The 2DS XL is More Proof That 3D Was Kind of a Bust for Nintendo

The 2DS XL is More Proof That 3D Was Kind of a Bust for Nintendo

OPINION: Seems Nintendo and 3D never truly needed each other.

Psst. Hey kid. Want to buy a Nintendo 2DS? Before you answer, look at this trailer for the New Nintendo 2DS XL. Mmm. So sleek and smooth. Looks good enough to eat, right?

"Buzz off, Nadia," you tell me, "and take that weird-smelling trenchcoat with you. I already have a Nintendo 3DS, and I think it's stupid that Nintendo is making another model of the stupid old system when it's having enough trouble keeping up with demand for the Switch."

Editor's pick

Should You Buy Dragon Quest VIII for the Nintendo 3DS?

Fair enough. But the reveal of the New Nintendo 2DS XL tells us a couple of things about Nintendo's long-lived family of handhelds. First, demand for the Nintendo 3DS is still surprisingly hot. The little machine seemingly sold out during Christmas 2016, and became very hard to find into the new year. Last winter, I did an online search of Amazon, GameStop, Wal-Mart, and other major retailers for the 3DS, and came up nearly empty-handed. New stock is finally on its way, and I guess Nintendo was slow to re-stock because it decided to perform a system revision first.

Second, if the New Nintendo 2DS XL is the Nintendo 3DS's final form [insert Frieza cackle], then its lack of a 3D feature is very telling. I'd go so far as to suggest the initial selling point for the Nintendo 3DS – its glasses-free 3D display – is a bust.

I don't blame Nintendo for initially getting swept up in the 3D hype. In 2009, back when the Nintendo 3DS was probably in development, 3D was a hot ticket thanks to James Cameron's Avatar movie. By the time the 3DS hit the market in 2011, 3D hype was already deflating – and news reports about how the Nintendo 3DS's 3D display might hurt your kids' eyes didn't endear many parents to Nintendo's system, or to 3D tech in general.

Fast-forward to today. Most movie theatres are (thankfully, thankfully) cutting way back on 3D showings for major titles. I can't remember the last time I turned up my 3D tuner on my 3DS; some newer 3DS games, like Dragon Quest VIII, lack 3D support altogether. James Cameron's Avatar is far behind us, and few people look back at 3D movies and televisions with any sort of warmth. Luckily, the 3DS wound up garnering a great library of games that pushed it up and carried it beyond the deflated 3D bubble.

A few 3DS games, like A Link Between Worlds, were a bit easier to navigate with 3D visuals, but it was never a necessity.

Making a Nintendo 3DS sans the 3D slider is a big cost-cutting measure for Nintendo, but it also says the system's 3D feature was never popular enough to become the system's primary identifying trait. Many developers found clever ways to use the DS's dual screens and lower touch screen, but the 3DS's 3D capabilities never evolved beyond being a cool visual trick that people would try out once before forgetting about altogether.

To be sure, I was blown away by the 3DS's glasses-free 3D back in the day. I also quickly learned it's an exclusionary gimmick. I have terrible eyesight, and the 3D effect gives me a headache; even though I like the 3D pop-out, I can't use it for long. In the same vein, people who are unable to "see" 3D images (like my mother, who is blind in one eye) wound up paying extra for a function they could never use, at least until Nintendo rolled out the 2DS. And that was seemingly designed with young kids in mind, i.e. users who weren't supposed to be looking at 3D images until their eyes developed fully.

So here we are at the very end of the 3DS's growth cycle, and what we have is a compellingly slim clamshell-style system that lacks the ability to project 3D. Living things evolve and adapt according to their environments, and the New 2DS XL demonstrates how consumer products similarly evolve and adapt according to people's needs.

(Seriously though, you want one? I have, like, 20 under this trenchcoat.)

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Nadia Oxford

Staff Writer

Nadia has been writing about games for so long, only the wind and the rain (or the digital facsimiles thereof) remember her true name. She's written for Nerve,, Gamepro, IGN, 1UP, PlayStation Official Magazine, and other sites and magazines that sling words about video games. She co-hosts the Axe of the Blood God podcast, where she mostly screams about Dragon Quest.

Related articles

We Received Another Reminder This Week That Delays Don't Help Crunch⁠—They Add to It

THIS WEEK IN THE BUSINESS | While a new console generation means change is in the air, some trends, like rampant crunch, remain unfortunate industry staples.

Masahiro Sakurai Made Fools of Us All With One Subtle Gesture Before the Byleth Reveal

Sakurai has a twisted sense of humor, and he's not afraid to use it.

WoW's Visions of N'Zoth May Not Be Enough To Keep Players Satisfied Until Shadowlands

The theme is strong with this patch, but the content might not keep players engaged.

Calling Persona 5 Scramble a Spin-Off Doesn't Quite Do It Justice

Persona's take on the musou sub-genre is more of a sequel than fan-service.

You may also like

Dying Light 2 Delayed Out of Spring 2020

The latest game to be delayed out of early 2020.

Disintegration's Technical Beta Launches Next Week

The two betas: Technical, and Open.

After Nearly a Week, Destiny 2's Corridors of Time Puzzle Has Been Solved

One final route through the maze has surfaced.