' jaws is still too charming for words. Super Punch-Out!!'s boxer doesn't exude the same "David vs Goliath" air. He's not a warrior or an underdog. He's just a dude who wants a belt.

If Gabby Jay lands a punch on you, call your mother and apologize for being a failure.

Thankfully, his opponents are an interesting and diverse bunch (stereotypically so, in some regards). As in Punch-Out!! NES, you start with a real weakling. Gabby Jay, whose wavering "Yay!" is supplied by Charles Martinet, is a meat punching-bag who only exists to oil up your gloves with spittle and blood. The challenge quickly ramps up thereafter, however. Most of your opponents fight dirty; they use sticks, flying kicks, and elbows. Masked Muscle, a disgraced luchador, blinds you by spitting in your face like a masked dilophosaurus. What kind of boxing league is this?

The kind that's fun to punch your way through, admittedly. Super Punch-Out!! doesn't take long to mop up once you know what you're doing, but as with other games in the series, learning each fighter's tricks, moves, and tells is an ordeal. You eat a lot of canvas before you're allowed to lay your gloved hands on that final belt.

Is Super-Punch Out!! as iconic as its NES precursor? Not quite. Does its soundtrack lack the iconic themes of the preceding game? Indeed. However, Super Punch-Out!! lets you punch a clown into unconsciousness. That alone makes it an instant recommendation, and a very welcome addition to the SNES Classic line-up.

Super Punch-Out!! purposefully apes the arcade Punch-Out!! titles instead of directly following-up on the NES classic. As a result, Super Punch-Out!! may play a little differently than you'd expect, but it's still a compelling off-the-wall goof-fest that never takes itself seriously. It also has some of the biggest, handsomest sprites drawn for an SNES game. If you missed out on Super Punch-Out!! in '94, it's time to get caught up.

4.5 /5

Super NES Classic Reviews Game by Game #13: Super Punch-Out!! Nadia Oxford Join us as we review every Super NES Classic game. Today: Do your patriotic duty. Punch a fat clown. 2017-08-18T19:40:00-04:00 4.5 5

This article may contain links to online retail stores. If you click on one and buy the product we may receive a small commission. For more information, go here.

Comments 11

  • Avatar for Nuclear-Vomit #1 Nuclear-Vomit 6 months ago
    I got my 2 year old to say "yay" every time I announce out loud "Gabby Jay!"
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for SIGGYZtar #2 SIGGYZtar 6 months ago
    Dang it! Jeremy's review of Metroid was the official one? :(
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for Jaz666 #3 Jaz666 6 months ago
    Another great review. Agree with both the positives and negatives.

    As someone who was prime age and audience for the original release, I can offer my friend's and my reason as to why it wasn't a hit; lack of multiplayer.

    I think we hired it out for a night amd enjoyed it, but just couldn't see the value in a single player only beat em up (they were beat em ups in those days, not fighting games! And double dragon et al were scrolling beat em ups!).

    We had to compare it against the wealth of mulitplayer options abound on Megadrive and SNES at the time, and this just couldn't compete in terms of longevity. At SNES prices in the UK a game had to last at least 3 months!

    I have since gone back and sunk a lot of time in this and I really do love it, but I still agree with pre-teen me in that it really did need multiplayer, or at least other challenge modes, for the time in which it was released.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for BigPrimeNumbers #4 BigPrimeNumbers 6 months ago
    "A generic player character takes the place of bold Little Mac"

    I don't understand this statement. You are still playing as Little Mac in this game. Do you just not like his art in this rendition?

    Anyhow, this is a great game - even better than the original if you ask me. I'm really enjoying these retro reviews!
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for VotesForCows #5 VotesForCows 6 months ago
    Not being associated with Tyson is probably a good thing at this stage!
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for MARl0 #6 MARl0 6 months ago
    I love Super Punch-Out. More so than the NES game (though not quite as much as the Wii game). I played this game so much back in the day.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for BulkSlash #7 BulkSlash 6 months ago
    Despite being much more into the Super Nintendo than the NES I never really took to Super Punch-Out!! I think it was a combination of it feeling a different to the original and the reticence to learn a whole bunch of new tells and patterns for the new fighters. Perhaps I should give it another chance?
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for riderkicker #8 riderkicker 6 months ago
    I gotta git gud.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for MarioIV #9 MarioIV 6 months ago
    Whenever I see Bob Mackey's name I imagine the narrator saying it like Bob Charlie.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for MarioIV #10 MarioIV 6 months ago
    Deleted August 2017 by MarioIV
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for StrwbrryJams #11 StrwbrryJams 6 months ago
    This game was rock-hard for me as a kid (though strangely I did fine on Punch Out!!). Revisiting this on Wii U was a real delight. The variety of the fighters is excellent and once you pick up the rhythm of Piston Hurricane, the rest of the game falls into place.
    Sign in to Reply
  • Avatar for ReyVGM #12 ReyVGM 6 months ago
    @BigPrimeNumbers The player in this game is not Little Mac. He doesn't have a name, actually.
    Sign in to Reply