The State of MLB The Show: Where the Series Sits Going Into MLB The Show 17

The State of MLB The Show: Where the Series Sits Going Into MLB The Show 17

It's baseball season!

Some of us root for teams that regularly lose 90 games (glares at the Twins), but plenty of other people are legitimately excited for baseball season. And, as usual, MLB The Show is the best possible way to experience the sport as a videogame.

On March 28, Sony San Diego will be kicking off the baseball season with the release of MLB The Show 17, bringing with it the usual array of new features. But where does the series sit going into the new year? That's an excellent question.

So pretty.

What MLB The Show Does Well

MLB The Show has been probably the most accurate sports simulator since the days of the PlayStation 3 (not counting spreadsheet sims like Out of the Park Baseball and Football Manager). Sony San Diego nailed The Show's physics simulator and animation sometime ago, and it's apparent in the way the ball leaves the bat and players field the ball. MLB The Show just feels "right" in a way that no other sports sim, absent maybe NBA 2K, quite manages.

MLB The Show's feeling of authenticity is aided by its spectacular graphics. The Show has long had some of the best-looking, most accurate stadiums around, and its character models are always excellent. Sony likes to treat The Show as a kind of graphical showcase, which is evident in the attention lavished on its visuals.

In all honesty, the overall look and feel of MLB The Show hasn't changed a huge amount over the years, but Sony has nevertheless managed to layer in a number of useful tweaks. The ability to lock on to a single hitter or pitcher, for instance, makes games go much more quickly. Likewise, the sometimes-maligned Quick Counts, which drop you into the middle of an established count, help the pacing considerably.

More recently, the bulk of Sony San Diego's attention has gone to building out Diamond Dynasty, the game's Ultimate Team mode, making it significantly more enjoyable. But for Sony San Diego, improvement has long come in degrees, with little tweaks here and graphical upgrades there. Still, the overall experience has been consistently strong, pleasing even the staunchest of baseball purists.

Editor's pick

MLB 16 The Show PlayStation 4 Review: Building a Diamond Dynasty

Where MLB The Show Struggles

The flipside of Sony San Diego's conservative updates is that Road to the Show and Franchise mode have gotten, well, kind of stale. Both are very straight-ahead modes with very few frills outside of the elaborate celebration animations. MLB The Show has nothing approaching NBA 2K's excellent presentation or FIFA's emergent storytelling, anything resembling a narrative being buried under loads and loads of stats, which is a problem with baseball in general (no, I don't hate fancy stats, leave me alone).

MLB The Show's franchise mode has long been deep but kind of dry.

Some of MLB The Show 16's new features were likewise hit or miss. Last year's edition brought with it a "Showtime" mechanic that made it easy to paint the corner for a strike, but ultimately did little for hitting. It should be mentioned that pitching has always had a major advantage over hitting in The Show, in part because the latter requires considerably more skill. It's one of a handful of issues that Sony San Diego has wrestled with for years now, with only marginal improvement.

Speaking of which, MLB The Show's commentary is still really bad, adding almost nothing in terms of narrative or flourish to the overall experience. It's been the same for years, which leads me to think that Sony San Diego has made a calculated bet that most people don't actually care about commentary unless it's especially grating or inaccurate. Again, this is another area where Sony San Diego's conservative approach to MLB The Show's updates are apparent.

Mostly, Sony San Diego is aware that they have a small but extremely dedicated audience of baseball purists, and their updates are geared toward keeping those fans happy. For everyone else, MLB The Show is an amazing but dense and inaccessible graphical showcase. But at least the online play has improved over the years.

This Year's Outlook

After all the talk about conservative updates, there are signs that MLB The Show is going all out with this year's version. Sony San Diego signaled their intentions early on by putting Ken Griffey Jr. on the cover in a seeming bid to recall the time NBA 2K featured Michael Jordan. Among its additions is Retro Mode—a special feature that serves as a tip of the hat to the classic Ken Griffey Jr. Presents Major League Baseball, and which should serve as a warm nostalgia trip for baseball fans.

Road to the Show also appears to have been livened up a bit with in-game cutscenes and conversations with important figures like your agent. Called "Pave Your Path," it will feature a lot more interactions that will influence your overall career, adding a bit more of a roleplaying element to the otherwise staid experience. Franchise Mode, meanwhile, takes a page from Madden's excellent Play the Moment with "Critical Situations," which drops you into key moments that will decide each game. This may the year that I finally have the patience to play through an entire season without breaking down and simming to the playoffs.

I'd be remiss if I didn't add that the PlayStation 4 Pro is out now, and with MLB The Show being a first-party Sony franchise (and a graphical showcase to boot), it's apt to take advantage of all of the platform's bells and whistles. If you're a baseball fan and you haven't invested in a fancy new 4K set, this may be the year.

Looking at The Show 17's feature set, it seems apparent that Road to the Show has received the biggest boost, with Pave Your Path finally, finally, finally bringing it up to the level of other modern superstar modes. Will it be enough? We'll see. But either way, this sure looks like one of the most ambitious updates MLB The Show has seen in years.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Kat Bailey

Editor in Chief

Kat Bailey is a former freelance writer and contributor to publications including 1UP, IGN, GameSpot, GamesRadar, and EGM. Her fondest memories as a journalist are at GamePro, where she hosted RolePlayer's Realm and had legal access to the term "Protip." She is USgamer's resident mecha enthusiast, Pokemon Master, and Minnesota Vikings nut (skol).

Read this next

One of Epic's Flagship Exclusives is Coming to Steam

Supergiant's Hades aiming for v1.0 sometime next year.

Life Is Strange 2, Episode 4 Review

Life Is Strange 2's penultimate episode is an emotional one.

New Trials of Mana Footage Shows Cleaner, More Accessible Fights

Let's have a good clean fight, Mana fans.

Microsoft Contractors Reportedly Heard You Talking to Your Kinect

The listen-ins were apparently meant to improve the service.

The Fire Emblem: Three Houses Student Ranking Thunderdome: 34 Students Enter, Only Shamir Leaves

We have no favorites among Three Houses' characters, except for the ones that are our favorites.

More Analyses

A Fresh Look at New Super Mario Bros. U on Switch: Does it Measure Up to the Classics?

Where does New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe rank alongside Super Mario Bros. 3 and Super Mario World?

The State of Destiny 2 After Forsaken: A Game That Can't Shake Its Troubles

Forsaken was a solid start, but it wasn't enough to pull everyone back.

Sorry Pokemon Fans, Your Gold-Plated Cards from Burger King Aren't Worth Squat

Burger King's Pokemon cards from 1999 look kind of nice and they're fun to remember, but they're barely worth the cost of a milkshake.

More on PlayStation 4

Life Is Strange 2, Episode 4 Review

Life Is Strange 2's penultimate episode is an emotional one.

New Trials of Mana Footage Shows Cleaner, More Accessible Fights

Let's have a good clean fight, Mana fans.

GTA 5 Cheats

Discover all the GTA 5 cheats with this handy GTA 5 cheats PS4, GTA 5 cheats Xbox One, and PC guide. Plus get all the GTA 5 cheats for Xbox 360 and PS3.

All Mortal Kombat 11 Characters and Future DLC Fighters

Here's our full Mortal Kombat 11 characters guide, including the current roster, and all forthcoming DLC characters.

Death Stranding is a Game About Walking, Apparently

Someone has finally played Death Stranding and can tell us what its all about.

Cyberpunk 2077 Producer Details Law Enforcement and the Rich Areas of Night City

There are no cops in the poorer districts. That all changes when you get to the affluent areas of Night City.

Remnant From The Ashes Tips and Controls

If you’re playing Remnant From The Ashes, you’ll need these essential tips.

More Sports Games

NBA 2K20 is Still Very Committed to Switch: "The Flexibility Can't be Matched With That Console"

FIFA is scaling back on Nintendo's platform, but for the moment, Visual Concepts is here to stay.

NBA 2K20 Finally Tackles the VC Microtransaction Grind: "We Didn't Want People to Feel [...] Trapped in This Grind Anymore"

Virtual Currency is here to stay, but at least the grind will be less painful this year.

FIFA 20 Release Date - Gameplay Changes, Cover Star, FIFA Volta, PC Specs

We’re right on the cusp of the reveal for FIFA 20. Here’s what we know so far.

Mario & Sonic at the Olympic Games Has a Nostalgic Throwback Mode

Watch Dr. Robotnik scamper like in the good ol' days!