Telling Lies Review

Telling Lies Review

The spiritual successor to Her Story is a shady investigation into the lives of four liars.

There are a lot of uncomfortable moments in Telling Lies, the latest game from Her Story director Sam Barlow. Moments of intimacy, not intended to be seen by other eyes; moments of confessions. And the squeamish quality of it all does not stop, nor start, there.

Everyone's journey through Telling Lies will be unique. It's a full-motion video (FMV) game, only without the hamminess you usually come to expect with games of the live-action persuasion. It's no longer just Barlow either; now he's bolstered with a co-writer, Amelia Gray, and a much larger team in development team in studio Furious Bee. The four stars of it are all portrayed by actors you've seen from something; like Logan Marshall-Green's star-turning role in last year's indie action hit Upgrade, or Kerry Bishé from the underrated tech industry drama Halt and Catch Fire. Likewise, Angela Sarafyan, here playing a cam girl, is not totally dissimilar to her appearance in HBO's Westworld; Alexandra Shipp, who plays Storm in the recent X-Men movies, electrifies the screen in her scenes. (Shipp and Bishé in particular are standouts.)

Borrowing from Her Story, Telling Lies is a compelling mystery, with many threads to untangle. Your own interests naturally lead you down certain paths; maybe you're driven by politics, or romance, or something out of a thriller. Telling Lies has a little of everything in the lives of these four people, and it's up to you, a person who has recently stolen an NSA hard drive, to sift through two years of footage from their lives to figure out what's going on, and why the NSA was tracking their every whim in the first place. The seedy quality is omnipresent too, whether you're watching someone read a bedtime story to a child or watching a shaky camera at a concert.

You search through footage using a virtual desktop, but you always see a slight reflection of the woman in-game surfing through all the data. | Caty McCarthy/USG; Sam Barlow, Furious Bee/Annapurna Interactive

The more I watched, the more captivated I was by each person's story. Maybe I'd pick up a narrative thread I didn't anticipate; like how I was caught off guard by seeing a video clip dated six months after what I was mostly watching up to that point. But the more I would investigate, the more uncomfortable I felt about it. Diving through these four people's lives feels wrong, and it never really stops feeling wrong.

Much like Her Story, you investigate by searching keywords in a database from an in-game virtual desktop. The first word you search for is "love," automatically. Five videos pop up, maximum. Immediately, it's easy to parse at least one relationship. It's a married couple flirting over a video call, one of whom is out of town on a work assignment. Then you start to pick up on inconsistencies. In another conversation, one person in that couple calls who they're talking to "boo." In my handwritten notes, I scribbled down one short question: "Who is boo?"

Telling Lies streamlines the investigation process from Her Story, making it easier to fall into a rabbit hole. You can pause video clips at any time, click onto any word or phrase in a subtitle, or rewind and fastforward them. When you dive into a video, it always starts playing at the point where the person in the video says the word or phrase you searched for. While scrubbing can get tedious in longer videos—especially with a character silently listening to whoever's on the other side, maybe fidgeting, with not much else action, where even the fastest of the three scrubbing speeds can feel slow—it is great if, say, you only come in a minute into a clip, and want to rewind to the start of it. Toward the end of my playthrough, I found my patience to sit and observe no matter the circumstances wearing thin, and I'd scrub through most clips to get to the information I wanted to mine out.

It's not about just listening and typing in keywords though. It's about watching too. I gleaned many leads just by reading into the background; maybe from a plaque with a character's name, or a character suddenly limping in videos after a certain date. I always take notes when I'm reviewing a game, but my notes for Telling Lies, in retrospect, are almost illegible. It's just words, underlined names and phrases, and the occasional arrow to another word or phrase or name. When I played Her Story way back when, my notes were very much the same way.

As disorganized as my notes sound (and are), my journey through Telling Lies was similarly all over the place. Thanks to the new subtitle system, I would click into a word or phrase that interested me, watch some clips that popped up in the search from it, and keep going. Sometimes I'd have a revelation at the end of my path; other times it felt more or less like, not so much a waste of time, but just some additional flavor.

Even then, I had some slight disappointments. The mysteries at the center of Telling Lies are never quite as gripping as Her Story's core murder mystery. Perhaps, I think, that's just a symptom of Telling Lies' ambitious scope, where political intrigue can live alongside with family drama.

At the start of Telling Lies, the four main characters were strangers to me. Their careers, passions, friends, and even names a mystery. By the end, I felt I knew most of them intimately, in a way that I imagine anyone would feel if they watched and listened to every phone call someone else made, whether it's to a long-distance relationship, or how they confide to a cam girl. I knew their apartments, how they'd act around different people, how certain events traumatized them.

Telling Lies is so packed, that I found myself shocked that it wasn't infinite, in some silly way. There is an obvious endpoint, where the leads in your notes dry up, where the revelations are fewer and farther in between. It's only toward the very end though, and each person's journey there will undoubtedly be unique to them.

By the time I rounded out Telling Lies, it was feeling like a game again, rather than Instagram browsing gone awry. I was typing in random keywords, hoping some new thing would pop up. Nothing came. I had searched all there was to search in these four people's lives, and while I felt accomplished, I felt skeezy too. As a privacy paranoid who already sticks opaque tape over every webcam surface, Telling Lies only made me want to quadruple down on those efforts. And maybe that's the point. Or rather, one of its many points.

Telling Lies feels like it's about four times as big as Sam Barlow's previous game Her Story, and it shows. You feel it not just in the four characters you're sifting through footage of, but in the variety of its videos too: from FaceTime calls to hidden cameras capturing secretive meetings. In Her Story, it was famously easy to go down a rabbit hole of sorts on your own intuition; in Telling Lies, that tendency is mechanized in smart, intuitive ways. When it comes to good interactive mysteries, Telling Lies is among the best you can get.

4.5/5

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Caty McCarthy

Features Editor

Caty McCarthy is a former freelance writer whose work has appeared in Kill Screen, VICE, The AV Club, Kotaku, Polygon, and IGN. When she's not blathering into a podcast mic, reading a book, or playing a billion video games at once, she's probably watching Terrace House or something. She is currently USgamer's official altgame enthusiast.

Read this next

What To Read, Play, and Watch Before Playing Telling Lies

Back at GDC 2019, Sam Barlow filled us in on the syllabus for Telling Lies.

Sam Barlow Takes Us Inside Telling Lies, His Star-Studded Follow-Up to Her Story

Director and writer Sam Barlow breaks down his new mega-ambitious game, Telling Lies.

Her Story Creator's New Game, Telling Lies, Has a Teaser Trailer

Find the first details for Sam Barlow's Telling Lies here.

Final Fantasy 7 Remake Has a Classic Mode For Proper Turn-Based Combat

You don't need to worry about all that newfangled action combat.

Borderlands 3's Endgame Fights for Position Against Destiny 2 and The Division 2

Gearbox is not letting Borderlands 3 getting lost in the MMO shuffle.

What's Your Favorite Dreamcast Game?

COMMUNITY QUESTION | With the Dreamcast turning 20 this week, let's talk about our favorite Dreamcast games.

More Reviews

NHL 20 Review

A conservative update that nevertheless shouldn't be ignored by hockey fans.

NBA 2K20 Review

NBA 2K20's excellence in some areas is marred by an uneven story mode and some major online problems.

Borderlands 3 Review

Leave Pandora behind, as you take to the stars to shoot and loot people on other planets.

River City Girls Review

There's substance in this stylish new game in the River City Ransom universe.

More on iPad

Mega Man’s New Mobile Game is a Partnership with a Pop Band

The short, free game serves as a playable music video for a song by Team Shachi.

Apple Arcade Stealthily Announces Octopath Traveler Devs' Successor, New ChuChu Rocket

And it somehow barely appeared during the actual keynote.

Final Fantasy Crystal Chronicles' Remaster is Hitting Early Next Year

You'll be able to ditch those GBA-to-GameCube link cables early next year.

More Adventure Games

Ring Fit Adventure for Switch is Wii Fit With a Story Mode

Nintendo's new fitness product is an adventure game first, with fitness challenges and minigames on the side.

Starting Screen | Why I Ignored the Dreamcast 20 Years Ago

I was a teenage Debby Dreamcast Downer.

Monster Hunter World Iceborne Master Rank - How to Increase Your Master Rank Quickly

There's a new Master Rank level in town for Monster Hunter World Iceborne, and here's how to increase it quickly.