We Return to the First Anthem Trailer: Comparing What Was Promised Versus What We Got

Two years later, we see how Anthem stands up to its E3 reveal trailer.

It's been almost two years since Electronic Arts and BioWare showed off the first gameplay trailer for Anthem. The trailer came during E3 2017, the gaming industry's marquee event, and Anthem made an impact. It was slick showcase of a brand-new world for BioWare fans to play in, powered by unique flying exosuits called Javelins.

Like many early trailers though, that trailer wasn't indicative of the final product. Some of this is understandable, as graphics gets optimized for the average system instead of a top-of-the-line rig. Some trailers are more of a statement of purpose, as characters pull off moves that are impossible within the actual confines of gameplay mechanics. And some trailers are outright lies, like the infamous Killzone 2 teaser for E3 2005. Where does Anthem's trailer fall in this estimation?

Tarsis Feels Like Home

Right from the beginning, the Fort Tarsis in the trailer is a lively, amazing setting. The Freelancer pulls back a brightly colored curtain to reveal an amazing future bazaar. People think about purchases while store vendors try to hawk their wares. The camera pans up to show a giant mechanical Strider walking just outside the bazaar area. It establishes not only the scope of Fort Tarsis, but also gives it a sense of life.

In-game, there's next to no crowd noise in Fort Tarsis. Most vendors sit by quietly, doing nothing. Occasionally, you'll hear citizens get into conversations, but if you stop to listen until they finish talking, they'll end up staring at you like the Children of the Corn. The trailer shows the Freelancer approached by an NPC, who warns her of trouble on the horizon. It's a mission, but delivered so well; there's a feeling like the Freelancer is helping a person, not just getting a mission from a quest giver.

The Fort Tarsis bazaar in the live game. | Mike Williams/USG, BioWare

The Javelin loading platform is visually exactly the same. The trailer shows an "Ally of the Week" marker, which isn't present in the final product, but that's a small change. Another change is it looks like originally all of your Javelins would be present on the loading dock, instead of the center slot being occupied by whatever your current chosen Javelin is.

Once the Freelancer steps out to the edge of Fort Tarsis, we see the the world of Anthem stretching out in front of us. Visually, there's definitely been some graphical optimizations, but the final version of Anthem still look very good. It's interesting to see content icons as the camera pans over the landscape: these still exist in Anthem, but only once you get close enough to certain world event content.

Just You and The Open World

The Freelancer's Javelin leaps off the platform and goes into flight mode, which feels largely the same in the live versions. There's some extra graphical polish and cinematic pizzazz, like the animal herd that goes stomping by, but nothing feels out-of-place in the current game. Flight and running animations look largely the same, though flying lack the overheating mechanic. Also, I've yet to see an Ursix in a world event, let alone one fighting against a group of Howlers.

The user interface pops up once the Freelancer gets into combat with a group of Scar. It's different from the live version, occupying the center of the screen rather than being shuffled off to the right. Otherwise, combat looks much the same. Once again though, the trailer shows visible, floating location markers, which aren't available in the live game.

I wish I could equip stuff. | Mike Williams/USG, BioWare

One big change pops up at around 4:25 in the gameplay trailer. For one, world events don't feel as common in Anthem's Freeplay as they are in this trailer, but I can chalk that up to providing a heightened sense of what Anthem was supposed to be. The big difference is the Freelancer notes a world event and says that's probably part of the mission she just received. Anthem's mission system prevents this kind of flow: if you load into a mission, you can only really tackle the objectives of that mission, and mission content doesn't appear in Freeplay. The Strider falls here in real-time, which doesn't happen in current Anthem, though there are world events that see you helping Strider-bound citizens.

At around 5:20 in the trailer, another major shift occurs. The Freelancer picks up a legendary rifle called Jarra's Wrath, and equips it immediately. None of this is possible in live Anthem. First, items gained in missions, Strongholds, or Freeplay don't resolve into actual weapons and gear until you get to the mission complete screen. Second, there's no way to equip weapons or armor mid-mission, because you can only change loadouts in The Forge.

The trailer ends with Cataclysm storm, a bit of content that's not in-game yet, but is coming soon. Interestingly enough, the Freelancer calls in two other player for the content, but I don't think that's possible in live. If they were in Freeplay, there'd be two other random players in the open-world already, matchmaking to add team members would have to be done prior to launching the mission.

I mean, flying is still the same. | Mike Williams/USG, BioWare

Was the Trailer a Lie?

I wouldn't call Anthem's gameplay trailer an outright fabrication or lie. Judging from the animations, I'd say there's some actual gameplay within the trailer itself that maps onto the live game almost directly. The specifics of playing were certainly remixed and changed within the last two years, but the trailer is closer to what Anthem is than say the Killzone 2 teaser. I'd call it an "enhanced" version of the final game, much like the E3 2012 Watch Dogs reveal. There are some thing in the Anthem gameplay reveal that I wish were in the final production, like a more seamless open world or the ability to equip weapons on the fly.

I'm left wondering what happened here? What led to all on the cutbacks in Fort Tarsis? Why did BioWare drop a more traditional open-world, where missions and world events can be tackled together, for the mission structure we see in the final product? Why the change in being able to equip new gear out in the field? It's a bunch of changes that lead to a vastly different experience.

I'd say this Anthem was actually indicative of whatever BioWare had at the time. Yes, it's more graphically intensive than the final product, but that's to be expected. Fort Tarsis looks to have taken more of the cuts, moving of a setting with verve and life to it, to the slow, plodding, lifeless version in live. I wish the final product was more indicative of this trailer, with missions and quest givers offering the same type of interactions shown here. Alas, that's not the game BioWare is releasing worldwide tomorrow. It looks similar, but the gameplay reveal trailer just has more magic to offer. I'd like the dream over the reality.

Tagged with Bioware, Electronic Arts, MMOs, Opinions, PC, PlayStation 4, Shooters, Xbox One.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Read this next

Starting Screen | Why 2019 Has Thus Far Been an Underwhelming Year for Games

After being spoiled for two solid years, we've hit a major lull. Will it get better in the second half?

BioWare Still "100% Committed to Anthem" After Key Devs Leave to Work on Dragon Age 4

Anthem remains a focus for BioWare, even as Dragon Age 4 development begins.

"[Crunch] Is Killing People. Something Has to Change"

THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | Once again, gaming headlines are dominated by the industry's shabby treatment of its workers.

BioWare Delays Major April Updates for Anthem to Prioritize Overall Health of the Game

Cataclysm gets delayed so BioWare can focus on core issues.

How the Frostbite Engine Became a Nightmare for EA in General, and BioWare in Particular

DICE's engine finds a rough reception at other EA studios.

"We Have a Saying: At Ubisoft You Always Have a Second Chance"

THIS WEEK IN BUSINESS | What lesson should we take from the shooter-looter's dysfunctional creation, how does Ubisoft deal with failure, and why are used games suffering?

BioWare Admits Toxic Workplace Problems "Are Real" Following Damning Anthem Development Report

After days of silence, BioWare admits to problems at its studio to employees.

More Opinions

The Castlevania Anniversary Collection is Good, but Still Has a Couple of Chipped Fangs

We break down the positives and negatives of Konami's latest effort to cater to the vampire hunter dwelling within you.

Who Needs a New Splinter Cell When You Have This VR Stealth-Action Kayak Game

Phantom: Covert Ops, a new Oculus Quest and Rift S game, elevates a baffling premise to silly fun.

Starting Screen | Why 2019 Has Thus Far Been an Underwhelming Year for Games

After being spoiled for two solid years, we've hit a major lull. Will it get better in the second half?

Madden 20 Franchise Mode is Finally Getting Something It's Needed for Ages: Narrative

A closer look at the Scenario Engine, which could make Madden's franchise mode feel more alive than it has in years.

More on PC

WoW Classic vs. Modern: What Has Changed Over the Past 15 Years

With WoW Classic's beta in full swing, we take a look at the early leveling experience in beta and the current WoW.

Dauntless Monsters List - All the Dauntless Behemoths and Their Weaknesses

This is our guide to every Dauntless monster, including Behemoth weaknesses, locations, and more.

Minecraft Earth Beta Release Date, and How to Get the Free Minecraft Earth Skin

Minecraft Earth beta release date, price, platforms and more are revealed. We've got all the info.

Lego Batman 3 Codes and Cheats - Lego Batman 3 Beyond Gotham

Here’s all of the Lego Batman 3 Beyond Gotham Cheats and Codes you’ll ever need to know.

Report: Riot Games Working With Tencent To Develop Mobile League of Legends

But it's not likely you'll be destroying Nexuses on the go this year.

Fortnite Fortbytes List - All Fortbyte Challenges and Rewards

Fortbytes are brand new to Fortnite Battle Royale for Season 9, and there will be new Fortbyte challenges available to find every day.

Dauntless Best Weapons - Swords, Axes, Repeaters, Chain Blades, Hammers, War Pikes Guide

Our full Dauntless weapons guide, containing information on swords, axes, chain blades, hammers, war pikes, and the best weapons in Dauntless.

More MMO Games

WoW Classic vs. Modern: What Has Changed Over the Past 15 Years

With WoW Classic's beta in full swing, we take a look at the early leveling experience in beta and the current WoW.

What The Division 2 Dark Hours Raid Gets Right And Wrong on Console, According To Those Who Beat It

"It's doable," according to the few players who have managed to do so.