Total War Warhammer is the Creative Refresh the Series Needs

Total War Warhammer is the Creative Refresh the Series Needs

Kat explores the new Total War game launching on May 24 and likes what she finds.

Pairing Total War and Warhammer almost feels too obvious in a way. Though cast partly in real-time, Total War has always had that massive wargame feel to it - a look that can't help evoking Warhammer's famous miniatures. Given how ubiquitous Warhammer has become in the video games space, my only question is what took so long for these two properties to finally unite.

The union between Total War and Warhammer is partly what has spurred me to finally get serious about this series. I've dabbled in the past, but whether because I didn't care as much about ancient warfare, or because my PC wasn't up to snuff, I never got that far. Warhammer, though, is squarely in my wheelhouse; and happily, Total War does a great job of staying true to the spirit of that universe.

It begins with the factions, each of which has their own objective, playstyle, and built-in enemy. If you play as the Dwarves - the most straightforward of the four races available out of the box (with a fifth that can be purchased as DLC) - you battle the Greenskins pretty much out of the gate, your main task being to unite the disparate Dwarven factions. By contrast, if you play as the Greenskins, you have to be almost constantly looting and pillaging lest your minions become bored and unruly.

Faction diversity has always been something that Total War has done particularly well, and it fits Warhammer - a game where players automatically self-identify with particular races - like a glove. Right from the beginning it strives to put you in a particular race's mindset, opening with a handsome cutscene and an epic voiceover, then patiently explaining their unique mechanics. The Dwarves step into battle almost immediately as they try to clear Greenskin invaders from their lands. The Empire is in a more balanced position, relying more on diplomacy than the sword in the early game as they try to build an empire, but are soon hit hard by the Total War equivalent of the White Walkers - Chaos. As for the Vampire Counts, they're more the cloak and dagger types, being focused on spreading corruption throughout the land.

As usual, the strategy portion of the game is interesting, but it mostly exists in the service of the big showpiece battles that have long set Total War apart from its competition. On these battlefields, thousands of soldiers clash in an arena-like battlefield, looking like so many ants as they merge together and hack away at one another. Unlike the strategy portion of the game, which is turn-based, Total War's battles are real-time, albeit much slower than your average StarCraft match. They are meant to evoke the epic clashes of Lord of the Rings or Game of Thrones, with individual units comprising dozens of soldiers bearing banners and yelling war cries. It is the focal point of Total War, and the area in which it is most similar to Warhammer.

Which is not to say that the strategy portion of Total War is totally without merit. As you expand your empire, you have to balance income with happiness while building up a strong army, which becomes tougher the larger you get. Cities are already established - no building towns from scratch in this one - with construction being limited to a couple expansion slots, so you have to think carefully about what buildings you want to add. Pubs can be great if your population is unhappy, trading posts provide extra income, and various mines and training centers will afford you special materials needed to build up your army.

Each faction also has their Lords - powerful heroes that serve at the head of their respective armies and bring with them their own special skill tree. Lords are extremely powerful in Total War Warhammer, frequently being able to take on several units by themselves, and their defeat is usually key to breaking an army and sending it fleeing. In that light, properly utilizing your lord and equipping them with the right items - there are some pretty strong RPG elements in Total War Warhammer - is paramount.

From an accessibility standpoint, it's all very well laid out and constructed, making it easy to quickly grasp the various forces at work within your empire and start experiencing success. Creative Assembly has been working on this particular series for a long time now, and their experience shows. It's nice that they now have some new territory to explore.

New Frontiers

In the long run, Warhammer is just what Total War needs to get some much-needed momentum. The series certainly has its diehards in the strategy community, but it stumbled out of the gate a bit with the problematic Total War Rome 2, then got a little bit too niche with Attila. Historical nerds may feel that Creative Assembly and Sega are selling out in partnering with Warhammer, but I personally couldn't be happier to see the series going in this new direction.

As always, Total War occupies its own niche in the strategy game landscape. If Civilization is all about building up an empire across hundreds of years, and Paradox is about historical fan fiction, then Total War is more for the type of people who listen to Dan Carlin's Hardcore History podcast and think about Mongol military tactics. It has some decent diplomacy options, including the ability to forge conferederations and trade deals, but combat is inevitable. That's why Warhammer is such a good fit for Total War.

On the flipside, Warhammer brings its own very specific flavor to Total War. Personally, I prefer the dystopian sci-fi of Warhammer 40K to Warhammer Fantasy, but there's no denying the appeal of Lord of the Rings-like battles and the allure of RPG elements. Total War even brings with it a quest system of sorts for your army that will net your Lord some pretty choice loot.

I'm not scoring Total War Warhammer because I haven't spent nearly enough time with it to do it justice - each faction is almost an entire game unto itself - and I haven't had time to jump into multiplayer. That said, I've enjoyed my extended foray into the Total War universe, and I'd be interested to dive a little deeper into each faction and see what Total War Warhammer looks like after a 30 hour campaign. As it is, if you like strategy games but you haven't tried out Total War yet, this seems like a pretty good entry point. And if you're a longtime fan and you're feeling burned out, this refreshing take is probably just what you need.

Sometimes we include links to online retail stores. If you click on one and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. See our terms & conditions.

Kat Bailey

Editor in Chief

Kat Bailey is a former freelance writer and contributor to publications including 1UP, IGN, GameSpot, GamesRadar, and EGM. Her fondest memories as a journalist are at GamePro, where she hosted RolePlayer's Realm and had legal access to the term "Protip." She is USgamer's resident mecha enthusiast, Pokemon Master, and Minnesota Vikings nut (skol).

Read this next

Total War: Warhammer II Executes Surprise Attack By Releasing This Year

Creative Assembly is ready to drop the sequel to last year's Total War: Warhammer.

Total War Heads to a "Brand New Era" Next

After tackling the fictional Warhammer universe, Creative Assembly is moving forward, not back.

Warhammer is the Breath of Fresh Air that Total War Needs

Plus other observations on Total War: Warhammer.

Disco Elysium: How to Find All Four Pieces of the Fairweather T-500 Ceramic Armor

We show you how to find the hanged man's armor hidden across Martinaise.

Doom and Doom 2 on Console Are Getting Free Classic Map Pack Add-Ons

Bethesda says "hell yes" to bringing Final Doom to consoles.

These Super Mario Maker 2 Link Power-Up Levels Show How Ingenious a Zelda Maker Could Be

The bar for Master Sword mastery is really, really high.

For Axiom Verge's Creator, the Switch Was a "Natural Platform" For the Sequel

Thomas Happ answers our most pressing questions about today's announcement.

More Reviews

Shovel Knight: King of Cards Review: This Crown Belongs to Another

King of Cards is the most ambitious Shovel Knight game to date, but it's not quite the best.

Shovel Knight Showdown Review: A Sneaky Contender for 2019's Best Party Game

An excellent arena battler that transcends Shovel Knight's boundaries in unexpected ways.

Life Is Strange 2 Series Review: Brothers, A Tale of Two Wolves

Life Is Strange's sequel has wrapped up, so our journey with Sean and Daniel has come to an end.

Phoenix Point Review: Still Trying to Rise

XCom creator Julian Gollop returns to the genre he helped kick off, with uneven results.