The Reset Button: Waiting for the Dust to Settle in Hearthstone's New Metagame

Some people tinker with and invent new strategies. Other people are like Kat.

The newest Hearthstone expansion launched today, kicking off an entirely new metagame with a host of new cards and the Standard and Wild modes.

It's a big moment for Hearthstone. In retiring a large number of powerful cards, Blizzard is pretty much blowing up two years worth of established decks and strategies. It will still be possible to play with Dr. Boom and company in Wild mode, but the Standard mode will be totally different - no more Goblins vs. Gnomes or Curse of Naxxramas. The reset button has been hit.

New cards! ... Are they any good?

In moments like these, when everyone is experimenting and chaos reigns, a few things tend to happen:

  • A handful of popular teams or decks immediately emerge. Sometimes they herald a new archetype, and sometimes they're just a gimmick that will quickly go away. The trick is figuring out which concepts have staying power.

  • A few of the most hyped cards end up becoming very popular or have their weaknesses exposed. Back when Pokemon Diamond first arrived, Rampardos was getting enough hype with its Mold Breaker ability that I decided to make the effort to train one. That was a mistake, though, as it was a glass cannon with no speed, and its best attack had wicked recoil. Beyond that, I didn't take into account the rise of revenge kill moves like Aqua Jet and Mach Punch, which were pretty much guaranteed to kill Ramparados even if I gave it a Choice Scarf. Needless to say, I kind of regretted the time and effort spent on Rampardos.

  • In Hearthstone, meanwhile, cards will routinely be heralded as gamebreaking in the months and week leading up to release, then discarded when players collectively discover that they're too slow, require too much support, or that there are better alternatives. Anyone remember Troggzor the Earthinator?

  • The metagame starts to settle a bit as everyone figures out what works and what doesn't work, at which point I realize that I'm missing half the cards I need to build a viable deck in constructed play.

  • The community comes to a concensus about overpowered and underpowered strategies and starts making a wishlist for the next expansion. Rinse and repeat.
Rampardos. Whoops.

Not surprisingly, the players who are most willing to go against the grain are the ones who tend to thrive in this sort of unsettled environment. They're the ones with the firmest grasp on the actual mechanics, and they're the ones who are the most willing to go outside the box and try out a card with no hype. Invariably, everyone else winds up following the lead of these players, which becomes the basis for the competitive metagame.

I wish I could say that I was one of those players. I wish I could say that I was the person who, say, had her name attached to a deck that she invented. Alas, I'm not. Instead, I make up for my lack of creativity by trolling Hearthpwn, Reddit, and various streams for deck ideas, like everyone else. I'm in my element when I'm effectively executing on established concepts, which is tough in the chaos of launch - one reason that the deck creators are champions and I'm not.

Does that make me a bad player? Maybe. The best thing that can probably be said for me is that I tend to avoid the really exploitive stuff in favor of strategies that I find legitimately fun and interesting. I almost never go hard rush or hard stall, and I tend to abhor gimmicks, preferring instead balanced strategies that let me play with a variety of characters. In waiting for everything to shake out, I'm mostly waiting to see what's viable so that I can implement it into my strategy. In the meantime, I'm mostly keeping my powder dry, waiting to see how things develop before I commit to any one deck.

Regardless, it's a fun moment for Hearthstone. No one likes when a competitive games gets stagnant, even copycats like me. Even now, the best players are churning through the new cards in Whispers of the Old Gods in search of a winning edge, and it won't be long before they start dominating the ladder. I look forward to seeing what they come up with.

Tagged with Analyses, Blizzard Entertainment, whispers of the old gods.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Read this next

Hearthstone Saviors of Uldum Release Date, Trailer, Plague Cards, and Quests

Get all the info on the upcoming Saviors of Uldum expansion for Hearthstone.

Hearthstone Swaps Around Classic Set, But Initial Reactions Seem Mixed

The new cards are getting a lukewarm reaction online.

From Candy Crush to Hearthstone: How the Loot Box Bill Could Affect Some of the Industry's Biggest Games

The bill defines microtransactions and loot boxes, but questions remain.

How Warcraft's Art Has Evolved and Shaped Blizzard's Games Over 25 Years

Blizzard senior art director Samwise Didier takes us through the 25 year evolution of Warcraft's art.

Hearthstone Rise of Shadows Cards, Decks, Factions, Single-Player - Hearthstone Expansion Guide

All the details on the Hearthstone Rise of Shadows expansion, out now for Blizzard's card battling game.

BlizzCon Dates Revealed With Three Pricey Ticket Options

The convention is expanding this year, and so are some ticket prices.

More Analyses

A Fresh Look at New Super Mario Bros. U on Switch: Does it Measure Up to the Classics?

Where does New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe rank alongside Super Mario Bros. 3 and Super Mario World?

The State of Destiny 2 After Forsaken: A Game That Can't Shake Its Troubles

Forsaken was a solid start, but it wasn't enough to pull everyone back.

Sorry Pokemon Fans, Your Gold-Plated Cards from Burger King Aren't Worth Squat

Burger King's Pokemon cards from 1999 look kind of nice and they're fun to remember, but they're barely worth the cost of a milkshake.